The Necessity of the Field AC Withstand Voltage Test for GIS Operation

Shi Feng, Qinghao Wang, Dongwei Huang, Yan Shi, Tianshu Hai, Yanhai Huang, Guobin Liu, Ning Zhang, Enlu Wang, Xinyu Li, Dongpeng ShiAdvances 2015 · DOI

Abstract: Gas Insulated Switchgear (GIS) systems are the backbone of modern compact substations, yet their reliability is often compromised during transport and installation. This article illustrates the characteristics and proportion of GIS system failures and argues that field AC withstand voltage testing is a non-negotiable final step to identify defects like conductive dust, mechanical burrs, and loose fasteners that factory tests cannot predict.

Introduction

While GIS technology offers significant advantages over traditional open-air substations—including a smaller footprint and lower maintenance requirements—failures in these systems are often more catastrophic and harder to repair. A critical gap exists in the quality assurance pipeline: a GIS unit may pass every test in the factory, but the journey to the site and the subsequent assembly process introduce new risks. Mechanical vibrations during transport can loosen fasteners, and the "clean-room" conditions of a factory are difficult to replicate in the field. Even microscopic conductive particles or burrs on electrode surfaces can lead to insulation failure once the system is energized.

Analysis of GIS Failure Causes

Statistical analysis of GIS failures reveals that the transition from factory to field is the most vulnerable period for the equipment.

Distribution of GIS failure causes, highlighting the impact of installation processes.

As shown in the data, approximately 58% of GIS failures are directly related to the installation phase (40% attributed to poor installation processes and 18% to site contamination). This underscores that while the hardware itself is robust, the human element and environmental controls during assembly are the greatest risks to operational safety.

Methodology: Field AC Withstand Testing

To mitigate these risks, a rigorous field-testing protocol centered on the Variable Frequency Series Resonance Test is required. The procedure involves isolating high-voltage cables and transformers before following a two-stage voltage application process:

  1. Sophisticated Purification (Conditioning): This preliminary stage applies lower voltages to "clean" the internal environment. The electric field causes conductive particles to move into designated "particle traps" and ablates minor burrs on electrode surfaces.
  2. AC Withstand Test: Following purification, the actual test voltage ($U_t$) is applied for one minute to verify dielectric integrity.
The multi-stage voltage application sequence used for purification and final withstand testing.

Environmental factors significantly impact the efficiency of this test. Humidity can degrade the "Q value" (quality factor) of the resonance circuit by 30–40%, making dry, sunny conditions a requirement for accurate results.

Key Results and Case Studies

Field AC withstand tests have proven successful in identifying critical defects that escaped factory inspection. In one instance at a 66 kV substation, the test identified a rift in a disk insulator. In another case at a 220 kV substation, an arc-over occurred at 109 kV during commissioning. Had the system been put into service without this field test, it likely would have resulted in a major explosion.

Conclusion and Future Directions

Field AC withstand voltage testing is indispensable for the safe operation of GIS in power systems. While current methods are effective at identifying dielectric weaknesses, the primary limitation remains the difficulty of fault localization within the grounded metal shell. Future advancements should focus on integrating acoustic sensors and partial discharge monitoring to move beyond simple pass/fail metrics toward precise fault triangulation and predictive maintenance.

Summary updated

Abstract

This article illustrates the characteristics and proportion of GIS system failure through the introduction to GIS system structure and characteristics; In order to make the GIS in the safe operation of the power system, It is necessary to test AC withstand voltage at the scene.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{feng2015necessity,
  author = {Shi Feng and Qinghao Wang and Dongwei Huang and Yan Shi and Tianshu Hai and Yanhai Huang and Guobin Liu and Ning Zhang and Enlu Wang and Xinyu Li and Dongpeng Shi},
  title = {{The Necessity of the Field AC Withstand Voltage Test for GIS Operation}},
  booktitle = {Advances},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.2991/isrme-15.2015.424},
}
Figure