The Influence of Everyday Acoustic Environments on the Challenging Behavior in Dementia: A Participatory Observation Study in Nursing Homes

Arezoo Talebzadeh, Ine Decoutere, Tara Vander Mynsbrugge, Dick Botteldooren, Paul Devos, Francesco Aletta, Dominique Van de Velde, Patricia De VriendtInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how everyday sounds in nursing homes influence challenging behaviors (CB) in people with dementia (PwD). By using participatory observations and a phenomenological-hermeneutical analysis, the research reveals that CB is highly individualized and triggered by an excess or lack of stimuli, with familiar sounds promoting safety and reducing agitation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Dementia is a growing global health challenge, and a significant symptom is "challenging behavior" (CB), which can be distressing for both individuals with dementia and their caregivers. While pharmacological interventions exist, non-pharmacological approaches are preferred. This paper focuses on the often-overlooked influence of the acoustic environment on CB in nursing homes. Existing research on environmental factors is limited, and specifically, the impact of everyday sounds on PwD's behavior remains underexplored. The authors aim to bridge this gap by understanding how the sonic environment contributes to or alleviates CB, paving the way for more supportive living spaces.

Methods

The study employed an ethnographic research design, involving 24/7 participatory observations over a period of 420 hours across nine nursing homes. Researchers, acting as integrated members of the care team, observed 35 residents with dementia. The observations focused on how residents reacted to everyday environmental sounds. The collected data, in the form of detailed field notes, were then analyzed using a phenomenological-hermeneutical method. This involved three phases:

  1. Naïve Understanding: Initial immersion in the data to grasp the overall experience.
  2. Structural Analysis: Breaking down transcripts into "meaning units" based on the Antecedent-Behavior–Consequence (ABC) model, condensing these units, and identifying subthemes and themes related to sound and behavior.
  3. Comprehensive Understanding: Synthesizing the findings to develop a holistic understanding of the relationship between the acoustic environment and CB.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized observational data collected directly from participants in nursing homes.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Individualized Triggers: The study strongly emphasizes that what triggers CB is highly personal. There's no one-size-fits-all solution, as factors like personality, the time of day, and the resident's current state significantly influence their reaction to sounds.
  • The Dichotomy of Stimuli: CB is linked to both an excess and a lack of auditory stimuli. Overstimulation can lead to agitation and a desire to escape, while understimulation can result in anxiety, fear, and a need to create one's own stimuli.
  • Familiarity Breeds Safety: Familiar and recognizable sounds (e.g., a doorbell, familiar voices) tend to create a sense of safety and predictability, thereby reducing CB. Conversely, strange or unexpected sounds can be unsettling and trigger negative reactions.
  • Sound as a Signal: CB can be interpreted as a signal that a person's well-being is threatened, often due to environmental factors like sound. It's not solely a symptom of dementia but an indirect consequence of the environment.
  • The "Ecological Equation": The findings align with ecological models suggesting that behavior is a product of the interaction between an individual and their environment, highlighting the importance of the sonic environment in this equation.

Key Results

  • Four Personae: The analysis identified four distinct "personae" based on residents' capacity to interpret sounds and react autonomously. These personae illustrate the spectrum of responses to the acoustic environment, ranging from individuals who can interpret and react appropriately to those who struggle with both.
  • Predictable Reactions to Familiar Sounds: When sounds were familiar and expected, residents' reactions were more predictable and less likely to result in CB. For instance, a resident might calmly acknowledge a familiar sound without agitation.
  • Anxiety from Silence: Periods of silence or monotony in nursing homes were observed to lead to anxiety and mistrust, prompting residents to engage in behaviors like talking to themselves or manipulating objects to create stimuli.
  • Restlessness from Noise: Conversely, loud and heterogeneous sound environments were found to create feelings of suspicion, restlessness, and anger, leading residents to seek quieter spaces or exhibit agitated behaviors.

Limitations and Future Work

  • No Audiometric Testing: Participants were not subjected to audiometric tests, which could have provided objective data on their hearing capabilities. While ethical considerations and practical difficulties with PwD were cited, this limits a complete understanding of auditory perception.
  • Dynamic Nature of Observations: The 24-hour observations were split into three time slots on different days, potentially leading to missed data or overlooked links between behavior and earlier events. The dynamic nature of observations also made it impossible to use video recordings for confirmation due to ethical concerns.
  • Limited Sample for Specific Findings: The observation that a significant other's presence could improve coping in complex sound environments was only noted in one participant. This suggests a need for further research to validate this finding and explore its broader applicability.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest future research should focus on:
  • Developing a valid model for enhancing quality of life and modifying behavior through soundscapes.
  • Investigating the specific types of sounds that are familiar and the capacity of PwD to interpret and react to them to optimize soundscape design.
  • Exploring the ratios of different sounds, sound volume, and their influence on CB.
  • Studying acoustic comfort in nursing homes with deaf and hard-of-hearing PwD.
  • Investigating the impact of high staff turnover on residents' sense of safety.
  • Designing experimental studies to further explore the relationship between stimulation levels and CB, while carefully considering ethical implications.

Summary updated

Abstract

Challenging behavior (CB) is a group of behaviors, reactions and symptoms due to dementia, which can be challenging for the caregivers. The study aims to research the influence of acoustics on CB in people with dementia (PwD). An ethnographic method was used to study the daily life of PwD in their nursing homes with a specific focus on how people react to everyday environmental sounds. Thirty-five residents were included in the sample based on purposeful, homogeneous group characteristics and sampling. Empirical data were collected using 24/7 participatory observations. The collected data were analyzed using a phenomenological-hermeneutical method: a naïve understanding, a structural analysis and a comprehensive understanding. The result shows that the onset of CB depends on whether the resident feels safe and is triggered by an excess or lack of stimuli. The excess or shortage of stimuli and whether and when it affects a person is personal. It depends on various factors, the person's state and the time of day, the nature of the stimuli, familiarity, or strangeness is also a determining factor for the onset and progression of CB. The results can form an essential basis for developing soundscapes to make the PwD feel safe and reduce CB.
BibTeX
@article{talebzadeh2023influence,
  author = {Arezoo Talebzadeh and Ine Decoutere and Tara Vander Mynsbrugge and Dick Botteldooren and Paul Devos and Francesco Aletta and Dominique Van de Velde and Patricia De Vriendt},
  title = {{The Influence of Everyday Acoustic Environments on the Challenging Behavior in Dementia: A Participatory Observation Study in Nursing Homes}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph20054191},
}
Figure