The use of ultrasonic scalpel lowers the risk of post-mastectomy seroma formation in obese women

T. Michalik, Rafał Matkowski, Przemysław Biecek, B. SzynglarewiczJournal of Cancer 2019 · DOI

Abstract

Introduction: Seroma formation (SF) is the most common postoperative complication after mastectomy and axillary surgery. The aim of this study was to assess its incidence and risk factors following a modified radical mastectomy in breast cancer patients. Materials and methods: 271 patients who underwent a modified radical mastectomy (250 with traditional electrocautery and 21 with an ultrasonic scalpel) were studied. The SF rate was calculated and its association with patient-related factors, surgical features and postoperative variables was assessed and statistically analyzed with P<0.05 as a significance threshold. Results: SF was observed in 18% of patients. Patient's age, operating time and number of removed axillary lymph nodes did not significantly differ between SF and non-SF patients. Patients BMI, total drainage amount, number of days with drain were higher and postoperative hospital stay was significantly longer in SF patients (P<0.001 each). The dissection instrument was also an important risk factor: SF developed in 20% of patients operated with electrocautery and in none with an ultrasonic scalpel (P<0.05). The association between surgical instrument and the number of removed lymph nodes, patient's age and BMI was not significant. Dissection with an ultrasonic scalpel resulted in a statistically significant lower total drainage amount. However, it was also related to a significantly longer operating time (P<0.001 each). Conclusions: Risk of SF after a modified radical mastectomy is significantly higher in patients with obesity. Despite longer operating time, using an ultrasonic scalpel is a valuable option in those cases because it lowers the total drainage amount and seems to be an important protective factor against SF.

Introduction

In breast cancer surgery, the recovery process is frequently complicated by seroma formation (SF)—the accumulation of serous fluid in the "dead space" created after a mastectomy and axillary lymph node dissection. While often viewed as a minor complication, persistent seromas can lead to skin flap necrosis, wound dehiscence, and infections, potentially delaying critical adjuvant treatments like chemotherapy or radiation.

The standard surgical tool is electrocautery (EC), which uses high-temperature heat to cut tissue and seal vessels. However, this high heat can cause significant thermal damage and may fail to effectively seal small lymphatic vessels, leading to fluid leakage. This study investigates whether an ultrasonic scalpel (US)—which utilizes high-frequency vibrations instead of high heat—can reduce SF risk, particularly in high-risk obese patients.

Methods and Materials

This retrospective study analyzed 271 breast cancer patients (staged cT1-T3N1) who underwent a modified radical mastectomy at the Lower Silesian Oncology Center in Poland between 2004 and 2017. The cohort was divided into two groups based on the surgical tool used:

  • Electrocautery Group: 250 patients.
  • Ultrasonic Scalpel Group: 21 patients (using the Ultracision system at 55.5 kHz).

Variables tracked included Body Mass Index (BMI), operating time, number of lymph nodes removed, total drainage volume, and duration of hospital stay. Seroma was defined as any clinically evident fluid collection requiring needle aspiration at the surgical site.

Results

Risk Factors for Seroma Formation

Analysis revealed that obesity is the primary patient-related risk factor for seroma. Among patients with a BMI < 30, the seroma rate was only 4%. However, approximately 95% of obese patients (BMI ≥ 30) developed seromas when traditional electrocautery was used. Patients who developed seromas also exhibited significantly higher total drainage volumes and required longer hospital stays.

Table 1: Comparison of clinical and surgical variables between non-seroma (non-SF) and seroma formation (SF) groups.

Impact of Surgical Instrumentation

The choice of dissection instrument proved to be a critical factor. SF occurred in 20% of the electrocautery group but was entirely absent (0%) in the ultrasonic scalpel group ($P < 0.05$). While the ultrasonic scalpel significantly reduced drainage, it came with a trade-off in efficiency: the median operating time nearly doubled compared to electrocautery.

Table 2: Comparison of outcomes between Electrocautery and Ultrasonic scalpel groups.

Discussion and Conclusion

The study supports the hypothesis that ultrasonic scalpels minimize thermal injury and seal lymphatic channels more effectively than traditional electrocautery. This is particularly beneficial for obese patients, where the risk of SF is highest.

Despite the longer operating time (120 minutes vs. 65 minutes) and higher equipment costs, the use of an ultrasonic scalpel appears to be a valuable protective measure. By reducing total drainage and eliminating seroma formation in this cohort, the technology may lower the overall cost of care by preventing complications and shortening hospital stays. Future randomized controlled trials with larger sample sizes are necessary to confirm these findings and conduct a formal cost-benefit analysis.

Summary updated

Abstract

<b>Introduction</b>: Seroma formation (SF) is the most common postoperative complication after mastectomy and axillary surgery. The aim of this study was to assess its incidence and risk factors following a modified radical mastectomy in breast cancer patients. <b>Materials and methods</b>: 271 patients who underwent a modified radical mastectomy (250 with traditional electrocautery and 21 with an ultrasonic scalpel) were studied. The SF rate was calculated and its association with patient-related factors, surgical features and postoperative variables was assessed and statistically analyzed with <i>P</i><0.05 as a significance threshold. <b>Results</b>: SF was observed in 18% of patients. Patient's age, operating time and number of removed axillary lymph nodes did not significantly differ between SF and non-SF patients. Patients BMI, total drainage amount, number of days with drain were higher and postoperative hospital stay was significantly longer in SF patients (<i>P</i><0.001 each). The dissection instrument was also an important risk factor: SF developed in 20% of patients operated with electrocautery and in none with an ultrasonic scalpel (<i>P</i><0.05). The association between surgical instrument and the number of removed lymph nodes, patient's age and BMI was not significant. Dissection with an ultrasonic scalpel resulted in a statistically significant lower total drainage amount. However, it was also related to a significantly longer operating time (<i>P</i><0.001 each). <b>Conclusions</b>: Risk of SF after a modified radical mastectomy is significantly higher in patients with obesity. Despite longer operating time, using an ultrasonic scalpel is a valuable option in those cases because it lowers the total drainage amount and seems to be an important protective factor against SF.
BibTeX
@article{michalik2019use,
  author = {T. Michalik and Rafał Matkowski and Przemysław Biecek and B. Szynglarewicz},
  title = {{The use of ultrasonic scalpel lowers the risk of post-mastectomy seroma formation in obese women}},
  journal = {Journal of Cancer},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.7150/jca.29774},
}
Figure