Abstract
In today's world where frequent regional conflicts affect global economic, political, and other fields, and trigger humanitarian crises, the Israeli-Palestinian conflict is among the most significant conflicts around the world. As the current world hegemony, the United States has an undoubted influence on the global community. Since the founding of the United Nations, to protect its own interests, the United States is enormously influential in various decisions of the United Nations to varying degrees, especially in the process of conflict settling. In the context of the failure of conflict resolution in the United Nations, this study analyzes the United States’ role in the mediation of disputes in the United Nations, with the method of case analysis. Guided by the realistic theory, this paper aims to deeply understand the motives of the United States' actions and how it affects conflict resolution, which has important practical significance. In conclusion, the United States has used a variety of strategies to influence conflict resolution of the United Nations, leading to the loss of the UN’s peacekeeping power.
Introduction
The United Nations was established to "save succeeding generations from the scourge of war," yet it often appears paralyzed during major regional crises. This paper investigates the 2021 escalation of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict—marked by the heaviest exchange of fire since 2014—to understand how a single superpower can navigate and neutralize international institutional mechanisms. By applying the lens of Realist international relations theory, we analyze why the UN failed to mediate this crisis and the specific role played by the United States as a rational hegemon.
Theoretical Framework: Realism in International Relations
To analyze state behavior in the 2021 conflict, this study employs a framework based on Realist Theory. Realism posits that the international system is anarchic and that states are the primary, rational actors driven by self-interest rather than institutional cooperation.
As illustrated in the figure above, Realism is divided into several branches that provide different perspectives on state motivation. While Classical Realism focuses on human nature, Neorealism emphasizes the international structure. Defensive Realism suggests states seek security, while Offensive Realism argues they seek absolute power. This study evaluates which of these frameworks best explains the US's decision to prioritize its "special relationship" with Israel over the collective goal of international peace.
Case Analysis: The 2021 Conflict and US Obstruction
The 2021 conflict demonstrated a significant disconnect between the UN’s theoretical role as a neutral mediator and its practical impotence. The United States utilized its structural position as a Permanent Five (P5) member of the Security Council to ensure the UN remained a bystander.
Strategic Vetoes and Arms Sales
A critical finding of this study is the systematic nature of US obstruction. The US rejected UNSC statements on the conflict three times in a single week (May 10, 12, and 16, 2021). These rejections were often justified by the claim that UN involvement would interfere with private US diplomatic efforts, yet they served to prevent other powers, such as China (the UNSC president at the time), from gaining diplomatic influence.
Furthermore, as shown in the timeline, the US approved a $735 million sale of precision-guided weapons to Israel on May 17, mid-conflict. This act functioned as a "green light," signaling permission for the conflict to continue escalating despite international calls for a ceasefire. This prioritization of national strategic interests over institutional mediation confirms that Realism provides a more accurate roadmap of modern diplomacy than Liberal Institutionalism.
Conclusion
The 2021 Israeli-Palestinian conflict serves as a stark example of the "Institutional Puppet" problem, where the UN's efficacy is entirely dependent on the cooperation of its most powerful members. The United States' strategic obstruction led to a demonstrable loss of the UN’s peacekeeping power. This case study confirms that when international law conflicts with the national interests of a hegemon, the latter effectively mutes the former, rendering international institutions secondary to state-level power dynamics.
Summary updated