The temporal structure of the inner retina at a single glance

Zhijian Zhao, David Klindt, André Maia Chagas, Klaudia P. Szatko, Luke E. Rogerson, Darío A. Protti, Christian Behrens, Deniz Dalkara, Timm Schubert, Matthias Bethge, Katrin Franke, Philipp Berens, Alexander S. Ecker, Thomas Euler

Abstract

The retina decomposes visual stimuli into parallel channels that encode different features of the visual environment. Central to this computation is the synaptic processing in a dense layer of neuropil, the so-called inner plexiform layer (IPL). Here, different types of bipolar cells stratifying at distinct depths relay the excitatory feedforward drive from photoreceptors to amacrine and ganglion cells. Current experimental techniques for studying processing in the IPL do not allow imaging the entire IPL simultaneously in the intact tissue. Here, we extend a two-photon microscope with an electrically tunable lens allowing us to obtain optical vertical slices of the IPL, which provide a complete picture of the response diversity of bipolar cells at a "single glance". The nature of these axial recordings additionally allowed us to isolate and investigate batch effects, i.e. inter-experimental variations resulting in systematic differences in response speed. As a proof of principle, we developed a simple model that disentangles biological from experimental causes of variability and allowed us to recover the characteristic gradient of response speeds across the IPL with higher precision than before. Our new framework will make it possible to study the computations performed in the central synaptic layer of the retina more efficiently.

Introduction

The mammalian retina is a sophisticated biological processor that decomposes visual scenes into parallel feature channels, such as motion, contrast, and color. This complex computation primarily occurs within the inner plexiform layer (IPL), a dense synaptic neuropil where bipolar cells (BCs) deliver excitatory input to amacrine and ganglion cells. The IPL is organized into distinct strata; different BC types terminate at specific depths, creating a functional map where vertical position correlates with response timing and polarity.

Traditionally, investigating this organization has relied on horizontal (x-y) imaging, which captures only a thin slice of the IPL at a time. To reconstruct the full depth, researchers must perform multiple sequential scans. This approach is not only time-consuming but also introduces significant "batch effects"—variations in temperature, indicator concentration, or tissue health between scans—that can obscure subtle biological signals, particularly the kinetics of neural responses.

Methods: Axial Scanning with Electrically Tunable Lenses

To overcome these limitations, we modified a standard two-photon (2P) microscope by integrating an electrically tunable lens (ETL) into the optical path. The ETL is a liquid-filled lens that can rapidly change its curvature and focal length in response to electrical current. By synchronizing the ETL with the microscope’s scanning mirrors, we achieved fast axial (x-z) scanning, enabling the acquisition of vertical optical slices of the retina.

Schematic and photograph of the modified two-photon microscope featuring an electrically tunable lens (ETL) for fast axial scanning.

We visualized the excitatory output of BCs using iGluSnFR, a fluorescent biosensor for glutamate. To analyze the resulting high-dimensional data, we developed a linear mixed-effects model and a shared encoding model. These mathematical frameworks were specifically designed to disentangle biological signals (e.g., position-dependent response speed) from experimental noise and batch effects.

Results: Capturing the Diversity of the IPL

Our axial scanning technique successfully captured the full diversity of BC responses—including both "On" and "Off" polarities and varying kinetics—within a single scan. Calibration experiments confirmed the linearity of the focus shift relative to the ETL driver input and demonstrated stable point spread functions (PSFs) across the scanning range.

Calibration and performance of the ETL-based axial scanning system, showing focus shift linearity and point spread function (PSF) measurements.

A key finding was the magnitude of batch effects: inter-experimental variation accounted for approximately 66% of the data variance, compared to 48% for the biological position of the cells. By treating these batch effects as a "temporal stretching" of a shared response kernel, we were able to normalize data across different animals and experimental sessions. This normalization revealed a clear biological pattern: response speeds are fastest in the center of the IPL and become progressively slower toward the borders of the Inner Nuclear Layer and the Ganglion Cell Layer.

Discussion

While the ETL-based system offers significant advantages, it does introduce specific technical challenges. Physical oscillations of the liquid lens during rapid "jumps" back to the start of a frame create settling time artefacts, requiring the exclusion of the first few lines of each scan. Additionally, changes in focus can slightly alter laser beam collimation, necessitating voltage offsets to maintain uniform intensity.

Despite these limitations, this framework provides a robust method for high-throughput screening of retinal processing. The ability to correct for batch effects allows for a more precise characterization of the IPL's temporal structure than previously possible. Future applications could extend this technique to in vivo recordings in the brain, where simultaneous multi-depth imaging is critical for understanding complex neural circuits.

Summary updated

Abstract

The retina decomposes visual stimuli into parallel channels that encode different features of the visual environment. Central to this computation is the synaptic processing in a dense layer of neuropil, the so-called inner plexiform layer (IPL). Here, different types of bipolar cells stratifying at distinct depths relay the excitatory feedforward drive from photoreceptors to amacrine and ganglion cells. Current experimental techniques for studying processing in the IPL do not allow imaging the entire IPL simultaneously in the intact tissue. Here, we extend a two-photon microscope with an electrically tunable lens allowing us to obtain optical vertical slices of the IPL, which provide a complete picture of the response diversity of bipolar cells at a "single glance". The nature of these axial recordings additionally allowed us to isolate and investigate batch effects, i.e. inter-experimental variations resulting in systematic differences in response speed. As a proof of principle, we developed a simple model that disentangles biological from experimental causes of variability and allowed us to recover the characteristic gradient of response speeds across the IPL with higher precision than before. Our new framework will make it possible to study the computations performed in the central synaptic layer of the retina more efficiently.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhao2020temporal,
  author = {Zhijian Zhao and David Klindt and André Maia Chagas and Klaudia P. Szatko and Luke E. Rogerson and Darío A. Protti and Christian Behrens and Deniz Dalkara and Timm Schubert and Matthias Bethge and Katrin Franke and Philipp Berens and Alexander S. Ecker and Thomas Euler},
  title = {{The temporal structure of the inner retina at a single glance}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-020-60214-z},
}
Figure