TL;DR
This study reveals that a stronger "risk culture" in a capital market is linked to better performance for international joint-venture securities (IJVS) operating within it. Specifically, IJVS in China, which exhibits a stronger risk culture than developed markets, perform better when their foreign shareholders' risk culture aligns more closely with China's. Conversely, a larger "risk culture distance" between foreign investors and the Chinese market significantly hinders IJVS performance.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The paper addresses the persistent underperformance of International Joint-Venture Securities (IJVS) in emerging markets, particularly China. While many factors influencing cross-border cooperation have been studied, the role of "soft factors" like culture, and specifically "risk culture," in explaining the performance of IJVS in capital markets remains underexplored. The authors highlight that despite the opportunities presented by China's growing financial market, IJVS have often struggled, leading to losses. This research aims to bridge this gap by investigating how the cultural backgrounds of participants, particularly their approach to risk, influence the success of these joint ventures.
Methods
The researchers employed a quantitative approach using Ordinary Least Squares (OLS) regression to analyze the impact of capital market risk culture on IJVS performance.
- Performance Measurement: They used two key metrics:
- Accounting Performance: Measured by Return on Assets (ROA).
- Technical Efficiency (TE): Calculated using Stochastic Frontier Analysis (SFA), which distinguishes between efficiency and random disturbances.
- Risk Culture Measurement: The core innovation is their definition and measurement of "risk culture." They define it as the psychological process participants use to judge uncertainty in a specific capital market. This is operationalized by measuring the standard deviation of unobserved implicit factors that explain stock price volatility, essentially capturing the market's inherent uncertainty and participants' tolerance for it.
- Cultural Distance: This was calculated as the difference in risk culture between the home country of foreign shareholders and the Chinese capital market.
- Control Variables: A comprehensive set of control variables were included to account for firm-specific factors (size, leverage, age, ownership structure) and external environmental factors (government ownership, media sentiment, local economic conditions).
- Robustness Checks: To ensure the reliability of their findings, the authors conducted several robustness tests, including:
- Using a dummy variable for risk culture distance (above or below the median).
- Conducting a matched-sample analysis, comparing IJVS with similar Chinese securities companies.
- Employing an instrumental variable (geographic distance) to address potential endogeneity issues.
Datasets
The study utilized data from:
- Annual reports of securities companies: Published by the Securities Association of China (SAC) for the period 2006-2016. This provided financial statements, ownership structures, and other relevant firm-level data.
- World Bank Database: Used for macroeconomic data (GDP growth, stock market returns, etc.) to measure capital market risk culture.
- CNRDS database: Used to collect negative news reports (fraud, default) for securities companies.
- National Bureau of Statistics: Provided local economic data.
- CEPII database: Used for geographic distance data as an instrumental variable.
The final sample consisted of 10 International Joint-Venture Securities (IJVS) and 109 securities companies in total.
Key Insights and Ideas
- China's Stronger Risk Culture: The study posits and finds evidence that China's capital market exhibits a stronger risk culture compared to developed countries. This is attributed to factors like policy uncertainty, an imperfect legal system, and a more prominent informal system, leading participants to have higher uncertainty tolerance.
- Culture as a Performance Driver: The research strongly suggests that cultural factors, specifically risk culture, are not just peripheral but are significant drivers of financial institution performance in emerging markets.
- The Double-Edged Sword of Diversification: While expanding business scope (e.g., obtaining more licenses) is generally seen as positive, the study found that for IJVS, this diversification can amplify the negative impact of risk culture distance, suggesting that a lack of cultural alignment becomes more detrimental when operations become more complex.
- Beyond Financial Metrics: The paper emphasizes that traditional financial performance metrics alone don't tell the whole story; understanding the underlying cultural dynamics is crucial for explaining success or failure.
Key Results
- IJVS Underperformance: The study confirmed that IJVS generally exhibit lower accounting performance (ROA) and technical efficiency compared to their Chinese counterparts.
- Positive Impact of Stronger Risk Culture: Securities companies operating in the Chinese market with a stronger shareholder risk culture demonstrated better ROA and technical efficiency. This supports Hypothesis 2.
- Negative Impact of Risk Culture Distance: A larger difference in risk culture between foreign shareholders and the Chinese capital market was found to be significantly negatively correlated with IJVS performance (ROA and TE). This supports Hypothesis 3. The larger the cultural gap, the poorer the performance.
- Robustness: The findings remained consistent across various robustness checks, including using a dummy variable for culture distance, matched samples, and instrumental variables.
Limitations and Future Work
- Sample Size: The authors acknowledge that the sample size, particularly for IJVS (10 firms), is relatively small and does not cover the most recent years due to the labor-intensive data collection process. They also note that some IJVS went bankrupt or left the market after 2016.
- Performance Metrics: While ROA and TE are standard, the authors suggest that incorporating other performance indicators like Economic Value Added (EVA) and alpha could provide a more robust conclusion.
- Endogeneity: Despite efforts to mitigate endogeneity (control variables, fixed effects, instrumental variables), the authors concede that other factors like CEO characteristics (compensation, delta) could still influence performance and are difficult to control for with their dataset.
- Future Research Directions: The paper suggests future research could explore the impact of corporate social responsibility on performance and delve deeper into the endogeneity issues by collecting data on CEO characteristics. It also opens avenues for understanding how cultural factors influence FDI sustainability more broadly.
Summary updated