The Malaysian Historical Geographical Information System (MHGIS): The Case of Chinese Temples in Johor

Guan Thye Hue, Wei Kai Kui, Juhn Khai Klan Choo, Xin De Josephine Fong, Weikai Dong, Kenneth Dean, Ruo Lin, Meng Yu, Hean Cheong TaiReligions 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces the Malaysian Historical Geographical Information System (MHGIS) to quantitatively map and analyze the development of Chinese temples and beliefs in Johor, Malaysia. The study reveals a thriving and diverse religious landscape, contradicting notions of decline, and highlights the syncretic nature of Chinese folk religion in the region.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While research on Chinese communities in Malaysia exists, a comprehensive, systematic, and geographically detailed understanding of Chinese temples and their associated beliefs, particularly in Johor, has been lacking. Previous studies often focused on specific temples, dialect groups, or lacked a holistic approach. The authors aim to fill this gap by creating a robust historical GIS database (MHGIS) to provide a macro-level view of the evolution and distribution of Chinese religious sites and practices in Johor. This is crucial for understanding the cultural and spiritual landscape of the local Chinese community.

Methods

The core methodology involves the development and application of the Malaysian Historical Geographical Information System (MHGIS). This system is built upon the principles of Historical GIS (HGIS), a subfield of digital humanities that uses GIS technology for historical research. The authors conducted extensive fieldwork over three years, visiting 943 Chinese temples across all 10 districts of Johor. This involved photographing temples and inscriptions, collecting documents (meeting minutes, financial reports, etc.), and conducting interviews. The collected data was then systematically collated, coded, and input into the MHGIS. Quantitative analysis was performed using Excel and the MHGIS to map distributions, analyze establishment dates, and identify main deities. Historical anthropological theories and methods were employed to interpret the collected data from a bottom-up perspective.

Datasets

The primary dataset is the collection of data from 943 Chinese temples in Johor. This includes:

  • 20,489 photographs of temples and their interiors.
  • 20,964 pieces of temple artefacts and paper documents, such as statues of deities, inscription steles, couplet boards, paper documents, relics, and newspaper clippings.
  • Temple establishment dates (where available).
  • Main deities worshipped in each temple.

This comprehensive collection forms the foundation of the MHGIS database.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • A Thriving Religious Landscape: Contrary to perceptions of decline, especially for Daoist temples, the study shows a continuous increase in the establishment of new Chinese temples in Johor, indicating a vibrant and growing religious scene.
  • Syncretic Nature of Beliefs: Chinese folk religion in Johor is characterized by a strong syncretism, blending elements of Confucianism, Buddhism, and Daoism. Many temples do not fit neatly into a single category, reflecting a flexible and inclusive approach to faith.
  • Dominance of Folk Beliefs: Despite the increasing presence of orthodox Buddhist organizations, folk beliefs remain dominant, with most temples practicing a mix of Confucianism, Buddhism, and Daoism.
  • Importance of Local Deities: While deities originating from China are prevalent, the indigenous deity Tua Pek Kong holds significant importance and widespread worship across Johor, highlighting the adaptation of beliefs to the local context.
  • Geographical Concentration: Chinese temples are heavily concentrated in Johor Bahru, Batu Pahat, and Muar, correlating with historical settlement patterns driven by the Kangchu system and economic development.

Key Results

  • Temple Distribution: Johor Bahru has the highest concentration of Chinese temples (345 temples, 36.6%), followed by Batu Pahat (141 temples, 14.95%) and Muar (91 temples, 9.65%).
  • Temple Establishment Trends: Temple construction saw a significant increase in the 21st century, with 52 new temples built between 2000-2020, exceeding the number built in previous 50-year periods. The peak construction period was 1950-1999 (99 temples).
  • Main Deities: The most prominent main deities are Tua Pek Kong (11.7%), Gautama Buddha (10.4%), Guanyin (9.1%), and Guandi (6.2%).
  • Daoist Dominance: Over 80% of temples established in the 21st century are dedicated to Daoist deities, while only about 19% are dedicated to Buddhist deities.
  • Data Collection Scale: The research collected an unprecedented 20,489 photographs and 20,964 artefacts/documents, significantly surpassing previous efforts.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Gaps: Due to the nature of historical records and the passage of time, the exact year of establishment for many temples could not be determined (77.2% lacked definite answers). Similarly, identifying the primary deity was not always straightforward for all temples.
  • Geographical Coverage: While the study covers all 10 districts, the authors acknowledge that the field investigation in Mersing was less extensive, potentially missing some temples.
  • Future Work: The authors plan to continue enriching the MHGIS with more data, including historical maps from different periods. They also aim to expand the system to include other states in Malaysia, further improving Chinese studies in the region. Future scholars can leverage the MHGIS for macro-level analysis of belief spread, community networks, and the development of religious practices.

Summary updated

Abstract

This is a quantitative study of Chinese temples in Johor using temple data to show the development of Chinese religion in the state. The study finds that Chinese temples in Johor are dominated by a fusion of Confucianism, Buddhism and Daoism, with only a minority of orthodox Buddhism in existence. The broad range of Buddhist and Daoist deities shows the diversity and inclusiveness of the religion. In addition, the number of newly created temples in the state is still on the rise, contradicting the perception that they, especially Daoist ones, are on the decline. The quantitative data collation and analysis of Chinese temples in Johor not only will reflect more accurately the development of religion and beliefs of the local Chinese community, but also is an attempt to construct Malaysia Historical Geographic Information System (MHGIS). We hope that in the future, we can make use of the convenience of the data humanities system to make a more macro and holistic exploration and development of the study of Chinese temples and beliefs in Malaysia.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hue2023malaysian,
  author = {Guan Thye Hue and Wei Kai Kui and Juhn Khai Klan Choo and Xin De Josephine Fong and Weikai Dong and Kenneth Dean and Ruo Lin and Meng Yu and Hean Cheong Tai},
  title = {{The Malaysian Historical Geographical Information System (MHGIS): The Case of Chinese Temples in Johor}},
  booktitle = {Religions},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/rel14030336},
}
Figure