Sports Bras Improve Chest Keloids but Outcomes Are Dependent on Breast Size: A Retrospective Analysis

Yanting Zhu, Qiguo Zhang, Ting Gong, Peng Zhang, Bo Cheng, Jian Liu, Chao JiFrontiers in Oncology 2022 · DOI

Abstract

This retrospective medical record review was performed on 95 female keloid patients treated with a standard therapy combining complete surgical excision with superficial X-ray radiation. The study aimed to analyze the relationship between breast size and treatment outcomes, as well as the benefits of sports bras in postoperative management. Results demonstrated that the keloid scores of the group not wearing sports bras were significantly worse than those of the sports bra group at a one-year follow-up. Furthermore, patients with larger breast sizes showed the most significant improvement when utilizing sports bras. The findings highlight that continuous wearing of a high-support sports bra effectively reduces skin tension on postoperative incisions and promotes recovery, particularly for patients with larger breast sizes.

Introduction

Keloids are aggressive, benign skin tumors characterized by collagen overproduction that extends beyond the boundaries of the original wound. The anterior chest is one of the most common and challenging sites for keloid formation due to constant skin tension caused by breathing, arm movements, and gravitational forces.

While the current "gold standard" for treatment involves surgical excision followed by superficial radiation, recurrence rates remain a significant clinical hurdle, often hovering around 20%. Recent biomechanical observations suggested a correlation between breast weight and keloid severity. This study investigates the hypothesis that "mechanical offloading"—using a sports bra to mitigate gravitational strain—can significantly improve postoperative outcomes and reduce recurrence.

Methods

Researchers conducted a retrospective review of 95 female patients treated between 2018 and 2020. All participants underwent a standardized treatment protocol consisting of complete surgical excision followed by superficial X-ray radiation (a total dose of 15 Gy administered in three fractions).

Study Groups

  • Sports Bra Group (n=50): Patients were instructed to wear high-support sports bras for at least 20 hours a day for six months following surgery.
  • Control Group (n=45): Patients followed standard postoperative care without the use of specialized sports bras.

Evaluation Metrics

Clinical outcomes were assessed at a one-year follow-up using the Japan Scar Workshop (JSW) Scar Scale 2015. Additionally, researchers calculated a Breast Size Score (BSS) for each patient based on under-bust and over-bust measurements. Patients were categorized into "large" (BSS > 7.7) and "small" (BSS < 7.7) groups to determine if breast volume influenced the efficacy of the intervention.

Results

The implementation of mechanical offloading via sports bras resulted in markedly superior clinical outcomes across several dimensions.

Clinical Scoring

At the one-year mark, the sports bra group achieved a median JSW keloid score of 1, whereas the control group had a significantly higher median score of 3 (p < 0.0001). Patients in the sports bra group exhibited milder erythema, reduced telangiectasia, and significantly narrower scar widths.

Clinical comparison of keloid healing between the control group (without sports bras) and the intervention group (with sports bras) before and one year after treatment.

Impact of Breast Size

The data confirmed a clear correlation between breast size and keloid severity. In the control group, patients with larger breast sizes (BSS > 7.7) consistently showed worse outcomes. However, this same demographic saw the most dramatic improvement when wearing sports bras. By supporting the weight of the breast, the bras effectively neutralized the gravitational tension that typically drives keloid proliferation in these patients.

Discussion

This study frames gravity as a "pathogen" in the context of chest keloids. In patients with larger breasts, gravitational strain can create significant longitudinal skin tension on the chest wall. This mechanical stress acts as a biological signal, triggering fibroblasts to overproduce collagen and leading to the formation of raised, symptomatic scars.

By acting as a mechanical orthotic, the high-support sports bra provides "mechanical offloading." This reduces the physical pull on the surgical incision, allowing the tissue to heal in a low-tension environment. This intervention addresses the root biomechanical cause of recurrence rather than just treating the biological symptoms.

Limitations and Conclusion

While the results are compelling, the authors note that the retrospective nature of the study introduces potential selection bias. Furthermore, the results relied on patient self-reporting for bra compliance. Future prospective, randomized controlled trials are necessary to standardize mechanical tension reduction as a formal component of postoperative keloid management.

In conclusion, the use of a high-support sports bra is a simple, low-cost, and highly effective intervention for female patients undergoing chest keloid surgery. It is particularly essential for patients with larger breast sizes, for whom mechanical tension is a primary driver of poor surgical outcomes.

Summary updated

Abstract

Our study is a retrospective medical record review performed on 95 female keloid patients with the standard therapy combining complete surgical excision with superficial X-ray radiation. We aimed to analyze the relationship between breast size and treatment outcomes as well as the benefits of sports bras in the postoperative management of keloids. The results showed that the keloid score of no sports bra group was significantly worse than the score of sports bra group at 1-year follow-up. In addition, the large breast size group showed more significant improvement of keloid score when wearing sports bras. Our study highlights that continuous wearing a sports bra effectively reduces the skin tension of the postoperative incision and promotes recovery, especially for patients with large breast size.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhu2022sports,
  author = {Yanting Zhu and Qiguo Zhang and Ting Gong and Peng Zhang and Bo Cheng and Jian Liu and Chao Ji},
  title = {{Sports Bras Improve Chest Keloids but Outcomes Are Dependent on Breast Size: A Retrospective Analysis}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Oncology},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fonc.2022.871115},
}
Figure