The Regretful Agent: Heuristic-Aided Navigation Through Progress Estimation.

Chih-Yao Ma, Zuxuan Wu, Ghassan AlRegib, Caiming Xiong, Zsolt Kira

Introduction

Vision-and-Language Navigation (VLN) represents a significant challenge in embodied AI, requiring agents to interpret natural language instructions and navigate complex 3D environments. Traditional approaches typically rely on either greedy decoding, which is computationally efficient but prone to irreversible errors, or beam search, which achieves higher success rates but is physically impractical for real-world robotics due to its requirement for simultaneous exploration of multiple paths. This paper introduces the "Regretful Agent," a novel framework that bridges this gap by incorporating a learned progress monitor as a search heuristic, allowing for efficient, human-like backtracking.

The Regretful Agent Framework

The core of the proposed architecture is the ability to recognize and rectify navigational mistakes. This is achieved through two primary components: the Regret Module and the Progress Marker.

The Regret Module

The Regret Module continuously evaluates the agent's progress toward the goal based on the instruction. Unlike previous models that used progress estimation solely for training regularization, the Regretful Agent uses it as an active heuristic. If the estimated progress stalls or decreases significantly after an action, the module triggers a "rollback" mechanism.

A low progress estimate (13%) accompanied by a warning signal, triggering the agent's regret mechanism.

The Progress Marker

To ensure that backtracking leads to a better outcome, the agent utilizes a Progress Marker. This component acts as a local memory, recording the progress scores of visited viewpoints. When an agent returns to a previous location, the Progress Marker biases the next action selection toward unexplored directions or paths with higher previously estimated confidence, preventing the agent from repeating the same error.

Heuristic-Aided Backtracking

The navigation process is formalized as a heuristic-aided search. The difference in progress between consecutive steps ($\Delta p$) serves as the primary signal for the Regret Module. This mechanism mimics human behavior: when we realize a path does not match our mental map of the instructions, we double back to the last known correct point.

The agent's navigation path on a floor plan, illustrating a rollback from the pantry room when confidence decreases.

The model is optimized using a multi-task loss function, including cross-entropy for action selection, Mean Squared Error (MSE) for progress monitoring, and an entropy loss to encourage exploration. This training regime ensures the agent learns not just the correct paths, but also how to recover from incorrect ones.

Experimental Evaluation

The Regretful Agent was evaluated on the Room-to-Room (R2R) dataset, which utilizes panoramic views from the Matterport3D dataset. The evaluation focused on "Validation Unseen" and "Test Unseen" environments to test the agent's generalization capabilities.

Key Results

The Regretful Agent established a new state-of-the-art for greedy VLN methods:

  • Success Rate (SR): The agent achieved a 5% absolute improvement on the test server over previous benchmarks.
  • Success weighted by Path Length (SPL): A critical metric for efficiency, SPL saw an 8% improvement. This indicates that the backtracking mechanism is purposeful and efficient, rather than resulting in aimless wandering.
  • Error Reduction: Qualitative analysis confirmed that the agent successfully reduced the percentage of unsuccessful trials involving rollbacks from 43% to 38%, suggesting it identifies mistakes earlier in the trajectory.

Conclusion

The Regretful Agent demonstrates that incorporating "regret"—the ability to recognize and backtrack from mistakes—significantly enhances navigational performance without the overhead of exhaustive search. By using progress estimation as a learnable heuristic, the agent achieves a balance between the efficiency of greedy search and the robustness of global search strategies. Future work will explore multi-step backtracking and improved "Stop" action logic to further refine the agent's autonomy in complex, multi-room environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

As deep learning continues to make progress for challenging perception tasks, there is increased interest in combining vision, language, and decision-making. Specifically, the Vision and Language Navigation (VLN) task involves navigating to a goal purely from language instructions and visual information without explicit knowledge of the goal. Recent successful approaches have made in-roads in achieving good success rates for this task but rely on beam search, which thoroughly explores a large number of trajectories and is unrealistic for applications such as robotics. In this paper, inspired by the intuition of viewing the problem as search on a navigation graph, we propose to use a progress monitor developed in prior work as a learnable heuristic for search. We then propose two modules incorporated into an end-to-end architecture: 1) A learned mechanism to perform backtracking, which decides whether to continue moving forward or roll back to a previous state (Regret Module) and 2) A mechanism to help the agent decide which direction to go next by showing directions that are visited and their associated progress estimate (Progress Marker). Combined, the proposed approach significantly outperforms current state-of-the-art methods using greedy action selection, with 5% absolute improvement on the test server in success rates, and more importantly 8% on success rates normalized by the path length.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ma2019regretful,
  author = {Chih-Yao Ma and Zuxuan Wu and Ghassan AlRegib and Caiming Xiong and Zsolt Kira},
  title = {{The Regretful Agent: Heuristic-Aided Navigation Through Progress Estimation.}},
  booktitle = {CVPR},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1109/cvpr.2019.00689},
}
Figure