The time course of molecular acclimation to seawater in a euryhaline fish

Lucrezia C. Bonzi, Alison A. Monroe, Robert Lehmann, Michael L. Berumen, Timothy Ravasi, Celia Schunter

TL;DR

This study investigates how the Arabian pupfish rapidly adapts its gill gene expression to survive drastic salinity changes, mimicking natural flood events. By analyzing transcriptomes over 21 days, researchers identified distinct short-term stress responses and longer-term molecular pathways crucial for adapting to hyperosmotic environments, revealing a remarkable genetic plasticity.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Many fish species are restricted to specific salinity ranges (stenohaline), but some, like euryhaline fish, can tolerate wide variations. The Arabian pupfish ( Aphanius dispar) is a prime example, living in both near-freshwater desert ponds and highly saline Red Sea lagoons. These habitats can become connected during flash floods, forcing the fish to rapidly acclimate to a >40 ppt salinity increase. Understanding the molecular mechanisms behind this rapid acclimation is crucial for comprehending adaptation to environmental change and the colonization of new habitats. Previous studies have identified some genes involved, but a comprehensive, time-course analysis of the entire molecular response to such a drastic shift was lacking.

Methods

The researchers employed a time-course transcriptomic approach. They collected Arabian pupfish from both desert ponds (low salinity) and Red Sea lagoons (high salinity). Desert pond fish were then experimentally transferred to high-salinity water, and their gill tissue was sampled at multiple time points: 0 hours (pre-transfer), 6 hours, 24 hours, 72 hours, 7 days, and 21 days.

Key techniques included:

  • RNA-sequencing (RNA-seq): To measure the abundance of all RNA transcripts in the gill tissue at each time point.
  • De novo transcriptome assembly: Since a reference genome for A. dispar was not readily available, the researchers assembled the transcriptome from scratch using the RNA-seq data.
  • Differential gene expression (DEG) analysis: To identify genes whose expression levels changed significantly between different conditions (e.g., pre-transfer vs. post-transfer, or between the two natural populations).
  • Clustering and time-series analysis (ImpulseDE2): To group genes with similar expression patterns over time and identify transient vs. monotonic changes.
  • Gene Ontology (GO) enrichment analysis: To understand the biological functions and pathways associated with the differentially expressed genes.

Datasets

The study utilized gill tissue samples from two natural populations of Aphanius dispar:

  1. Desert pond population: Collected from a near-freshwater environment (1.45 ppt salinity).
  2. Red Sea coastal lagoon population: Collected from a highly saline environment (43.49 ppt salinity).

For the experimental part, desert pond fish were transferred to high-salinity water (43 ppt) to mimic the natural scenario. Samples were collected at 0h, 6h, 24h, 72h, 7d, and 21d post-transfer.

The raw RNA-seq data has been made publicly available in the National Center for Biotechnology Information Sequence Read Archive under BioProject PRJNA722804.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Distinct basal differences: Even after months of acclimation to similar holding conditions (except salinity), the desert pond and Red Sea populations showed significant differences in gene expression, particularly in genes related to ion transport and immune function. This highlights pre-existing adaptations to their native environments.
  • Timed responses: The study revealed a clear temporal separation of molecular responses. Short-term (hours) responses focused on cellular stress and immediate ion homeostasis, while longer-term (days) responses involved tissue remodeling and more sustained adaptation mechanisms.
  • A "toolkit" for adaptation: The diverse set of genes and pathways activated suggests that A. dispar possesses a broad molecular "toolkit" that it can deploy to cope with hyperosmotic stress, enabling colonization of varied habitats.
  • Transient vs. sustained mechanisms: Some genes were only temporarily activated (e.g., cellular stress response, apoptosis), indicating immediate damage control. Others showed sustained changes, reflecting long-term adjustments in ion transport and tissue structure.
  • Immune system plasticity: The immune system response was also dynamic, with some components upregulated in the Red Sea population and others in the transferred fish, suggesting salinity can influence immune function in complex ways.

