The Significant Impact of Biomass Burning Emitted Particles on Typical Haze Pollution in Changsha, China

Qu Xiao, Hui Guo, Jie Tan, Zaihua Wang, Yuzhu Xie, Hyungah Jin, Mengrong Yang, Xinning Wang, Chunlei Cheng, Bo Huang, Mei LiToxics 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses single-particle aerosol mass spectrometry (SPAMS) to investigate the impact of biomass burning (BB) on haze pollution in Changsha, China. It reveals that BB is a major driver of severe haze events, distinguishing between primary BB particles from agricultural burning and those from local cooking, and identifying a secondary processed BB particle type formed through atmospheric aging.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Haze pollution is a significant environmental and health concern, particularly in rapidly developing regions like China. While biomass burning (BB) is recognized as a major contributor to atmospheric fine particulate matter (PM2.5) and haze formation, a detailed understanding of the specific sources, evolution, and impact of BB-emitted particles on air quality is still needed. Specifically, differentiating between various BB sources (e.g., agricultural residue burning vs. cooking) and understanding how these particles change in the atmosphere (aging) are crucial for effective pollution control strategies. This paper aims to address these gaps by providing a high-resolution, real-time analysis of BB particles during a typical haze event in Changsha.

Methods

The core methodology employed is Single-Particle Aerosol Mass Spectrometry (SPAMS). This technique allows for the real-time, individual chemical analysis of airborne particles. The SPAMS instrument used in this study was capable of measuring particle size, scattering intensity, and both positive and negative mass spectra.

Key methodological aspects include:

  • BB Particle Identification: A two-step process was used:
  • Initial Screening: Particles were flagged if they exhibited a strong potassium ion signal (K+) and at least one characteristic negative ion (CN- or CNO-).
  • Cluster Analysis: An improved ART-2a algorithm was used to group particles with similar mass spectra. These clusters were then analyzed for their mass spectra, size distributions, and temporal trends to classify them into distinct types (BB1, BB2, and BB-sec).
  • Source Apportionment: This involved combining SPAMS data with:
  • Backward Trajectory Analysis: The HYSPLIT model was used to determine the origin of air masses reaching the sampling site.
  • Satellite Fire Hotspot Data: NASA's FIRMS data was used to identify regional biomass burning activities.
  • Aging Process Investigation: The study specifically looked for particles that showed spectral characteristics indicative of atmospheric transformation, such as the presence of secondary inorganic species (sulfate, ammonium) and the absence of primary BB markers.

Datasets

  • Ambient Air Quality Data: Conventional air quality parameters (PM2.5, PM10, O3, NO2, SO2, CO) were obtained from a co-located national monitoring site.
  • Meteorological Data: Wind direction, wind speed, temperature, and atmospheric pressure were collected.
  • Biomass Burning Fire Hotspot Data: NASA's Fire Information for Resource Management System (FIRMS) was used.
  • Air Mass Backward Trajectory Data: The HYSPLIT model, using GDAS meteorological data, was employed.
  • Controlled Laboratory Combustion Data: Smoke from burning rice straw, wheat straw, and corn stalks was analyzed to establish reference spectra for fresh BB particles.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • BB as a Primary Haze Driver: The study provides strong evidence that biomass burning is a direct and significant contributor to severe haze events, as evidenced by the sharp increase in PM2.5 coinciding with a surge in BB particle counts.
  • Distinguishing BB Sources: The research successfully differentiates between two primary types of BB particles:
  • BB1: Linked to agricultural straw burning, characterized by episodic spikes and likely originating from regional sources.
  • BB2: Associated with local nighttime cooking emissions, showing a more regular diurnal pattern and likely originating from within the urban area.
  • Atmospheric Aging of BB Particles: The identification of "BB-sec" particles, which lack primary BB markers but contain sulfate and ammonium, highlights the significant atmospheric transformation of BB emissions. This aging process can alter particle characteristics and potentially lead to their underestimation if only primary markers are considered.
  • Implications for Policy: The findings underscore the need for targeted emission control strategies, emphasizing both regional agricultural burning regulations and local cooking emission management. The suggestion for converting crop straw into high-efficiency fuel or clean energy also points towards sustainable solutions.

