The winners and losers of land use intensification: pollinator community disassembly is non‐random and alters functional diversity

Romina Rader, Ígnasi Bartomeus, Jason M. Tylianakis, Étienne LalibertéDiversity 2014 · DOI

Introduction

As global landscapes are increasingly converted for agricultural use, the resulting loss of biodiversity has become a primary concern for conservationists and agronomists alike. However, the impact of land-use change is not merely a numbers game. While counting the number of species (taxonomic richness) provides a baseline, it often fails to capture the ecological consequences of biodiversity loss. The real-world impact on ecosystem services, such as pollination, depends on functional diversity—the variety of roles species play and the specific traits they possess.

In a study conducted in the Canterbury region of New Zealand, researchers investigated how pollinator communities "disassemble" as land use intensifies. Their findings suggest that agricultural intensification acts as a selective filter, systematically removing species with specific traits and leaving behind a functionally "thin" community that may be less resilient to future environmental shocks.

The Study: A Gradient of Intensity

To understand the dynamics of community disassembly, the researchers sampled 24 sites across four distinct land-use types, representing a gradient of increasing human intervention:

  1. Native Gardens: Low-intensity environments with diverse vegetation.
  2. Blackcurrant Orchards: Moderate-intensity perennial systems.
  3. Dairy Farms: High-intensity pastoral systems with significant soil compaction and biomass removal.
  4. Rotational Cropping: High-intensity annual systems characterized by frequent tilling and chemical inputs.

Over the course of a year, the team collected 23,509 individual insects representing 25 species (14 native and 11 introduced). Each species was scored across ten functional traits, including body size, social behavior, diet breadth, and larval feeding requirements.

Non-Random Disassembly: The Filtering Effect

A central question of the research was whether species loss in disturbed habitats is random or predictable. By using nestedness analysis (NODF), the researchers found that pollinator communities in intensive agricultural sites are largely subsets of the communities found in more diverse, low-intensity sites. The observed nestedness score (79.01) was significantly higher than what would be expected by chance (59.81).

This confirms that community disassembly is non-random. As land use intensifies, the environment acts as a filter that systematically excludes certain species while allowing others to persist. This "filtering" effect means that the most sensitive species are lost first, rather than a random selection of the community.

The Profiles of Vulnerability

The study identified clear "winners" and "losers" based on their functional traits:

The "Losers"

Species most susceptible to land-use intensification typically shared several key characteristics:

  • Large Body Size: Larger insects often require more resources and may have specific nesting requirements that are disrupted by farming.
  • Solitary Behavior: Unlike social species that can share resources and labor, solitary pollinators are more vulnerable to localized disturbances.
  • Narrow Diet Breadth: Specialists that rely on a limited range of floral resources are easily displaced when those specific plants are removed.
  • Non-Floral Larval Requirements: Species whose larvae require specific habitats, such as decaying wood or parasitic hosts, are often the first to vanish when those niche habitats are cleared for crops or pasture.

The "Winners"

The species that dominate high-intensity landscapes, such as rotational cropping fields, tend to be small-bodied, social generalists. This includes introduced species like the honey bee (Apis mellifera) and certain bumble bees (Bombus terrestris). These species are highly mobile and can utilize a wide variety of floral resources, making them more resilient to the simplified landscapes of modern agriculture.

Functional Erosion and Ecosystem Resilience

The most striking result of the study was the impact on functional richness. As sites moved from low-intensity gardens to high-intensity cropping, functional richness plummeted by 83%.

Crucially, in the most intensive sites, functional richness was lower than what would be expected even given the decline in species numbers. This suggests that intensification specifically targets species with unique functional roles. While the "functional dispersion" (the spread of traits) remained somewhat stable, the loss of redundant species means the "insurance policy" of the ecosystem is gone. In these thinned-out communities, the loss of even one more species could lead to a total collapse of specific pollination functions.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This research highlights that simply maintaining a high number of individuals (such as honey bee populations) does not equate to a healthy or resilient pollinator community. The systematic loss of large, solitary, and specialized pollinators suggests that intensive agricultural landscapes are becoming functionally impoverished.

While this study provides a robust framework for understanding community disassembly, the authors note that further research is needed to directly link these trait losses to measurable changes in crop yields and wild plant reproduction. Understanding the threshold at which functional erosion leads to service failure will be critical for developing sustainable agricultural practices that support both food production and biodiversity.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Aim Pollination services are at risk from land use change and intensification, but responses of individual pollinator species are often variable, making it difficult to detect and understand community‐level impacts on pollination. We investigated changes in community composition and functional diversity of insect pollinator communities under land use change in a highly modified landscape. Location Canterbury region, South Island, New Zealand. Methods We trapped insect pollinators every month for 1 year at 24 sites across four land use types of increasing intensity in New Zealand: gardens with native vegetation, blackcurrant orchards, dairy farms, and rotational cropping farms. We investigated changes in pollinator species and functional richness and differences in species and functional composition. Results Under increasing land use intensity, both species and functional richness declined markedly. Changes in functional richness, however, were overall not significantly different than expected based on the observed declines in species richness. Nevertheless, there was a significant trend towards greater than expected functional richness within less‐intensive land use types and lower than expected functional richness within intensive land use types. The order of species loss under increasing land use intensity was non‐random, as pollinators with a narrow diet breadth, large body size, solitary behaviour and a preference for non‐floral larval food resources were lost first. Main conclusions Our study shows that pollinator species bearing particular trait attributes are susceptible to differences in land use. Our study suggests that pollination services may be more vulnerable to environmental changes and disturbances in more intensive land use types as a result of lower pollinator functional richness.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{rader2014winners,
  author = {Romina Rader and Ígnasi Bartomeus and Jason M. Tylianakis and Étienne Laliberté},
  title = {{The winners and losers of land use intensification: pollinator community disassembly is non‐random and alters functional diversity}},
  booktitle = {Diversity},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1111/ddi.12221},
}
Figure