The Impatient May Use Limited Optimism to Minimize Regret

Michaël Cadilhac, Guillermo A. Pérez, Marie van den Bogaard

TL;DR

This paper introduces a new class of strategies called "optipess" for agents in discounted-sum games. These strategies balance optimism about the environment's cooperation with a fallback to worst-case scenarios, allowing them to minimize regret. The authors develop algorithms to compute this minimal regret, showing it's decidable in PSpace.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In reinforcement learning and game theory, agents often interact with environments where future rewards are discounted. A key challenge is how an agent should act when the environment's behavior is uncertain. Agents might regret past decisions if they realize a different choice would have yielded a better outcome, especially if the environment was more cooperative or adversarial than initially assumed. This paper tackles the problem of quantifying and minimizing this "regret" for an agent, particularly in the context of discounted-sum games. The authors aim to find strategies that are not only rational in hindsight (minimizing regret) but also robust against various environmental behaviors.

Methods

The core of the paper's contribution lies in defining and analyzing "optipess" strategies. These are a specific type of strategy that first employs a "best-case optimal" (SBO) approach, assuming the environment is helpful, and then switches to a "worst-case optimal" (SWO) approach after a certain time threshold. The paper then delves into the computational aspects:

  • Regret Minimization: They leverage existing work on admissible and regret-minimal strategies, showing that optipess strategies are both.
  • Algorithm Development: The authors develop algorithms to compute the minimum possible regret for a given game. This involves identifying "short witnesses" (histories of bounded length) that capture the essential regret-inducing scenarios.
  • Complexity Analysis: They prove that determining whether a strategy minimizes regret is decidable in PSpace. This is achieved by developing NP algorithms for checking regret bounds and leveraging properties of arithmetic circuits for representing complex values.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical game models and algorithmic complexity rather than empirical evaluation on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Optipess Strategies: The novel idea is that an agent can be "impatient" by initially assuming the best (cooperative environment) but also "prudent" by having a fallback to a worst-case optimal strategy after a certain point. This "limited optimism" is key to minimizing regret.
  • Regret as a Measure of Hindsight: The paper formalizes regret as the maximal difference between the value achieved by a strategy and the best possible value achievable against any environment.
  • Short Witnesses for Regret: A crucial insight is that the regret of a strategy can be determined by examining only a limited number of specific game histories, rather than all infinitely many possibilities. This significantly simplifies computation.
  • PSpace Decidability: The paper establishes that the problem of finding the minimum regret for a discounted-sum game is decidable within polynomial space, a significant theoretical result.

Key Results

  • Optipess Strategies are Regret-Minimal and Admissible: The paper proves that optipess strategies achieve the minimum possible regret and are also admissible (not dominated by any other strategy).
  • PSpace Algorithm for Minimum Regret: The authors show that determining the minimum regret of a game is decidable in PSpace.
  • NP Algorithm for Regret Bound Checking: An NP algorithm is provided to check if the regret entailed by a given time-switching strategy exceeds a certain value.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Exact Complexity Open: While the paper shows the problem is decidable in PSpace, the exact complexity remains an open question. They pose a specific problem related to polynomial sums that, if solved, could potentially refine the complexity bounds.
  • Generalization: The paper focuses on discounted-sum games. Future work could explore whether these concepts and algorithms extend to other types of games or more complex environments.
  • Practical Implementation: While theoretical complexity is addressed, the practical implementation of these algorithms for very large games might still be challenging due to the inherent complexity of game theory problems.

Summary updated

Abstract

Discounted-sum games provide a formal model for the study of reinforcement learning, where the agent is enticed to get rewards early since later rewards are discounted. When the agent interacts with the environment, she may realize that, with hindsight, she could have increased her reward by playing differently: this difference in outcomes constitutes her regret value. The agent may thus elect to follow a regret- minimal strategy. In this paper, it is shown that (1) there always exist regret-minimal strategies that are admissible—a strategy being inadmissible if there is another strategy that always performs better; (2) computing the minimum possible regret or checking that a strategy is regret-minimal can be done in , disregarding the computational cost of numerical analysis (otherwise, this bound becomes ).
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cadilhac2019impatient,
  author = {Michaël Cadilhac and Guillermo A. Pérez and Marie van den Bogaard},
  title = {{The Impatient May Use Limited Optimism to Minimize Regret}},
  booktitle = {FoSSaCS},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1007/978-3-030-17127-8\_8},
}
Figure