The Purposes of Ethno-Botany

J. W. HarshbergerBotanical Gazette 1896 · DOI

This paper, published in 1896 by J. W. Harshberger, is a foundational text in the field of ethnobotany—a term Harshberger himself is credited with coining just a year prior. Writing at the dawn of the discipline, he argues that the study of how indigenous peoples used plants is not merely a curiosity for collectors, but a rigorous scientific tool for reconstructing human history.

TL;DR

Harshberger defines "ethno-botany" as a multi-disciplinary approach to archaeology that uses plant remains to determine the cultural "stage" of ancient tribes, map prehistoric trade routes, and discover new medicinal or industrial applications for modern society. It marks a shift from viewing artifacts as curiosities to treating them as biological data points.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the late 19th century, American archaeology was often a descriptive endeavor focused on collecting "unique objects." Harshberger identifies a gap in how these collections—specifically the Hazzard collection of Ancestral Puebloan (Cliff Dweller) artifacts—were analyzed.

He argues that without a systematic study of plant products (food, clothing, tools), we miss the "cultural position" of a people. The paper seeks to move beyond simple classification to answer deeper questions: Were these people nomadic or sedentary? Where did their crops originate? How did they interact with distant tribes?

Methods

Harshberger proposes a suite of "forensic" botanical techniques that were quite advanced for the 1890s:

  • Microscopic Wood Anatomy: Using thin sections to identify species by examining cellular structures like tracheids, tyloses, and medullary rays (e.g., distinguishing white oak from chestnut).
  • Physical Property Testing: Determining wood species by calculating specific gravity, ash content, and fuel value, then comparing these to established tables (like Sargent’s work on North American trees).
  • Dendrochronology (Early Form): Analyzing annual rings to infer past meteorological conditions, such as droughts or the occurrence of forest fires.
  • Paleobotanical Analysis: Identifying seeds and plant fibers found in archaeological contexts, including human excrement, to reconstruct ancient diets.
  • Reverse-Engineering: Unraveling woven fabrics to understand ancient manufacturing techniques and "Indian stitches."

Datasets

While the paper predates modern digital datasets, it relies on several key 19th-century "benchmarks":

  • The Hazzard Collection: A series of objects obtained by the Wetherill brothers in Mancos Canyon, Colorado, exhibited at the 1893 World’s Fair.
  • Sargent’s Tables: A voluminous reference work on the physical properties of North American forest trees.
  • Historical Texts: Accounts from early explorers like Hernandez de Oviedo (1535) to track the historical distribution of plants like tobacco.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Plants as Trade Proxies: Harshberger posits that because maize (Zea mays) originated in central Mexico, its presence in the American Southwest is definitive proof of ancient trade routes. He suggests that while one plant might be an outlier, a "half a dozen plants" found together can map a main trade route with high accuracy.
  • The "Pastoral" Gap: He observes that the traditional European classification of human progress (Savage → Pastoral → Agricultural → Civilized) doesn't fit North America. Indigenous tribes often skipped the "pastoral" (herding) stage entirely, moving from hunting directly to agriculture.
  • Extreme Providency: He highlights the "Cliff Dwellers" as masters of recycling. For example, a hollowed-out pumpkin used as a jar would, once broken, be repurposed into scraping tools, and worn-out Yucca fibers were never discarded but "conserved and made useful."
  • Living Museums: Harshberger concludes with a visionary proposal for "ethno-botanic gardens" where plants are arranged not by taxonomy, but by the tribes that used them and their specific utility (fiber, dye, medicine).

Key Results

  • Species Identification: Through microscopy and specific gravity tests, Harshberger successfully identifies archaeological wood samples as white oak and chestnut.
  • Medicinal Discovery: He notes the discovery of the "mescal button" (peyote) among the Kiowas as a "stimulant and nerve tonic" new to Western materia medica, illustrating the practical value of ethnobotanical research for modern medicine.
  • Cultural Mapping: He uses the distribution of Nicotiana (tobacco) species to differentiate between the agricultural practices of tribes in the Southwest versus those in the Missouri-to-Oregon corridor.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Dating Ambiguity: Harshberger acknowledges the difficulty in determining if a piece of wood was collected "at once or after the piece had lain on the ground for some time," which complicates the use of tree rings for precise dating.
  • Need for Reference Collections: He emphasizes that the field cannot progress without systematic "seed collections" in museums, as identifying seeds from diverse sources is impossible without a comparative baseline.
  • Call for Infrastructure: The paper is ultimately a plea for the establishment of ethno-botanic gardens and specialized museum departments to provide "living plants for study" alongside archaeological objects.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{harshberger1896purposes,
  author = {J. W. Harshberger},
  title = {{The Purposes of Ethno-Botany}},
  booktitle = {Botanical Gazette},
  year = {1896},
  doi = {10.1086/327316},
}
Figure