The Variability of the Black-Hole Image in M87 at the Dynamical Time Scale
Kaushik Satapathy, Norbert Wex, Feryal Özel, Lia Medeiros, Sean Taylor Dougall, Chi‐kwan Chan, Maciek Wielgus, Ben Prather, George N. Wong, Charles F. Gammie, Kazunori Akiyama, A. Alberdi, Juan Carlos Algaba, Richard Anantua, Keiichi Asada, Rebecca Azulay, Anne-Kathrin Baczko, D. R. Ball, Mislav Baloković, John Barrett, B. A. Benson, Lindy Blackburn, R. Blundell, W. Boland, Katherine L. Bouman, Geoffrey C. Bower, Boyce, Hope A., Michael Bremer, Christiaan D. Brinkerink, Roger Brissenden, S. Britzen, Avery E. Broderick, Dominique Broguière, Thomas Bronzwaer, Sandra Bustamante, Doyoung Byun, J. E. Carlstrom, Andrew Chael, Koushik Chatterjee, Shami Chatterjee, Ming‐Tang Chen, Xiaopeng Cheng, Ilje Cho, Pierre Christian, J. Conway, J. M. Cordes, Thomas O. Crawford, G. Crew, Alejandro Cruz Osorio, Yuzhu Cui, Jordy Davelaar, Mariafelicia De Laurentis, Roger Deane, J. T. Dempsey, G. Desvignes, Jason Dexter, Sheperd S. Doeleman, Ralph P. Eatough, H. Falcke, Joseph Farah, Vincent L. Fish, E. B. Fomalont, H. Alyson Ford, Raquel Fraga-Encinas, Per Friberg, Christian M. Fromm, Antonio F. Fuentes, Peter Galison, Roberto García, Olivier Gentaz, Boris Georgiev, C. Goddi, Roman Gold, Arturo I. Gomez-Ruiz, José L. Gómez, M. H. Gu, Mark Gurwell, Kazuhiro Hada, Daryl Haggard, M. H. Hecht, Ronald Hesper, Luis C. Ho, Paul T. P. Ho, Mareki Honma, Wu Jiang, Huang, Lei, David H. Hughes, Shiro Ikeda, Manami Inoue, Sara Issaoun, D. J. James, Buell T. Jannuzi, M. A. Janssen, Britton Jeter, Jiang, Wu, Alejandra Jiménez-Rosales, Michael D. Johnson, Svetlana G. Jorstad
This paper analyzes the variability of the M87 black hole image using Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) data from 2017. By focusing on closure phases, a robust interferometric observable, the authors identified specific image regions that exhibit minimal variability, suggesting thin, gravitationally lensed rings. This finding helps constrain theoretical models of black hole accretion flows.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) has provided unprecedented images of black holes, revealing their "shadows." However, these accretion flows are expected to be dynamic, with variability occurring on timescales comparable to the observation periods. Understanding this variability is crucial for accurately interpreting the images and using them to test fundamental physics, such as Einstein's theory of general relativity. Specifically, the authors aim to quantify the day-to-day variability in the M87 black hole image during the 2017 EHT campaign and compare it to predictions from General Relativistic Magnetohydrodynamic (GRMHD) simulations. The challenge lies in disentangling true structural changes from instrumental and atmospheric effects, which closure phases help to mitigate.
Methods
The core of the methodology involves analyzing closure phases, which are derived from the visibility data collected by the EHT. Closure phases are particularly useful because they cancel out station-specific atmospheric and instrumental errors. The authors first analyze the 2017 EHT observations to identify which closure triangles (combinations of three telescopes) exhibit low day-to-day variability. They then develop a data-driven model to quantify this variability, accounting for the evolution of closure phases due to the Earth's rotation.
Subsequently, they compare these observed variability patterns to a large suite of GRMHD simulations. These simulations model the accretion flow around black holes with varying parameters, including magnetic field configurations (SANE vs. MAD), electron temperature models, black hole spins, and electron number densities. The GRMHD outputs are then processed through General Relativistic ray tracing and radiative transfer to generate synthetic EHT observations. The variability in these simulated observations is quantified using a metric called the compliance fraction, which measures how often a simulation produces variability consistent with the observed low variability in M87.
Datasets
The primary dataset used is the 2017 Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) observations of M87. The authors also utilize a large library of GRMHD simulations generated by various research groups, covering a wide parameter space relevant to M87.
Key Insights and Ideas
Closure phases are powerful probes of variability: By canceling out instrumental errors, closure phases allow for a more direct measurement of structural changes in the black hole image.
M87's image is remarkably stable on short timescales: The study reveals that certain combinations of telescopes (closure triangles) show very little day-to-day variability (around 3-5°), suggesting a stable underlying structure.
Variability is localized in the Fourier plane: The regions of high variability are strongly associated with baselines that cross visibility amplitude minima. This is a key prediction of theoretical models and provides a direct link between the observed data and theoretical understanding.
Thin, lensed rings are favored: GRMHD simulations that best reproduce the observed low variability are those that produce thin ring-like images, where gravitational lensing effects dominate the structure. This implies less turbulent accretion flows.
Black hole spin and magnetic field configuration have marginal effects on variability: While these parameters are crucial for overall accretion flow dynamics, their impact on the short-term variability of the observed image is less significant than the ring's fractional width.
