The Solenoidal Large Intensity Device (SoLID) for JLab 12 GeV

J. Arrington, Jay Benesch, A. Camsonne, J. Caylor, Jianping Chen, S. Covrig Dusa, Alexander Emmert, George W. Evans, H. Gao, J. Ole Hansen, G. M. Huber, S. Joosten, V. Khachatryan, Nilanga Liyanage, Z.-e. Meziani, M. Nycz, Chao Peng, M. Paolone, Whit Seay, P. A. Souder, N. Sparveris, H. Spiesberger, Ye Tian, E. Voutier, Junqi Xie, Weizhi Xiong, Z. Ye, Jixie Zhang, B. Zhao, Xiaochao ZhengarXiv 2022 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

The Solenoidal Large Intensity Device (SoLID) is a proposed next-generation spectrometer designed to exploit the full potential of Jefferson Lab’s 12 GeV electron beam. By combining massive angular acceptance with ultra-high luminosity, SoLID will provide a high-definition 3D map of the nucleon's internal structure and search for physics beyond the Standard Model at the "QCD intensity frontier."

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In nuclear physics, researchers often face a frustrating trade-off: you can either have high luminosity (hitting a target with a lot of particles to see rare events) or high acceptance (detecting particles over a wide range of angles and momenta). Existing detectors usually pick one.

To truly understand the proton, we need both. We need to move beyond 1D "snapshots" of quark momentum to 3D "tomography" that includes transverse motion and spatial distribution. Furthermore, fundamental questions remain unanswered: Where does the proton's mass actually come from (since the Higgs mechanism only accounts for ~1% of it)? Are there undiscovered "dark" forces acting between electrons and quarks? This paper describes how SoLID solves the luminosity-acceptance dilemma to tackle these foundational questions.

Methods

SoLID is built around a massive superconducting solenoid magnet (repurposed from the CLEO-II experiment). Its design is modular, allowing for two primary configurations:

  1. SIDIS & $J/\psi$ Configuration: Uses a suite of Gas Electron Multiplier (GEM) trackers, Cherenkov detectors for particle identification, and electromagnetic calorimeters to capture a wide range of reaction products.
  2. PVDIS Configuration: Employs a unique set of "baffles"—physical shields designed to block low-energy background noise while allowing high-energy electrons from parity-violating scattering to reach the detectors.

The "secret sauce" of SoLID is its ability to handle data rates at a luminosity of $10^{39} \text{ cm}^{-2}\text{s}^{-1}$. This is orders of magnitude higher than previous large-acceptance detectors, requiring cutting-edge electronics and high-speed computing to process the firehose of data.

Datasets

As a proposal for a new facility, the paper focuses on projected data and how it compares to existing benchmarks. The planned experiments will utilize:

  • Polarized Targets: $^3\text{He}$ (acting as a polarized neutron) and $\text{NH}_3$ (polarized proton) to study spin structure.
  • Unpolarized Targets: Liquid hydrogen and deuterium for precision cross-section measurements.
  • Nuclear Targets: $^{48}\text{Ca}$ to investigate how the nuclear environment modifies quark distributions (the EMC effect).
  • Comparisons: The paper benchmarks SoLID’s reach against current world data from HERA, COMPASS, and Hermes, as well as future projections for the Electron-Ion Collider (EIC).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Mass" Trace Anomaly: By measuring $J/\psi$ meson production near the threshold, SoLID can probe the gluonic gravitational form factors. This helps isolate the "trace anomaly" contribution to the proton's mass—the part generated by the strong force itself.
  • BSM Reach: Through Parity-Violating Deep Inelastic Scattering (PVDIS), SoLID can search for "Beyond the Standard Model" (BSM) physics. It is sensitive to new contact interactions at an energy scale of $\sim 17.6 \text{ TeV}$, which is competitive with and complementary to the LHC.
  • 3D Tomography: SoLID will extract Transverse Momentum-Dependent distributions (TMDs). This allows physicists to see how quark spin correlates with its orbital motion, essentially creating a 3D "movie" of the proton's interior.
  • Filling the High-x Void: While the future EIC will excel at low-x (where gluons dominate), SoLID is uniquely positioned to provide high-precision data in the high-x region (where valence quarks dominate), a region critical for testing Lattice QCD calculations.

Key Results

  • Tensor Charge: SoLID is projected to improve the accuracy of the nucleon's tensor charge determination by an order of magnitude.
  • Weak Mixing Angle: It will provide a highly precise measurement of the weak mixing angle ($\sin^2 \theta_W$) at low energy, a sensitive test for new "dark" $Z$ bosons.
  • Flavor Separation: The high statistics will allow for the first clear separation of $u$ and $d$ quark contributions to the proton's transverse spin structure.

Limitations and Future Work

The primary challenge for SoLID is the sheer volume of data and the complexity of the required theoretical corrections. To reach sub-percent precision, researchers must account for complex "radiative corrections" (secondary particle emissions) that can distort the signal.

Looking ahead, the authors discuss how SoLID could be upgraded if Jefferson Lab receives a 20+ GeV beam or a positron beam. These upgrades would allow SoLID to explore even deeper into the gluonic structure of matter and perform even more stringent tests of electroweak theory.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Solenoidal Large Intensity Device (SoLID) is a new experimental apparatus planned for Hall A at the Thomas Jefferson National Accelerator Facility (JLab). SoLID will combine large angular and momentum acceptance with the capability to handle very high data rates at high luminosity. With a slate of approved high-impact physics experiments, SoLID will push JLab to a new limit at the QCD intensity frontier that will exploit the full potential of its 12 GeV electron beam. In this paper, we present an overview of the rich physics program that can be realized with SoLID, which encompasses the tomography of the nucleon in 3-D momentum space from Semi-Inclusive Deep Inelastic Scattering (SIDIS), expanding the phase space in the search for new physics and novel hadronic effects in parity-violating DIS (PVDIS), a precision measurement of $J/ψ$ production at threshold that probes the gluon field and its contribution to the proton mass, tomography of the nucleon in combined coordinate and momentum space with deep exclusive reactions, and more. To meet the challenging requirements, the design of SoLID described here takes full advantage of recent progress in detector, data acquisition and computing technologies. In addition, we outline potential experiments beyond the currently approved program and discuss the physics that could be explored should upgrades of CEBAF become a reality in the future.
BibTeX
@misc{arrington2022solenoidal,
  author = {J. Arrington and Jay Benesch and A. Camsonne and J. Caylor and Jianping Chen and S. Covrig Dusa and Alexander Emmert and George W. Evans and H. Gao and J. Ole Hansen and G. M. Huber and S. Joosten and V. Khachatryan and Nilanga Liyanage and Z.-E. Meziani and M. Nycz and Chao Peng and M. Paolone and Whit Seay and P. A. Souder and N. Sparveris and H. Spiesberger and Ye Tian and E. Voutier and Junqi Xie and Weizhi Xiong and Z. Ye and Z. Ye and Jixie Zhang and B. Zhao and Xiaochao Zheng},
  title = {{The Solenoidal Large Intensity Device (SoLID) for JLab 12 GeV}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2209.13357},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2209.13357},
}
Figure