Is a cultural ethology possible?

F. T. CloakHuman Ecology 1975 · DOI

TL;DR

In this foundational 1968 paper, F. T. Cloak, Jr. proposes "cultural ethology"—a rigorous framework for studying human culture as a collection of discrete, learned behavioral propensities. By treating cultural traits as "corpuscles" subject to natural selection, Cloak argues we can transform anthropology into a hard natural science, moving past subjective introspection to observe how specific stimuli trigger specific, adaptive cultural responses.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cloak identifies a fractured landscape in the study of human behavior. On one side, animal ethologists were beginning to look at humans but focused almost exclusively on innate, "wired-in" behaviors (like smiling), largely ignoring the massive influence of learned culture. On the other side, social scientists often treated culture as a vague, holistic, or purely social force, frequently falling into the trap of "anthropocentrism"—believing they could understand behavior simply by asking people why they do what they do.

The paper seeks to bridge this gap. It addresses the challenge of how to scientifically study learned human traditions without relying on the subjective "emic" (insider) accounts of participants, which Cloak argues are often post-hoc rationalizations rather than true explanations of behavior.

Methods

This is primarily a theoretical and programmatic paper, but it outlines a specific methodological shift:

  • Behavioral Propensities: Cloak proposes breaking culture down into "propensities"—specific internal instructions where a certain stimulus (a "releaser") triggers a specific response.
  • Etic Observation: Borrowing from animal ethology, he advocates for observing humans in natural or simulated natural conditions to identify these stimulus-response units.
  • Particulate Analysis: He suggests a "Mendelian" approach—starting with simple, clear-cut behaviors controlled by single factors before trying to explain complex, multi-propensity social structures.
  • Technological Integration: The author suggests using then-emerging technologies like videotape, telemetry (to track respiration and heartbeat), and "stimulus-surrogates" (films or audio tapes) to record involuntary "intention-movements" that occur below the level of conscious awareness.

Datasets

While not a primary data-reporting paper, Cloak references several key sources to support his framework:

  • Trinidad Study: The author’s own research involving a corpus of 3,666 behavioral propensities across 28 immigrant families in a Trinidadian village.
  • Ethnographic Case Studies: Analysis of the Nuer-Dinka relationship (via Sahlins and Evans-Pritchard) and the "sacred cattle complex" of India (via Marvin Harris).
  • Kinesics and Proxemics: References to Ray Birdwhistell’s studies of facial expressions and Edward T. Hall’s work on how humans use space.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Culture as "Corpuscles": In a striking precursor to the concept of "memes," Cloak argues that culture is composed of "tiny unrelated snippets" or "corpuscles of culture." These are discrete units of instruction transmitted with high fidelity from one generation to the next.
  • Natural Selection of Ideas: Because these cultural propensities are transmitted between individuals, they are subject to natural selection. A specific cultural behavior (like a specific way of farming or a social belief) survives if it provides a functional advantage to the population, regardless of whether the individuals understand why they are doing it.
  • The "Expandable In-group": Cloak reinterprets complex social structures (like the Nuer lineage system) not as abstract social machines, but as the result of a specific behavioral propensity: "anyone who attacks my brother attacks me." He argues the behavior causes the social form, not the other way around.
  • Rejection of Introspection: The paper argues that an informant’s statement is a datum to be explained, not an explanation in itself. To understand culture, we must look at what people do, not what they say they are doing.

Key Results

As a theoretical proposal, the "results" are the conceptual tools provided:

  • Functional Integration: Cloak explains that while cultural particles may be logically arbitrary (like the specific sounds of a language), they appear "integrated" because they have been filtered through the lens of survival and functional utility over thousands of years.
  • Validation of Ethological Methods: He demonstrates that specific, automatic verbal responses (like the "corn-peas-cassava" response in his Trinidad study) act exactly like the "fixed action patterns" seen in animals, proving that cultural behavior can be studied with the same granularity as biological behavior.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Complexity: Cloak acknowledges that many human behaviors are "multigenic"—the product of many propensities acting at once—making them difficult to isolate in early research.
  • The "Innate vs. Learned" Hurdle: He notes that it is often difficult to immediately distinguish between a behavior that is phylogenetically "wired-in" and one that is culturally acquired, though he argues that for a cultural ethologist, the mode of acquisition is less important than the distribution and function of the behavior.
  • Call for Natural Science: The paper concludes that this approach is "absolutely essential" if anthropology is to fulfill its promise of becoming a true natural science of culture.

Note: This paper is a significant historical marker in the development of evolutionary culture theory, pre-dating Richard Dawkins' "The Selfish Gene" by eight years.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{cloak1975is,
  author = {F. T. Cloak},
  title = {{Is a cultural ethology possible?}},
  booktitle = {Human Ecology},
  year = {1975},
  doi = {10.1007/bf01531639},
}
Figure