Key Results
Three out of six linearly independent closure triangles showed very low day-to-day variability ($\sim3-5^\circ$) in the 2017 EHT M87 observations.
Conversely, three other triangles exhibited substantially higher variability ($\sim90-180^\circ$), directly correlating with baselines that probe visibility amplitude minima.
GRMHD simulations indicate that the fractional width of the bright emission ring is the most discriminating characteristic for reproducing the observed low variability. Models with thinner rings (lower fractional width) are favored.
The study found that changing the magnetic field configuration (SANE vs. MAD), electron temperature model, or black hole spin had only a marginal effect on the consistency of the models with the observed variability.
Limitations and Future Work
Systematic errors: While closure phases mitigate many errors, a residual systematic error of $\sim2^\circ$ in closure phase measurements is acknowledged, which is comparable to the observed low variability.
Model degeneracy: The paper notes a degeneracy between electron density scale ($n_e$) and black hole mass ($M_{BH}$) in radiative transfer calculations, meaning that their product is what truly matters for image properties.
Future work: The authors suggest further investigation into the dependence of variability on visibility minima depth and a more detailed comparison of GRMHD simulations with observational constraints beyond EHT data (e.g., X-ray luminosity, jet power). They also highlight the utility of their developed method for exploring black hole image variability and discriminating between models.
Summary updated
Abstract
The black-hole images obtained with the Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) are expected to be variable at the dynamical timescale near their horizons. For the black hole at the center of the M87 galaxy, this timescale (5-61 days) is comparable to the 6-day extent of the 2017 EHT observations. Closure phases along baseline triangles are robust interferometric observables that are sensitive to the expected structural changes of the images but are free of station-based atmospheric and instrumental errors. We explored the day-to-day variability in closure phase measurements on all six linearly independent non-trivial baseline triangles that can be formed from the 2017 observations. We showed that three triangles exhibit very low day-to-day variability, with a dispersion of $\sim3-5^\circ$. The only triangles that exhibit substantially higher variability ($\sim90-180^\circ$) are the ones with baselines that cross visibility amplitude minima on the $u-v$ plane, as expected from theoretical modeling. We used two sets of General Relativistic magnetohydrodynamic simulations to explore the dependence of the predicted variability on various black-hole and accretion-flow parameters. We found that changing the magnetic field configuration, electron temperature model, or black-hole spin has a marginal effect on the model consistency with the observed level of variability. On the other hand, the most discriminating image characteristic of models is the fractional width of the bright ring of emission. Models that best reproduce the observed small level of variability are characterized by thin ring-like images with structures dominated by gravitational lensing effects and thus least affected by turbulence in the accreting plasmas.
BibTeX
@article{satapathy2022variability,
author = {Kaushik Satapathy and Norbert Wex and Feryal Özel and Lia Medeiros and Sean Taylor Dougall and Chi‐kwan Chan and Maciek Wielgus and Ben Prather and George N. Wong and Charles F. Gammie and Kazunori Akiyama and A. Alberdi and Juan Carlos Algaba and Juan Carlos Algaba and Richard Anantua and Keiichi Asada and Rebecca Azulay and Anne-Kathrin Baczko and D. R. Ball and Mislav Baloković and John Barrett and B. A. Benson and Lindy Blackburn and Lindy Blackburn and R. Blundell and W. Boland and Katherine L. Bouman and Geoffrey C. Bower and Boyce, Hope A. and Michael Bremer and Christiaan D. Brinkerink and Roger Brissenden and S. Britzen and Avery E. Broderick and Dominique Broguière and Thomas Bronzwaer and Sandra Bustamante and Doyoung Byun and J. E. Carlstrom and Andrew Chael and Koushik Chatterjee and Shami Chatterjee and Ming‐Tang Chen and Xiaopeng Cheng and Ilje Cho and Pierre Christian and J. Conway and J. M. Cordes and Thomas O. Crawford and G. Crew and Alejandro Cruz Osorio and Yuzhu Cui and Jordy Davelaar and Mariafelicia De Laurentis and Roger Deane and J. T. Dempsey and G. Desvignes and Jason Dexter and Sheperd S. Doeleman and Ralph P. Eatough and H. Falcke and Joseph Farah and Vincent L. Fish and E. B. Fomalont and H. Alyson Ford and Raquel Fraga-Encinas and Per Friberg and Christian M. Fromm and Antonio F. Fuentes and Peter Galison and Roberto García and Olivier Gentaz and Boris Georgiev and C. Goddi and Roman Gold and Arturo I. Gomez-Ruiz and José L. Gómez and M. H. Gu and Mark Gurwell and Kazuhiro Hada and Daryl Haggard and M. H. Hecht and Ronald Hesper and Luis C. Ho and Paul T. P. Ho and Mareki Honma and Wu Jiang and Huang, Lei and David H. Hughes and Shiro Ikeda and Manami Inoue and Sara Issaoun and D. J. James and Buell T. Jannuzi and M. A. Janssen and Britton Jeter and Jiang, Wu and Alejandra Jiménez-Rosales and Michael D. Johnson and Svetlana G. Jorstad},
title = {{The Variability of the Black-Hole Image in M87 at the Dynamical Time Scale}},
journal = {The Astrophysical Journal},
year = {2022},
doi = {10.3847/1538-4357/ac332e},
}