The Work Competence of General Practitioners Working in Shanghai’s Community Health Services: A Cross-Sectional Study based on Self-assessment

Tianhao Wang, Xueying Ru, Yuan Zhang, Xiangjie Zhang, Jian Gong, Limin Lao, Junling Gao, Zhigang PanResearch 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Background: The aim of the study was to investigate the work competence of General Practitioners (GPs) in community health services (CHS) in Shanghai, China. Methods: A questionnaire was designed based on a previous capacity evaluation indicator system. We adopted a stratified and proportional cluster sampling method in this self-assessment and cross-sectional study. We collected data on GPs' demographic variables and work competence—categorized into patient care ability, teaching ability, communication skill, and coordination ability—using the questionnaire. Results: A total of 2,954 GPs were sampled from 116 CHS in Shanghai. The median scores for patient care ability, teaching ability, and communication/coordination skills were 80, 76, and 80 on a scale of 100, respectively. GPs aged 30-39, those in urban CHS, and those with teaching experience or training scored higher in patient care. Teaching ability scores were higher among those with 5-20 years of experience and those in training CHS. Conclusions: While GP competence in Shanghai largely meets daily practice requirements, there is significant room for improvement in teaching ability.

Introduction

As China transitions toward a primary-care-centered medical model, the role of the General Practitioner (GP) has expanded beyond simple diagnosis to include education, team leadership, and coordination. However, China lacks a universally acknowledged model to measure these multi-faceted competencies. Most existing studies are limited by small sample sizes or a narrow focus on clinical knowledge. This paper provides a comprehensive "health check" on the GP workforce in Shanghai—one of China’s most developed medical hubs—to identify where the current training pipeline succeeds and where it fails to produce well-rounded community health leaders.

Methods and Data

The researchers conducted a cross-sectional study using a self-designed questionnaire validated through two rounds of Delphi expert consultation.

Sampling and Framework

The study employed a stratified and proportional cluster sampling method across 116 Community Health Service (CHS) centers in Shanghai, ensuring a representative mix of urban/rural locations and training/non-training facilities. Competence was divided into three pillars:

  1. Patient Care Ability: (16 indexes) covering public healthcare, common disease diagnosis, and clinical skills.
  2. Teaching Ability: (10 indexes) focusing on knowledge transfer and pedagogical skills.
  3. Communication & Coordination: (4 indexes) including interpersonal skills and management.

Participant Demographics

The study generated a primary dataset from 2,592 eligible GPs (a 99.9% response rate). The sample was majority female (58.9%), mostly aged 30–39 (49.2%), and largely university-educated (79.2%).

Demographic characteristics of the GP sample (N=2592)

Key Results

Overall median scores were 80 for patient care, 76 for teaching, and 80 for communication/coordination. Specific findings include:

  • Urban vs. Rural: GPs in urban CHS centers generally scored higher in patient care than their rural counterparts.
  • Professional Title: Higher professional titles (senior vs. primary) were strongly associated with better communication and coordination scores, suggesting these "soft skills" are gained through clinical seniority.
  • Training Status: The study tracked various professional factors, including whether GPs worked in training-designated CHS or had received standardized GP training.
Professional background and training status of the surveyed GPs

Discussion: Insights and Paradoxes

The "Teaching Gap"

Teaching ability was the lowest-scoring domain (median 76/100). Notably, 25% of GPs reported being "unwilling to spend time in teaching," citing high workloads and low rewards. This suggests a systemic bottleneck: if current GPs are disincentivized from teaching, the quality of the next generation of doctors is at risk.

The Standardized Training Paradox

In a counter-intuitive finding, GPs who underwent "standardized training" actually scored lower in patient care and communication than those who did not. This may be because these three-year programs spend significant time in large hospitals and only one year in community centers, potentially leaving trainees disconnected from the specific nuances of community-based patient trust and management.

The 30-39 "Sweet Spot"

GPs in their 30s scored highest in patient care. This group represents the "main force" of the CHS—young enough to have received modern medical education but experienced enough to have mastered clinical application.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The study acknowledges that self-assessment bias is a limitation; GPs might over-report their abilities. Furthermore, Shanghai's resource-rich environment means these findings may not generalize to less-developed regions of China.

Future Work: The authors call for a shift from self-reported surveys to objective clinical assessments. They also recommend a curriculum overhaul for GP standardized training to include more "soft skill" training (communication, management) and more dedicated time within community health centers rather than large-scale hospitals.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background: The aim of the study was to investigate the work competence of GPs in community health services(CHS) in Shanghai, China. Methods: A questionnaire was designed on the basis of a previous capacity evaluation indicator system. We adopted a stratified and proportional cluster sampling method in this self-assessment and cross-sectional study. We collected data on GPs demographic variables and work competence which was separated as patient care ability, teaching ability, communication skill and coordination ability, using the questionnaire. Results: A total of 2954 GPs were sampled from 116 CHS in Shanghai. The median score of patient care ability, teaching ability, communication skill and coordination ability were 80[70-88.75], 76[60-80] and 80[70-85] on a scale of 100, respectively. GPs who were 30-39 years old, worked in urban CHS, and participated in GP trainer’s training or had teaching experience got higher scores in patient care ability. GPs who worked for 5-20 years in CHS, worked in training CHSs and participated in GP trainer’s training program had higher scores in teaching ability. As for communication skill and coordination ability, GPs who were older than 30-39 years old and with a senior professional title, worked in training CHS, participated in GP trainer’s training and had teaching experiences in CHS got higher scores. Conclusions: The work competence of GPs in Shanghai’s CHS largely meets the requirements of daily practice, but there is still great improving space in the aspect of teaching ability.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2021work,
  author = {Tianhao Wang and Xueying Ru and Yuan Zhang and Xiangjie Zhang and Jian Gong and Limin Lao and Junling Gao and Zhigang Pan},
  title = {{The Work Competence of General Practitioners Working in Shanghai’s Community Health Services: A Cross-Sectional Study based on Self-assessment}},
  booktitle = {Research},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-805729/v1},
}
Figure