Abstract
Objectives: In Appalachia, tobacco smoking rates are significantly higher than the United States average, and many of the comorbidities that exist with tobacco are prominent. The researchers investigated the impact of tobacco smoking on patients for one year of health outcomes at our resident primary care clinic. Methods: The present study examined outpatient clinic charts and hospital records for a calendar year to determine patient self-reported tobacco rates. Patient medical comorbidities were tracked as well as rates of hospital utilization during the calendar year, and those figures were compared for a group of 90 patients who currently smoke and another group of 90 patients who have never smoked. Results: Tobacco smokers in the present study were more likely to have a history of several medical comorbidities including COPD, musculoskeletal problems, psychiatric treatment, and substance abuse issues. Additionally, tobacco smokers were more likely to have visited the emergency department and to have been admitted to the hospital during the year. Conclusions: The problem of tobacco smoking is complex and primary care clinics provide a wealth of information to investigate numerous comorbid concerns. Consistent with prior research, tobacco users in this study were at greater risk for many medical problems.
Introduction
Tobacco use remains a critical public health challenge, particularly in Appalachia where smoking rates significantly exceed national averages. In West Virginia, the smoking rate is approximately 27%, compared to the U.S. average of 17%. While the general risks are known, localized data from primary care settings is essential to understand the specific burden on healthcare resources and the interplay with regional comorbidities. This study utilizes Electronic Health Record (EHR) data to move beyond the limitations of self-reported telephone surveys, providing a granular look at health outcomes over a 12-month period.
Methods
A retrospective chart review was conducted at a family medicine residency clinic in West Virginia. From a total clinic population of 8,024, a cohort of 180 patients was selected, consisting of 90 current smokers and 90 never-smokers. Inclusion criteria required patients to be at least 18 years old, have at least one year of history with the clinic, and have completed at least two provider visits and two sets of lab results within the study year.
Data was extracted using a 58-point collection sheet covering demographics, clinical diagnoses (e.g., COPD, CAD), physiological markers (BMI, blood pressure, lipids), and resource utilization (ED visits, hospitalizations). Statistical analysis employed Chi-square tests for nominal data and MANOVAs for longitudinal measures.
Results
Demographics and Comorbidities
The study cohort was balanced by smoking status, with both groups showing similar age profiles (mean ~55 years). However, significant differences emerged in mental health history. Smokers were substantially more likely to have a psychiatric diagnosis (78% vs 60%) and a history of substance abuse (18% vs 2%).
Beyond behavioral health, physical comorbidities were starkly different. COPD was present in 40% of smokers compared to 2% of non-smokers. Musculoskeletal issues were also more prevalent in the smoking group (74% vs 49%). Interestingly, smokers had a lower average BMI (30.8) than never-smokers (35.1), though the authors caution that this does not equate to lower mortality risk.
Resource Utilization and Clinical Outcomes
The most dramatic findings concerned hospital resource use. Over the one-year period, smokers utilized emergency and inpatient services at significantly higher rates:
- Emergency Department (ED) Visits: 1.47 per year for smokers vs. 0.67 for never-smokers.
- Hospital Admissions: 0.70 for smokers vs. 0.28 for never-smokers.
- Hospital Days: 1.77 days for smokers vs. 0.46 days for never-smokers.
Clinical markers showed an unexpected trend: smokers demonstrated greater improvements in HDL cholesterol and diastolic blood pressure over the year. This is attributed to a "room for improvement" effect, where smokers began at a much poorer baseline, allowing for more visible gains through primary care interventions.
Discussion and Treatment Data
The high rates of counseling (99% by medical assistants) contrast with the low rates of pharmacological treatment (8%) for tobacco cessation. This gap highlights a significant opportunity for improving integrated care models within primary care settings.
Limitations and Future Directions
The study is limited by its one-year duration and reliance on self-reported smoking status within the EHR. Future research should leverage longer-term EHR data to track whether the utilization gap continues to widen. The findings underscore the necessity of addressing tobacco use not as an isolated habit, but as part of a complex web of psychiatric and physical comorbidities common in high-risk regions like Appalachia.
Summary updated