Key Results

  • During a haze episode on October 12, 2024, PM2.5 concentrations surged from 25 µg·m⁻³ to 273 µg·m⁻³, with the proportion of total BB single particles increasing from 17.2% to 54%.
  • BB particles were classified into two main types: BB1 (71.7% of total BB particles) and BB2 (28.3% of total BB particles).
  • BB1 particles were strongly linked to agricultural straw burning in northern Changsha, while BB2 particles were associated with local nighttime cooking in urban Changsha.
  • A distinct "BB-sec" particle type, likely representing aged BB particles with secondary coatings (sulfate and ammonium), was identified and appeared with a temporal lag after BB1 peaks.
  • The overall contribution of BB particles to total detected particles during the sampling period was 11.5% on average, with a maximum hourly ratio of 66.9%.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Potential Underestimation of BB Particles: The study suggests that the "BB-sec" particle type, formed through aging, might be underestimated by standard classification methods that rely solely on primary emission markers. This implies that the true impact of BB might be higher than directly measured.
  • Health Risk Assessment: While the paper discusses the general toxicity of BB particles, it calls for further research to investigate the specific health risks associated with BB particles during haze episodes, given their enhanced toxicity compared to urban ambient PM2.5.
  • Source Apportionment Refinement: While backward trajectories and fire hotspots provided strong indications, more detailed source apportionment models could further refine the attribution of BB particles to specific activities and locations.
  • Long-term Monitoring: The study focused on a specific autumn period. Extending such investigations to different seasons and years would provide a more comprehensive understanding of BB's role in air quality.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this study, typical haze pollution influenced by biomass burning (BB) activities in Changsha in the autumn of 2024 was investigated through the mixing state and evolution process of BB particles via the real-time measurement of single-particle aerosol mass spectrometry (SPAMS). From the clean period to the haze period, the PM<sub>2.5</sub> concentration increased from 25 μg·m<sup>-3</sup> at 12:00 to 273 μg·m<sup>-3</sup> at 21:00 on 12 October, and the proportion of total BB single particles in the total detected particles increased from 17.2% to 54%. This indicates that the rapid increase in PM<sub>2.5</sub> concentration was accompanied by a concurrent increase in the contribution of particles originating from BB sources. The detected BB particles were classified into two types based on their mixing states and temporal variations: BB1 and BB2, which accounted for 71.7% and 28.3% of the total BB particles, respectively. The analysis of backward trajectories and fire spots suggested that BB1 particles originated from straw burning emissions at northern Changsha, while BB2 particles were primarily related to local nighttime cooking emissions in Changsha. In addition, a special type of K-containing single particles without K cluster ions was found closely associated with BB1 type particles, which were designated as secondarily processed BB particles (BB-sec). The BB-sec particles contained abundant sulfate and ammonium signals and showed lagged appearance after the peak of BB1-type particles, which was possibly due to the aging and formation of ammonium sulfate on the freshly emitted particles. In all, this study provides insights into understanding the substantial impact of BB sources on regional air quality during the crop harvest season and the appropriate disposal of crop straw, including conversion into high-efficiency fuel through secondary processing or clean energy via biological fermentation, which is of great significance for the mitigation of local haze pollution.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xiao2025significant,
  author = {Qu Xiao and Hui Guo and Jie Tan and Zaihua Wang and Yuzhu Xie and Hyungah Jin and Mengrong Yang and Xinning Wang and Chunlei Cheng and Bo Huang and Mei Li},
  title = {{The Significant Impact of Biomass Burning Emitted Particles on Typical Haze Pollution in Changsha, China}},
  booktitle = {Toxics},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/toxics13080691},
}
Figure