TL;DR
This study investigates how public and market-based science and technology (S&T) finance impacts collaborative innovation in China's Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei region. It reveals that the effectiveness of S&T finance is not linear but depends crucially on a region's "absorptive capacity" (its technological and economic strength), exhibiting distinct threshold effects.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei (BTH) region, a key economic hub in China, faces challenges in fostering collaborative innovation due to significant disparities in innovation resources and capabilities among its constituent areas. While S&T finance is seen as a crucial tool to promote the flow of capital, technology, and talent, its actual impact on regional collaborative innovation is complex. Specifically, the paper questions whether the influence of S&T finance is uniform or if it varies based on a region's ability to absorb and utilize external knowledge and resources. This gap in understanding the nuanced relationship between S&T finance, regional development, and innovation capacity is what the authors aim to address.
Methods
The researchers employed a dynamic panel threshold model to analyze the impact of S&T finance on regional collaborative innovation. This model is particularly suited for capturing non-linear relationships and potential endogeneity issues. They used regional absorptive capacity, broken down into technological level and economic base, as threshold variables. This approach allows them to identify specific "tipping points" where the effect of S&T finance changes. The model was estimated using a generalized method of moments (GMM) approach, which helps address potential endogeneity problems.
Datasets
The study utilized provincial panel data for the Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei region spanning from 2009 to 2020. The data sources included:
- China Statistical Yearbook
- China Statistical Yearbook of S&T
- China Statistical Yearbook of High-tech Industries
- National Bureau of Statistics
- China Financial Yearbook
- China Regional Financial Operation Report
- China Provincial Marketization Index Report
Key Insights and Ideas
- S&T Finance Isn't a Monolith: Public S&T finance and market S&T finance have distinct, even opposing, effects. Public finance can sometimes hinder innovation, while market finance generally promotes it.
- Absorptive Capacity is Key: A region's ability to absorb and utilize new knowledge and resources (its "absorptive capacity") is a critical determinant of how effective S&T finance will be.
- Thresholds Matter: The impact of S&T finance isn't constant. There are specific levels of technological and economic development where the influence of finance shifts dramatically.
- Public Finance's Double-Edged Sword: Public S&T finance can initially inhibit innovation, especially in regions with low absorptive capacity. However, as capacity increases, this inhibitory effect weakens.
- Market Finance's Growing Power: Market S&T finance's positive impact on innovation tends to increase with a region's technological advancement. Its effect also shifts from negative to positive as the economic base strengthens.
Key Results
- Low Overall Innovation: The overall level of regional collaborative innovation in the Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei region is found to be low.
- Public S&T Finance: Generally shows an inhibitory role on regional collaborative innovation. However, this inhibition weakens as absorptive capacity (both technological and economic) increases, suggesting a potential for positive impact at higher capacity levels.
- Market S&T Finance: Positively affects regional collaborative innovation. Its positive influence grows with improvements in the technological level. For the economic base, its effect shifts from negative to positive as the economic base strengthens, indicating that a certain level of economic development is needed for market finance to be truly beneficial.
- Double Threshold Effects: Both public and market S&T finance exhibit significant double threshold effects related to absorptive capacity, meaning there are two distinct "tipping points" where their impact changes.
Limitations and Future Work
- Regional Specificity: The study focuses on the Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei region. While insightful, the findings might not be directly generalizable to other regions with different economic structures or innovation ecosystems.
- Data Granularity: The paper uses provincial-level data. More granular data (e.g., city-level) could provide finer insights into the variations within the region.
- Future Work: The authors suggest that future research should continue to explore the dynamic changes in regional absorptive capacity and how these interact with different S&T finance models. They also highlight the need to consider the interplay between government policy and market mechanisms in optimizing S&T finance for regional collaborative innovation.
Summary updated