The Long-Term Effects of Labor Market Entry in a Recession: Evidence from the Asian Financial Crisis

Eleanor Jawon Choi, Jae-Woo Choi, Hyelim Son

Introduction

The "scarring effect" is a well-documented phenomenon in labor economics: individuals who enter the workforce during an economic downturn often face lower wages and reduced career prospects for years. However, most existing literature focuses on relatively mild recessions and short-to-medium-term career trajectories. This study investigates the profound and lasting impact of a major economic shock—the 1997-1998 Asian Financial Crisis—on the life trajectories of South Korean graduates. By tracking cohorts over two decades, the research reveals that the consequences of an "unlucky" start extend far beyond the office, permanently reshaping family formation, wealth accumulation, and living arrangements.

The 1997-1998 Asian Financial Crisis

The Asian Financial Crisis provided a unique natural experiment. South Korea experienced a sharp, unexpected spike in unemployment, creating a clear divide between cohorts who graduated just before the meltdown and those who entered a collapsed labor market. Unlike typical business cycle fluctuations, this crisis was a systemic shock that fundamentally altered the country's economic landscape, providing a rigorous testing ground for the long-term persistence of labor market scars.

Methodology and Data

To capture these long-term dynamics, the researchers utilized the Korean Labor and Income Panel Study (KLIPS), pooling 20 waves of data from 1998 to 2017. This longitudinal approach allowed them to track individuals from their initial entry into the labor market through their mid-40s. For increased robustness, the findings were cross-referenced with the Economically Active Population Survey (EAPS) and 2% samples from the 2010 and 2015 South Korean censuses.

The study employed a "scarring" regression model, using a cubic function to detrend the data and account for secular shifts in fertility and education. To address potential endogenous selection—the possibility that students might delay graduation to avoid the recession—the authors used an Instrumental Variables (IV) approach. They used a student's "predicted" graduation year (based on age) as a proxy for their actual entry into the labor market, ensuring the results were not biased by individual choices to stay in school.

Key Findings: The Gender Divergence

The research highlights a stark divergence in how men and women responded to the crisis, driven by different economic mechanisms.

Men: The Income Effect

For men, the "income effect" was the primary driver of long-term outcomes. A 1 percentage point increase in the unemployment rate at graduation led to a 1.9% lower employment probability and 2.6% lower earnings over the first decade of their careers. These financial setbacks had profound social consequences:

  • Marriage and Fertility: Lower earnings made men less "marriageable" or less able to afford the costs associated with starting a family. This resulted in a 3.1% decline in marriage rates and a 2.5% decline in fertility.
  • Permanent Scars: While the wage penalty for men eventually dissipated after approximately 12 years, the "social" scars—the missed opportunities for marriage and fatherhood—appeared to be permanent.

Women: The Substitution Effect

In contrast, women experienced a shorter labor market hit (disappearing within two years) but a significant shift in life choices driven by the "substitution effect." When the opportunity cost of staying home was low due to a lack of high-quality jobs, women pivoted toward family formation:

  • Accelerated Motherhood: A 1 percentage point higher unemployment rate led women to accelerate their first childbirth by 0.36 years and have 0.05 more children on average.
  • Marriage as Insurance: Interestingly, female recession graduates were more likely to marry spouses from "advantaged" economic backgrounds, suggesting that marriage served as a form of insurance against initial labor market instability.

Wealth Accumulation and Consumption Smoothing

The study also examined how these cohorts managed their financial health. Despite the significant drop in earnings, recession-era graduates did not necessarily experience a corresponding drop in their standard of living. Instead, they engaged in "consumption smoothing":

  • Asset Depletion: Men from recession cohorts held significantly lower levels of financial assets and were less likely to be homeowners even 13+ years after graduation.
  • The "Bank of Mom and Dad": Many men moved back in with their parents to mitigate the financial impact of the crisis, relying on family support to maintain expenditure levels.

Conclusion and Implications

The findings suggest that the timing of labor market entry is a critical determinant of long-term welfare. While the immediate labor market penalties may eventually fade, the secondary effects on family structure and wealth accumulation can persist for a lifetime. This research underscores the importance of policy interventions that support young workers during major economic shocks, not just to protect their immediate earnings, but to safeguard their long-term social and financial well-being.

Future research may further explore the intergenerational spillover effects, such as how the "unlucky" start of a child affects the retirement and mental health of their parents. Additionally, as the "Great Recession" cohorts in the West age, it will be vital to see if these patterns hold true in different cultural contexts where social norms around breadwinning and coresidence may differ.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{choi2020long,
  author = {Eleanor Jawon Choi and Jae-Woo Choi and Hyelim Son},
  title = {{The Long-Term Effects of Labor Market Entry in a Recession: Evidence from the Asian Financial Crisis}},
  booktitle = {Labour},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1016/j.labeco.2020.101926},
}
Figure