The timing of biological carbon sequestration and carbon abatement in the energy sector under optimal strategies against climate risks

Vincent Gitz, Hourcade, Jean Charles, Philippe Ciais

TL;DR

This paper uses an optimal control model to explore the timing of biological carbon sequestration (BCS) alongside energy sector emissions reductions. It finds that a small portion of BCS should be used immediately as a "brake" to slow CO2 rise, while the majority should be held in reserve as a "safety valve" for future use, significantly reducing the peak costs of decarbonization and delaying the energy system's transition.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the complex question of how to optimally integrate biological carbon sequestration (BCS) into climate change mitigation strategies, specifically in conjunction with reducing emissions from the energy sector. While BCS, primarily through afforestation, offers a way to remove CO2 from the atmosphere, its effectiveness and optimal deployment timing are debated. Some view it as a loophole that could delay necessary energy sector reforms, while others see it as a valuable tool. This paper aims to provide an economic rationale for the timing of BCS by considering the costs of fossil fuel abatement, the opportunity costs of land for afforestation, and the uncertainties surrounding future climate damages. The core challenge is to balance immediate action with the flexibility to adapt to future, potentially more severe, climate risks.

Methods

The authors employ a stochastic optimal control model, extending the DIAM³ model. This framework allows them to simultaneously manage two "control variables": the rate of carbon abatement in the energy sector and the rate of land allocation for biological carbon sequestration. The model incorporates uncertainty about future climate damages, with information about these damages revealed at a specific point in time (t_info). The objective is to maximize the expected utility of consumption, which is influenced by climate damages, abatement costs, and sequestration costs. A key aspect of their approach is distinguishing between permanent and temporary carbon sequestration, and modeling the associated costs, including the opportunity cost of land, which is a significant factor for temporary sequestration.

Datasets

The paper utilizes data from the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) for cropland and pasture areas and the Global Trade Analysis Project (GTAP) database for agricultural net revenue. These datasets are used to construct a global map of agricultural land suitable for afforestation and to estimate the marginal opportunity cost of this land.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • BCS as a "Brake" and "Safety Valve": The most significant insight is the dual role of BCS. A small portion should be used immediately as a "brake" to slow CO2 concentration growth and reduce the urgency of energy sector abatement, thereby increasing the "option value" of future emission trajectories. The majority of BCS potential, however, should be reserved as a "safety valve" to be deployed later, after climate damage uncertainties are resolved, to mitigate the impact of severe climate "bad news."
  • The Value of Uncertainty: The paper highlights how uncertainty about future climate damages fundamentally shapes the optimal timing of BCS. Holding sequestration potential in reserve allows for a more informed and cost-effective response when the true severity of climate risks becomes clearer.
  • Reversibility of Afforestation: A crucial finding is that a significant portion of afforested land can be converted back to other uses (like agriculture) once climate damages stabilize or decarbonization in the energy sector becomes less costly. This reversibility makes BCS a flexible tool.
  • BCS Complements, Not Replaces, Energy Sector Action: The study emphasizes that BCS is a complement to, not a substitute for, emissions reductions in the energy sector. Early sequestration acts as a brake, but it doesn't eliminate the need for precautionary abatement measures.

Key Results

  • Optimal Timing: The model suggests that a small fraction of BCS potential should be used immediately, with the bulk reserved for later deployment.
  • Cost Reduction: In scenarios with high climate damages, BCS can reduce the peak costs of fossil fuel abatement by up to 29% and smooth out these costs significantly.
  • Delayed Energy Transition: The optimal use of BCS can postpone the pivot point for the energy system's transition to low-carbon profiles by up to two decades.
  • Robustness: The findings regarding the timing and role of BCS are shown to be robust across a range of sensitivity tests, including variations in land opportunity costs and carbon storage per hectare.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simplified Carbon Cycle: The model neglects feedbacks between climate change and the carbon cycle, which could enhance the role of early, permanent sequestration.
  • Exogenous Technical Change: The study assumes exogenous technical change in the energy sector, whereas induced technical change could alter abatement costs.
  • Limited Spatial Analysis: The analysis is aggregate and does not account for the spatial distribution of BCS potential, which is crucial for developing countries with land-use constraints. Future work could involve a spatial analysis to clarify the "when and where" flexibility of BCS.
  • Co-benefits Ignored: While acknowledging potential co-benefits of afforestation (e.g., cleaner water, biodiversity), these were not explicitly included in the main analysis due to a lack of comprehensive global data, though they were considered in sensitivity tests.
  • Data Limitations: The paper notes the difficulty in obtaining robust global data on land opportunity costs and suggests that more detailed studies on co-benefits and regional potentials are needed.

Summary updated

Abstract

International audience
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gitz2005timing,
  author = {Vincent Gitz and Hourcade, Jean Charles and Philippe Ciais},
  title = {{The timing of biological carbon sequestration and carbon abatement in the energy sector under optimal strategies against climate risks}},
  booktitle = {HAL},
  year = {2005},
}
Figure