Issues of Which Organization is Responsible for Hospital Evacuation in Nuclear Disasters

Masaru Ogasawara, Yuta Sato, Katsunori Ito, Kyoji Saito, Katsuhiro Ito, Hiroyuki HanadaPrehospital 2019 · DOI

Abstract

In the aftermath of the Great East Japan Earthquake and the subsequent Fukushima Daiichi nuclear disaster, it was revealed that approximately 10% of hospitalized patients died during evacuations where medical teams were not involved in transportation. This research investigates the evolution of Japan’s nuclear disaster medical system and evaluates whether current organizational structures are sufficient to manage large-scale hospital evacuations. While specialized teams like the Nuclear Emergency Medical Assistance Teams (NEMAT) have been established, significant gaps remain in manpower, training, and clear lines of responsibility for evacuating the Urgent Protective Action Planning Zone (UPZ).

Introduction

The 2011 Fukushima nuclear accident highlighted a critical vulnerability in disaster response: the safe evacuation of vulnerable hospital patients. When residents must evacuate due to high air dose rates, the transition from a clinical environment to a transport vehicle represents a period of extreme risk. Historical data from the Great East Japan Earthquake indicates that the absence of medical oversight during these transfers contributed to a 10% mortality rate among evacuated patients. This paper examines the current state of Japan's nuclear emergency preparedness and the persistent challenges in coordinating mass medical evacuations.

Methodology

This study involved a structural analysis of Japan’s revised medical response framework for nuclear emergencies. The researchers evaluated the capacity, mandates, and limitations of several key organizations:

  • Nuclear Emergency Medical Assistance Teams (NEMAT): Specialized units comprising doctors, nurses, and radiological technologists.
  • Disaster Medical Assistance Teams (DMAT): General disaster response units.
  • Radiation Emergency Medical Assistance Teams (REMAT): Specialized radiation medicine units.
  • Red Cross Relief Teams: Humanitarian medical units.

The analysis focused on the feasibility of evacuating the Urgent Protective Action Planning Zone (UPZ), defined as the area within a 30km radius of a nuclear power plant.

Results: The Current Infrastructure

Since the Fukushima accident, Japan has designated 41 Nuclear Emergency Core Hospitals to serve as hubs for specialized care. Supporting these facilities are 53 NEMAT units. These teams are specifically trained to operate in nuclear disaster scenarios and provide information and support during the acute phase of an emergency.

However, the study identifies a stark contrast between these specialized resources and the broader disaster response network. There are over 2,000 DMAT teams and numerous Red Cross units across Japan. While these groups form the backbone of standard disaster relief, they are currently stipulated not to conduct clinical treatment in high-dose radiation areas. Furthermore, they generally lack specific education regarding nuclear disaster protocols.

Discussion: The Responsibility Gap

The research highlights several critical insights regarding the logistical challenges of current evacuation plans:

1. The Scale Mismatch

The UPZ can house anywhere from tens of thousands to one million residents. In a major nuclear event, several thousand patients may require simultaneous evacuation. With only 53 NEMAT teams available, the ratio of specialized responders to patients is dangerously low. The number of teams qualified and permitted to work in contaminated zones is simply too small to respond to the projected needs.

2. Specialization vs. Clinical Utility

While REMAT teams provide essential expertise in dose assessment and radiation medicine, they often lack emergency physicians. This creates a scenario where a team can measure radiation levels but may not be equipped to provide life-saving clinical care during a high-stress transport. Conversely, DMAT teams have the clinical skills but are barred from the high-dose zones where they are most needed.

3. The UPZ Isolation

Within the UPZ, the entry of supply vehicles and the restoration of lifelines (electricity, water) are strictly limited. This makes "sheltering in place" at a hospital virtually impossible. If a hospital cannot be sustained and the specialized teams are overwhelmed, patients are left in a "responsibility vacuum."

Conclusion

Despite significant structural progress and the creation of specialized nuclear medical units, the fundamental question of which organization is responsible for massive hospital evacuations remains unsolved. The current system relies on a small number of specialized teams that are insufficient for the projected scale of a UPZ evacuation. To prevent a recurrence of the high mortality rates seen in 2011, future disaster planning must bridge the gap between general disaster response and specialized nuclear medicine, while clearly defining organizational leadership for the clinical supervision of patient transport.

Summary updated

Abstract

Introduction: At the time of a nuclear disaster, residents should evacuate from areas with high air dose rate. In the Great East Japan Earthquake, about 10% of patients died in a hospital evacuation in which medical teams were not involved in transportation. Aim: To determine if hospital evacuation improved after the Fukushima nuclear accident. Methods: This research investigates how the medical system of a nuclear disaster in Japan changed. Results: There are 41 hospitals designated as Nuclear Emergency Core Hospitals, and they have 53 Nuclear Emergency Medical Assistance Teams (NEMAT; disaster medical dispatching team specialized in nuclear disasters consisting of medical doctors, nurses, and radiological technologists) that can support hospitals and information in the acute phase. Discussion: At the time of a nuclear disaster, NEMAT is supposed to evacuate residents from the Urgent Protective Action Planning Zone (UPZ; within about 30 km radius). Tens of thousands to one million people live in this area. Hospital evacuation of more than several thousand patients is necessary. The entry of workers for transportation vehicles and lifeline restoration is limited within UPZ, so staying in a hospital is virtually impossible. There are over 2000 Disaster Medical Assistance Teams (DMAT), and many Red Cross Relief Teams; both of which are stipulated not to conduct clinical treatment in high dose areas and are not educated on nuclear disasters. Although there are Radiation Emergency Medical Assistance Teams (REMAT) consisting of doctors and technicians specializing in radiation medicine, they are few in number. They can perform dose assessment, but general medical care cannot be performed because an emergency physician is not included. Therefore, although NEMATs will conduct emergency and hospital evacuation in the affected area, the number of teams is too small to respond. The issue of which organization is responsible for massive hospital evacuation remains unsolved.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ogasawara2019issues,
  author = {Masaru Ogasawara and Yuta Sato and Katsunori Ito and Kyoji Saito and Katsuhiro Ito and Hiroyuki Hanada},
  title = {{Issues of Which Organization is Responsible for Hospital Evacuation in Nuclear Disasters}},
  booktitle = {Prehospital},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1017/s1049023x19003194},
}
Figure