The Performance Analysis of Signal Recognition Using Attention Based CNN Method

Zan Yin, Bo Chen, Weimin Zhen, Chaojie Wang, Ting Zhang

Introduction

Automatic Modulation Recognition (AMR) is a foundational task in cognitive radio, enabling receivers to identify signal modulation types—such as BPSK, QPSK, or QAM—so they can be properly processed. However, traditional AMR methods often struggle in high-noise environments. Conventional constellation diagrams lose vital statistical information at low signal-to-noise ratios (SNR), appearing as indistinguishable clouds of points. This paper introduces the Image-based CNN with Attention Model (ICAM), a framework designed to overcome these limitations by leveraging density-based signal representation and attention mechanisms.

Methodology

The ICAM framework employs a novel data representation called Contour Stella Images. Instead of simple scatter plots, the system calculates the density of signal points using a sliding window and maps these densities to a specific color scale. This approach preserves the statistical distribution of the signal, making patterns discernible even under heavy noise.

Density mapping for Contour Stella Images

The model architecture utilizes a ResNet18 backbone enhanced with a Convolutional Block Attention Module (CBAM). This "plug-and-play" module incorporates both channel and spatial attention. Channel attention identifies the most meaningful feature maps, while spatial attention directs the network to focus on signal clusters rather than the noisy background. To evaluate the model, a dataset of 11,000 images was generated across eight modulation categories (BPSK, 4ASK, QPSK, OQPSK, 8PSK, 16QAM, 32QAM, and 64QAM) with SNRs ranging from -6dB to 20dB.

Results and Discussion

The ICAM model demonstrated superior performance compared to standard AlexNet and ResNet implementations. At an SNR of 0dB, the model achieved an accuracy exceeding 99%. Crucially, at the challenging -6dB SNR level, ICAM outperformed the standard ResNet18 by approximately 3%, validating the effectiveness of the attention mechanism in filtering noise.

Example of a BPSK Contour Stella Image showing distinct clusters

Interpretability analysis using Grad-CAM (Gradient-weighted Class Activation Mapping) confirmed that the model focuses on the core clusters of the signal. For instance, in BPSK signals, the attention mechanism successfully isolates the two primary clusters, effectively ignoring the surrounding noise cloud. This transformation of a statistical problem into a texture-recognition task allows the CNN to excel where traditional methods fail.

Conclusion

While ICAM significantly improves AMR performance, distinguishing between phase-based modulations (like QPSK and 8PSK) remains difficult at extremely low SNRs due to physical signal blurring. Future research will focus on more advanced architectures to further enhance recognition accuracy for similar spatial signatures and move toward real-time hardware implementation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Modulation recognition has always been an important task in the development of the cognitive radio. At present, there are two main application methods for signal data, namely, directly using the signal sequence and using some conversions such as constellation diagram. In this paper, the converted contour stella images are adopted as data source for research. The deep learning method has been proposed, which is called Image-based CNN with Attention Model (ICAM). ICAM is based on Residual Neural Network (ResNet). To evaluate the performance of ICAM, we generate a dataset which contains contour stella images involving of 8 kinds of modulation types with signal to noise ratio (SNR) from -6dB to 20dB. Compared with other state-of-the-art image-based methods, which are including those using constellation diagram and contour stellar images, ICAM makes more satisfactory performance. Besides, the Grad-Cam technology is applied to visualize and prove the effectiveness of ICAM.
BibTeX
@article{yin2020performance,
  author = {Zan Yin and Bo Chen and Weimin Zhen and Chaojie Wang and Ting Zhang},
  title = {{The Performance Analysis of Signal Recognition Using Attention Based CNN Method}},
  journal = {IEEE Access},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1109/access.2020.3038208},
}

Loading related content...

Figure