Abstract
The relative leader-member exchange (RLMX) relationship is a subjective perception of an individual's status within a team, formed by comparing their own leader-member exchange (LMX) relationship with that of their peers. Drawing on attribution theory and affective events theory, this study investigates how RLMX influences employee proactive behavior through the emotional mediators of pride and shame. Furthermore, we examine the moderating role of an individual's internal attribution tendency. Based on data from 377 employees collected over two time points, hierarchical regression results indicate that RLMX is positively related to proactive behavior, with both pride and shame serving as significant mediators. Notably, the indirect effect via pride is stronger for individuals with a high internal attribution tendency, while the effect via shame is more pronounced for those with a lower internal attribution tendency.
Introduction
In modern organizational psychology, the quality of the relationship between a supervisor and a subordinate—known as Leader-Member Exchange (LMX)—is a well-established predictor of performance. However, employees do not evaluate their relationships in a vacuum; they engage in social comparison. Relative Leader-Member Exchange (RLMX) captures this comparative standing, reflecting whether an employee perceives they are treated better or worse than their colleagues. While high RLMX is generally associated with positive outcomes, the underlying emotional mechanisms and individual differences that drive these behaviors require deeper exploration.
Theoretical Framework and Hypotheses
This research proposes a dual-path model where RLMX triggers distinct emotional responses that motivate proactive behavior. On one hand, high relative status fosters a sense of pride, providing the psychological energy for self-affirmation and initiative. On the other hand, it can trigger a form of "moral shame" or a sense of debt toward the leader, pushing the employee to reciprocate through high performance.
The intensity of these emotional paths is hypothesized to be moderated by Internal Attribution Tendency—the degree to which individuals attribute outcomes to their own efforts and abilities rather than external factors.
Methodology
The study utilized a multi-stage survey design to mitigate common method bias. Data were collected from 377 employees across various industries in China's Zhejiang Province, including manufacturing, real estate, and the internet sector.
- Time Point 1: Participants reported their perceived RLMX and internal attribution tendencies.
- Time Point 2: Participants reported their experienced emotions (pride and shame) and their proactive behaviors.
The sample was predominantly young (45.6% aged 18-25) and consisted mostly of non-managerial staff (76.1%). Established scales were used to measure all constructs, and the data were analyzed using hierarchical regression and the SPSS Process macro.
Key Findings
The statistical analysis confirmed several critical relationships within the model. RLMX was found to be a significant direct predictor of proactive behavior. Interestingly, the data supported the "Favorite's Burden" hypothesis: high RLMX was positively correlated with shame, suggesting that favored employees feel a "shame of privilege" or pressure to justify their status.
As shown in the regression results, RLMX significantly predicts proactive behavior ($eta = 0.496, p < .001$), pride ($eta = 0.451, p < .001$), and shame ($eta = 0.549, p < .001$). The mediation analysis revealed that the indirect effect of RLMX on proactivity via pride was $0.0934$, while the effect via shame was $0.1203$.
The Role of Attribution
Internal attribution tendency acts as a psychological filter for these emotions. For employees who tend to take personal credit for their successes (high internal attribution), the path from RLMX to proactive behavior through pride is significantly amplified ($eta = 0.211, p < .001$). Conversely, for those with low internal attribution, the drive to be proactive is more heavily influenced by the shame/pressure path, as they may feel their high status is a gift they must work to deserve.
Discussion and Implications
This study highlights that being the "favorite" is a complex emotional experience. While pride is a natural motivator, the finding that high RLMX increases shame suggests a powerful reciprocity mechanism in high-pressure environments. Managers should be aware that while differentiating treatment can drive proactivity, it also places a unique emotional burden on high-status subordinates.
Limitations
- Self-Reporting: The reliance on self-reported data for proactive behavior may introduce social desirability bias.
- Cultural Context: The study was conducted in China, where concepts of "face" and reciprocity (Guanxi) are deeply embedded. The "shame of privilege" might manifest differently in Western, more individualistic cultures.
- Temporal Dynamics: Emotions are transient; future research using daily diary methods could better capture the real-time fluctuations of pride and shame in response to leader interactions.
Summary updated