The Trickle-Down Effect of Leaders’ VWGB on Employees’ Pro-Environmental Behaviors: A Moderated Mediation Model

Jianfei Wu, Weinan Zhang, Chuanhu Peng, Juan Li, Saiyu Zhang, Wenjing Cai, Dan ChenFrontiers in Psychology 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Although previous research has highlighted the positive effect of leaders' voluntary workplace green behavior (VWGB), limited research attention has been given to empirically testing how and when such behavior produces trickle-down effects. Taking a role model perspective and drawing on social identity theory, this research aims to fill this gap by proposing and testing the mechanism and boundary conditions of the influencing processes whereby leaders' VWGB can trickle down to employees' pro-environmental behaviors. By theorizing a moderated mediation model, the current research empirically examines the hypotheses by conducting a hierarchical regression analysis. We employed a survey questionnaire research design to collect two waves of multisource data. The data used in the analysis are from survey responses of 313 subordinate-supervisor dyads at two different time points. The results show that leaders' VWGB can have a trickle-down influence on employees' task-related pro-environmental behavior and proactive pro-environmental behaviors through their green self-identity and that this trickle-down effect is greater among employees with higher green climate perceptions. Our results reveal the intervening mechanism and boundary condition of leaders' VWGB by conducting a systematic examination of how this effect trickles down.

Introduction

While it is well-established that "green" leadership generally leads to better environmental outcomes, the specific psychological "black box" of how and to what extent this influence manifests has remained under-explored. This paper addresses the gap between a leader's discretionary actions—Voluntary Workplace Green Behavior (VWGB)—and the actual pro-environmental behaviors of their subordinates. The researchers sought to determine if a leader’s personal habits, such as recycling or reducing paper waste, actually reshape an employee’s self-identity and whether the organization's overall environmental "vibe" acts as a catalyst or a barrier to this influence.

Theoretical Framework

The study proposes a moderated mediation model grounded in Social Identity Theory. This theory suggests that individuals categorize themselves into social groups and adopt the values of those they perceive as role models within that group. In this context, leaders serve as role models whose voluntary green actions influence the self-concept of their subordinates.

The hypothesized moderated mediation model illustrating the paths from leader behavior to employee outcomes.

Methodology

To test the proposed model, the authors employed a time-lagged, multisource survey design involving 313 subordinate-supervisor dyads from 10 high-star hotels in Anhui Province, China. The hospitality industry was selected due to the increasing importance of "green and competitive" strategies in service-heavy sectors.

Data collection occurred in two waves to reduce common method bias:

  1. Time 1: Employees rated their leaders' VWGB, their own green self-identity, and their perception of the organization's "green climate."
  2. Time 2 (One month later): Direct supervisors rated the employees' actual pro-environmental behaviors.

Key Results and Insights

Identity as the Engine of Change

The core finding is that leaders influence green behavior by reshaping the employee's self-concept. When a leader consistently acts green, employees begin to internalize these values, thinking, "I am the type of person who acts pro-environmentally." The study distinguishes between task-related behavior (eco-friendly actions within one's job description) and proactive behavior (going above and beyond to help the environment). Green self-identity was found to fully mediate task-related behavior and partially mediate proactive behavior.

The "Green Climate" Multiplier

The trickle-down effect is not universal; it is significantly stronger when employees perceive a "High Green Climate." In organizations where policies and procedures clearly value sustainability, a leader's individual actions are amplified. Conversely, in indifferent climates, these actions may be ignored.

The moderating effect of green climate perception on the relationship between leaders’ VWGB and employees’ green self-identity.

Statistical analysis supported all primary hypotheses:

  • Leadership to Identity: Leaders’ VWGB was significantly related to employees’ green self-identity (β = 0.24, p < 0.001).
  • Mediation: Green self-identity robustly mediated both task-related (β = 0.69, p < 0.001) and proactive (β = 0.88, p < 0.001) behaviors.
  • Moderation: The interaction between leader behavior and green climate perception was significant (β = 0.15, p < 0.001), showing a steeper trickle-down effect in high-green climates.

Conclusion

This research demonstrates that leaders' voluntary green habits trigger a powerful trickle-down effect by reshaping employee identity. However, this effect is contingent upon the organizational context. For managers, this suggests that individual role modeling is most effective when paired with clear organizational commitment to environmental sustainability. Future research should explore these dynamics across different industries and within team-based frameworks to further unpack the complexities of organizational greening.

Summary updated

Abstract

Although previous research has highlighted the positive effect of leaders' voluntary workplace green behavior (VWGB), limited research attention has been given to empirically testing how and when such behavior produces trickle-down effects. Taking a role model perspective and drawing on social identity theory, this research aims to fill this gap by proposing and testing the mechanism and boundary conditions of the influencing processes whereby leaders' VWGB can trickle down to employees' pro-environmental behaviors. By theorizing a moderated mediation model, the current research empirically examines the hypotheses by conducting a hierarchical regression analysis. We employed a survey questionnaire research design to collect two waves of multisource data. The data used in the analysis are from survey responses of 313 subordinate-supervisor dyads at two different time points. The results show that leaders' VWGB can have a trickle-down influence on employees' task-related pro-environmental behavior and proactive pro-environmental behaviors through their green self-identity and that this trickle-down effect is greater among employees with higher green climate perceptions. Our results reveal the intervening mechanism and boundary condition of leaders' VWGB by conducting a systematic examination of how this effect trickles down.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wu2021trickle,
  author = {Jianfei Wu and Weinan Zhang and Chuanhu Peng and Juan Li and Saiyu Zhang and Wenjing Cai and Dan Chen},
  title = {{The Trickle-Down Effect of Leaders’ VWGB on Employees’ Pro-Environmental Behaviors: A Moderated Mediation Model}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2021.623687},
}
Figure