Key Results

  • Transcriptome assembly: A de novo assembly of the A. dispar gill transcriptome yielded 99,167 contigs, with 87.2% successfully annotated.
  • Basal differences: 552 differentially expressed genes (DEGs) were identified between the native desert pond and Red Sea populations at time 0, with ion transport and immune system functions being key areas of divergence.
  • Salinity acclimation:
    • Short-term (6-24h): Primarily involved immediate cellular stress responses (e.g., molecular chaperones, apoptosis), cell signaling cascades, and initial adjustments in ion transport and organic osmolyte synthesis. 75 genes showed changes at 6h, and 164 at 24h.
  • Mid-term (72h-7d): Characterized by cell cycle arrest, tissue remodeling (e.g., extracellular matrix degradation, cell adhesion), and further adjustments in osmoregulation. 30 DEGs were found at 72h (compared to 24h), and 423 at 7d (compared to 0h).
  • Long-term (21d): Showed gene expression patterns increasingly resembling the Red Sea population, with sustained upregulation of seawater ion transporters and genes related to tissue organization. 139 DEGs were observed at 21d (compared to 0h).
  • Adaptive pathways: Genes involved in ion transport (e.g., CFTR, NKCC1), osmoregulation (e.g., myo-inositol pathway), immune response, and tissue modification (e.g., keratinization, mucus production) were consistently highlighted as crucial for adaptation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model organism limitations: While A. dispar is a good model for studying euryhalinity, it is not a widely studied model organism, which might limit broader comparative insights.
  • Experimental design: The study focused on gill tissue. Future work could explore other osmoregulatory organs.
  • Environmental factors: While salinity was the primary focus, other environmental factors present in the natural habitats (e.g., temperature, water chemistry) could also influence gene expression and might warrant further investigation.
  • Functional validation: While transcriptomic data provides strong hypotheses, direct functional validation of key genes and pathways through genetic manipulation or physiological experiments would strengthen the findings.
  • Broader ecological implications: Further research could explore how these molecular adaptations translate to fitness, reproductive success, and the ability to colonize new, challenging environments. The authors suggest that understanding the "large toolkit of molecular processes" is key to understanding colonization potential.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Arabian pupfish, Aphanius dispar, is a euryhaline fish inhabiting both inland nearly-freshwater desert ponds and highly saline Red Sea coastal lagoons of the Arabian Peninsula. Desert ponds and coastal lagoons, located respectively upstream and at the mouths of dry riverbeds ("wadies"), have been found to potentially become connected during periods of intense rainfall, which could allow the fish to migrate between these different habitats. Flash floods would therefore flush Arabian pupfish out to sea, requiring a rapid acclimation to a greater than 40 ppt change in salinity. To investigate the molecular pathways of salinity acclimation during such events, a Red Sea coastal lagoon and a desert pond population were sampled, with the latter exposed to a rapid increase in water salinity. Changes in branchial gene expression were investigated via genome-wide transcriptome measurements over time from 6 h to 21 days. The two natural populations displayed basal differences in genes related to ion transport, osmoregulation and immune system functions. These mechanisms were also differentially regulated in seawater transferred fish, revealing their crucial role in long-term adaptation. Other processes were only transiently activated shortly after the salinity exposure, including cellular stress response mechanisms, such as molecular chaperone synthesis and apoptosis. Tissue remodelling processes were also identified as transient, but took place later in the timeline, suggesting their importance to long-term acclimation as they likely equip the fish with lasting adaptations to their new environment. The alterations in branchial functional pathways displayed by Arabian pupfish in response to salinity increases are diverse. These reveal a large toolkit of molecular processes important for adaptation to hyperosmolarity that allow for successful colonization to a wide variety of different habitats.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bonzi2021time,
  author = {Lucrezia C. Bonzi and Alison A. Monroe and Robert Lehmann and Michael L. Berumen and Timothy Ravasi and Celia Schunter},
  title = {{The time course of molecular acclimation to seawater in a euryhaline fish}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-021-97295-3},
}
Figure