Abstract
Foundation species uniquely control associated biodiversity through non-trophic effects, whereas dominant species are locally abundant but are replaceable in ecological systems. Long-term data on ant assemblages at the Harvard Forest Hemlock Removal Experiment (HF-HeRE) and the Black Rock Future of Oak Forests Experiment (BRF-FOFE) provide insights into how ant assemblages change and reassemble following the loss of a foundation species (Tsuga canadensis) or a dominant genus (Quercus). At HF-HeRE, removal of T. canadensis trees resulted in taxonomic and functional shifts in ant assemblages relative to control stands. In contrast, ant assemblages at BRF-FOFE varied little regardless of whether oaks or non-oaks were removed from the canopy. Non-trophic effects of foundation species were stronger than indirect trophic effects on taxonomic and functional diversity of ant assemblages. In contrast, non-trophic effects of dominant species were weaker than indirect trophic effects on ant taxonomic diversity and some measures of ant functional diversity.
Introduction
In ecology, the "insurance hypothesis" suggests that high biodiversity makes ecosystems resilient because different species can step in to fill functional roles if others are lost. However, this assumes species are somewhat interchangeable. This study challenges that assumption by comparing the ecological roles of foundation species and dominant species.
Foundation species, such as the Eastern Hemlock (Tsuga canadensis), are thought to be irreplaceable. They control ecosystem processes—like soil chemistry, light levels, and moisture—through "non-trophic" effects, creating a unique physical environment. In contrast, dominant species are highly abundant but may be functionally redundant, meaning other species can provide similar ecosystem services if the dominant species is lost. This research asks: Does losing a foundation species cause a more dramatic reorganization of biodiversity than losing a dominant one?
Methods and Experimental Design
The researchers utilized two long-term, hectare-scale canopy manipulation experiments in the northeastern United States:
- HF-HeRE (Harvard Forest): Focused on the loss of the foundation species Tsuga canadensis via girdling (simulating pest-induced death) and logging.
- BRF-FOFE (Black Rock Forest): Focused on the loss of the dominant genus Quercus (Oaks) via girdling.
Ants were used as bio-indicators because they are abundant, taxonomically well-understood, and highly sensitive to environmental changes like soil temperature and canopy cover. The team employed the "ALL protocol" (pitfall traps, baits, litter sifting, and hand collection) over a decade. Data were analyzed for Taxonomic Diversity (species richness and diversity indices) and Functional Diversity (mapping 12 traits, such as body size and nesting habits, to see if the ecological roles of the ants changed).
Key Insights: The Uniqueness of Foundation Species
The study found that Hemlock forests create a specific microclimate—dark, cool, moist, and acidic. When Hemlocks die, this unique "physical envelope" vanishes. The non-trophic effects of Hemlocks (shading and soil cooling) were much stronger drivers of ant diversity than indirect food-web (trophic) effects.
In contrast, while Oaks are the most common trees in many forests, they do not appear to create a unique environment that ants specifically depend on. When Oaks were removed at the Black Rock site, other hardwoods provided enough similar environmental conditions that the ant community remained stable. This suggests that Oaks are functionally replaceable by other deciduous trees in this context.
Results
Harvard Forest (Hemlock Removal)
Removing Hemlocks caused significant taxonomic and functional shifts. While Hemlock control stands had the lowest species richness, they hosted unique assemblages (such as Aphaenogaster picea). Logged and girdled plots saw an influx of new species, significantly altering the community structure. Functional shifts were also evident; for example, larger-bodied carpenter ants moved in to exploit the increased coarse woody debris.
Black Rock Forest (Oak Removal)
Ant assemblages varied very little regardless of whether oaks or non-oaks were removed from the canopy. Interestingly, excluding large herbivores (deer and moose) had a significant effect on ant composition in the Oak forest (a trophic effect) but almost no effect in the Hemlock forest, where the tree's physical presence (non-trophic effect) was the dominant force.
Discussion and Limitations
The results suggest that the distinction between foundation and dominant species is vital for conservation and forest management. Foundation species like the Eastern Hemlock provide unique structural roles that cannot be easily filled by other species.
However, the authors note that "foundation status" might be taxon-specific. While ants were largely unaffected by Oak loss, previous research at the same site suggested that mites and springtails do view Oaks as foundation species. This implies that the ecological importance of a species may depend on which part of the biodiversity spectrum is being observed. Future work could extend these observations to other basal species to see if this foundation/dominant distinction holds across different biomes.
Data Accessibility
All data and R code are available from the Harvard Forest Data Archive (datasets HF-118 and HF-097).
Summary updated