The Parameterized Complexity of Motion Planning for Snake-Like Robots

Siddharth Gupta, Guy Sa'ar, Meirav Zehavi

Abstract

We study a motion-planning problem inspired by the game Snake that models scenarios like the transportation of linked wagons towed by a locomotor to the movement of a group of agents that travel in an "ant-like" fashion. Given a "snake-like" robot with initial and final positions in an environment modeled by a graph, our goal is to decide whether the robot can reach the final position from the initial position without intersecting itself. Already on grid graphs, this problem is PSPACE-complete. Nevertheless, we prove that even on general graphs, it is solvable in time $k^{O(k)}|I|^{O(1)}$ where $k$ is the size of the robot, and $|I|$ is the input size. Towards this, we give a novel application of color-coding to sparsify the configuration graph of the problem. We also show that the problem is unlikely to have a polynomial kernel even on grid graphs, but it admits a treewidth-reduction procedure. To the best of our knowledge, the study of the parameterized complexity of motion problems has been largely neglected, thus our work is pioneering in this regard.

Introduction

The SNAKE GAME problem involves a robot composed of $k$ linked segments moving through an environment represented as a graph. The robot must navigate from an initial configuration to a target configuration without self-intersection. While intuitively simple, this problem is computationally daunting; previous work established its PSPACE-completeness even on restricted topologies like grid graphs. This implies that as the environment size $n$ grows, the computational cost typically becomes prohibitive.

Sequence of configurations for a snake-like robot moving through a graph.

However, in many practical applications—such as medical endoscopes or linked transport wagons—the length of the robot $k$ is significantly smaller than the overall environment. This research investigates whether the problem is Fixed-Parameter Tractable (FPT) with respect to $k$, effectively asking if the exponential complexity can be confined to the parameter $k$ rather than the environment size $n$.

Methods

The authors employ several advanced techniques from parameterized complexity to analyze and solve the SNAKE GAME.

Configuration Graph Sparsification

The state space of a snake robot is immense, with approximately $n^k$ possible configurations. To navigate this efficiently, the authors introduce a novel application of color-coding. Traditionally used to find simple paths, color-coding is used here to "sparsify" the configuration graph. By creating a smaller representative graph that preserves the reachability properties of the original, the authors reduce the search space to a manageable size.

Cross-Composition and Kernelization

To determine if the problem can be compressed into a smaller "kernel" (a reduced instance whose size depends only on $k$), the authors use cross-composition. They present a reduction from the Hamiltonian Cycle problem, demonstrating that a polynomial kernel for SNAKE GAME would imply a collapse in the polynomial hierarchy ($NP \subseteq coNP/poly$), which is widely considered unlikely.

Schematic of the cross-composition reduction used to prove the absence of a polynomial kernel.

Treewidth Reduction

The authors also utilize the irrelevant vertex technique. They prove that if an environment's treewidth (a measure of its "thickness") exceeds a certain threshold, it must contain a large "wall" structure. They show that movement through such a wall can be simplified, allowing for the contraction of edges and the reduction of the environment's complexity without altering the reachability result.

Key Results

The study yields several significant theoretical breakthroughs:

  • FPT Algorithm: The problem is solvable in $k^{O(k)} \cdot n^{O(1)}$ time. For a fixed robot length, the complexity grows only polynomially with the environment size.
  • Shortest Path: The algorithm can identify the shortest sequence of moves required to reach the goal within the same FPT time bound.
  • Kernelization Limits: The SNAKE GAME is unlikely to admit a polynomial kernel, even on grid graphs, meaning there is no general way to "compress" large instances into small ones efficiently.
  • Treewidth Bound: The problem admits a treewidth-reduction procedure, ensuring that any instance can be transformed into an equivalent one where the environment's treewidth is bounded by a polynomial in $k$.

Conclusion

This work pioneers the study of parameterized complexity in motion planning. By shifting focus to the robot's length, the authors move the SNAKE GAME from the realm of PSPACE-completeness to fixed-parameter tractability. While the $k^{O(k)}$ factor remains a challenge for very long robots, this research provides a robust framework for future investigations into multi-agent snakes, dynamic environments, and potential algorithmic optimizations to reach $2^{O(k)}$ complexity.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study a motion-planning problem inspired by the game Snake that models scenarios like the transportation of linked wagons towed by a locomotor to the movement of a group of agents that travel in an ``ant-like'' fashion. Given a ``snake-like'' robot with initial and final positions in an environment modeled by a graph, our goal is to decide whether the robot can reach the final position from the initial position without intersecting itself. Already on grid graphs, this problem is PSPACE-complete [Biasi and Ophelders, 2018]. Nevertheless, we prove that even on general graphs, it is solvable in time k^{O(k)}|I|^{O(1)} where k is the size of the robot, and |I| is the input size. Towards this, we give a novel application of color-coding to sparsify the configuration graph of the problem. We also show that the problem is unlikely to have a polynomial kernel even on grid graphs, but it admits a treewidth-reduction procedure. To the best of our knowledge, the study of the parameterized complexity of motion problems has been~largely~neglected, thus our work is pioneering in this regard.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gupta2019parameterized,
  author = {Siddharth Gupta and Guy Sa'ar and Meirav Zehavi},
  title = {{The Parameterized Complexity of Motion Planning for Snake-Like Robots}},
  booktitle = {International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2019},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=zvFtzC5wvI},
}
Figure