The utilization of medical information systems in future radiation disasters: reflections on a comparison of experiences of utilization between Japan and Taiwan

Chie Kushima, Naoya In, Fu‐Chih Lai, Hiroyuki Hanada, Toshiko TomisawaFrontiers in Public Health 2023 · DOI

Abstract: This paper examines the critical role of medical information systems (MIS) in managing large-scale radiation disasters. By comparing the fragmented, hospital-centric data approach in Japan with the centralized National Health Insurance (NHI) system in Taiwan, the authors argue for a shift toward "e-governance" to improve real-time resource tracking and patient management during emergencies.

Introduction

In the immediate aftermath of a radiation disaster, the speed of medical response is the primary determinant of outcomes. Responders require instantaneous access to data regarding victim locations, hospital bed availability, and the distribution of specialized medical supplies, such as antidotes or blood reserves.

A significant challenge identified in recent history is the siloed nature of medical data. During the 2011 Great East Japan Earthquake and the subsequent Fukushima Daiichi nuclear accident, the Japanese central government struggled to obtain accurate victim counts and locations. Because information was managed locally by individual clinics and hospitals, there was a profound lack of both "vertical integration" (from local to national levels) and "horizontal integration" (between different medical facilities). This structural fragmentation led to delays in care and a chaotic emergency response. This paper explores how Japan might enhance its disaster resilience by adopting elements of Taiwan’s integrated digital infrastructure.

Methodology

This research is presented as an opinion and reflection piece based on a comparative structural analysis. In March 2023, the authors conducted an exploratory visit to Taiwan, engaging with major medical centers—including Linkou Chang-Gung Memorial Hospital and Kaohsiung Medical University Chung-Ho Memorial Hospital—and the Taiwanese Ministry of Health and Welfare (MOHW).

The study contrasts two primary frameworks:

  1. Japan’s Emergency Medical Information System (EMIS): Evaluated through its performance during the 2011 Fukushima disaster.
  2. Taiwan’s National Health Insurance (NHI) System: Evaluated through its performance during the 2014 Kaohsiung gas explosion and the 2015 Formosa water park explosion.

Comparative Analysis of MIS Architectures

The Centralization Advantage in Taiwan

Taiwan’s NHI system serves as more than a billing platform; it is a robust real-time surveillance tool. Every citizen possesses an NHI card, and every healthcare provider is linked to a central database. This allows the government to maintain a live "sketch" of the nation’s medical landscape, including medication stocks and patient histories. The MOHW operates a unified "Situation Center" that aggregates data from volunteer services, insurance claims, the CDC, and disaster supply inventories, enabling multidimensional decision-making.

The Fragmentation Trap in Japan

Conversely, Japan’s medical information is managed autonomously by individual hospitals. While systems like EMIS and G-MIS exist, they often rely on manual data entry by local staff. During a disaster, these personnel are frequently overwhelmed, leading to the information gaps observed in 2011.

Key Results

The systemic differences between the two nations are summarized in the following table, highlighting how daily data management practices directly impact disaster efficacy.

Table 1: Comparison of Medical Information Systems in Japan and Taiwan during Disasters and Daily Operations.

As shown in Table 1, Taiwan’s model allows for centralized management by both local and central governments during both routine operations and emergencies. In Japan, the reliance on manual reporting from local DMAT (Disaster Medical Assistance Teams) to the central government creates a bottleneck that hinders rapid response.

Proactive Preparedness and Future Directions

Despite not having faced a major radiation disaster, Taiwan has proactively integrated radiation-specific protocols into its MIS. This includes the "Orange Code" for staff alerts and designated "red line" isolation routes for contaminated patients, lessons directly informed by Japan’s 2011 experience.

For Japan, the path to a centralized system is obstructed by complex legal and administrative structures. Currently, the Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare (MHLW) manages natural disasters, while the Nuclear Regulation Authority (NRA) oversees radiation emergencies. This "horizontal" disconnect prevents a unified e-governance approach.

Conclusion

The authors conclude that while Japan possesses the necessary cloud technology, it lacks the integrated policy framework required to make that technology effective during a national crisis. Resolving the "integration issue" through vertical policy alignment between municipal and national levels is the most critical factor for improving future disaster response.

Summary updated

Abstract

The utilization of medical information systems in future radiation disasters: reflections on a comparison of experiences of utilization between Japan and Taiwan
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kushima2023utilization,
  author = {Chie Kushima and Naoya In and Fu‐Chih Lai and Hiroyuki Hanada and Toshiko Tomisawa},
  title = {{The utilization of medical information systems in future radiation disasters: reflections on a comparison of experiences of utilization between Japan and Taiwan}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Public Health},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fpubh.2023.1288315},
}
Figure