Provider-Patient Discussions About Smoking and the Impact of Lung Cancer Screening Guidelines: NHIS 2011–2015

Jinhai Huo, Tong Han Chung, Bumyang Kim, Ashish A. Deshmukh, Ramzi G. Salloum, Jiang BianJournal of General Internal Medicine 2019 · DOI

Introduction

Smoking remains the leading preventable cause of death in the United States. Despite numerous policy initiatives aimed at increasing cessation rates—including the Affordable Care Act (ACA) and "Meaningful Use" electronic health record (EHR) requirements—the frequency of clinical discussions regarding smoking cessation has remained a point of concern. This study, published in the Journal of General Internal Medicine, evaluates the prevalence and trends of these life-saving conversations between 2011 and 2015, a period marked by the introduction of new lung cancer screening (LCS) guidelines.

Methods

Researchers performed a secondary analysis of the National Health Interview Survey (NHIS) from 2011 to 2015. The study population included 30,132 current smokers, representing a weighted national population of approximately 40.1 million individuals. The primary outcome was whether patients recalled a healthcare provider discussing smoking with them in the past year. Data were analyzed using the Cochran-Armitage trend test and multivariable logistic regression to identify key predictors of these discussions, controlling for demographics, health status, and insurance coverage.

The study found a statistically significant but clinically modest increase in the rate of provider-patient discussions about smoking. In 2011, 51.3% of current smokers reported having such a discussion; by 2015, this figure had risen to 55.4%.

Overall trend in provider-patient smoking discussions from 2011 to 2015.

While the upward trend is positive, the growth rate of approximately 1% per year suggests that top-down policy changes have a slow impact on clinical practice. Alarmingly, as of 2015, nearly 45% of current smokers still reported no recent discussion about quitting with a healthcare professional.

The Impact of Lung Cancer Screening Guidelines

A major focus of the study was the impact of lung cancer screening (LCS) guidelines. In 2015, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) began covering low-dose CT scans for high-risk smokers, a process that mandates a "shared decision-making" visit including cessation counseling.

The data showed that patients eligible for LCS (based on age and smoking history) were significantly more likely to have a discussion than low-risk or younger smokers.

Smoking discussion rates stratified by lung cancer screening eligibility.

However, a notable "LCS Gap" exists: 15% of patients who actually underwent lung cancer screening could not recall a single discussion about quitting smoking. This suggests that even when counseling is a reimbursement requirement, it may be too brief or perfunctory to be memorable for the patient.

Predictors and Disparities

The study identified several key predictors of receiving cessation counseling:

  • Healthcare Access: The strongest predictor was the frequency of office visits. Patients with six or more visits per year were over 11 times more likely to have a discussion than those with no visits.
  • Insurance Status: Uninsured patients had the lowest rates of discussion (31.9%), while those with public insurance had the highest (65.4%), likely reflecting differences in access to primary care.
  • Racial Disparities: Hispanic smokers were significantly less likely (OR 0.68) to report these discussions compared to non-Hispanic whites, highlighting persistent barriers such as language and cultural norms.

Conclusion and Limitations

While policy shifts like the ACA and LCS guidelines have moved the needle, the majority of smokers still do not receive adequate cessation counseling. The study is limited by its reliance on patient self-reporting, which is subject to recall bias. A doctor may mention smoking briefly, but if the patient does not perceive it as a meaningful "discussion," the clinical impact may be lost.

Future efforts should focus on integrating high-quality, memorable cessation counseling into routine clinical workflows, particularly for high-risk, minority, and uninsured populations who currently face the greatest gaps in care.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{huo2019provider,
  author = {Jinhai Huo and Tong Han Chung and Bumyang Kim and Ashish A. Deshmukh and Ramzi G. Salloum and Jiang Bian},
  title = {{Provider-Patient Discussions About Smoking and the Impact of Lung Cancer Screening Guidelines: NHIS 2011–2015}},
  journal = {Journal of General Internal Medicine},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1007/s11606-019-05111-6},
}
Figure