The impact of bilateral ongoing activity on evoked responses in mouse cortex

Daisuke Shimaoka, Nicholas A. Steinmetz, Kenneth D. Harris, Matteo Carandini

TL;DR

This study reveals that spontaneous, bilateral brain activity in mice significantly influences how their cortex responds to visual stimuli, accounting for a large portion of trial-to-trial variability. This ongoing bilateral activity interacts additively with evoked responses, impacting neural processing but not the animals' ability to make perceptual decisions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Neuroscience has long grappled with the significant variability observed in neural responses, even when presented with identical stimuli. This variability is a major hurdle in understanding how the brain processes information and makes decisions. While spontaneous "ongoing activity" in the brain has been implicated, its precise role, especially when it's synchronized across hemispheres, remains unclear. Specifically, researchers wanted to know:

  • To what extent does this bilateral ongoing activity contribute to the variability in sensory responses?
  • Does this bilateral activity persist during sensory stimulation, or is it suppressed?
  • How does this bilateral activity interact with the responses evoked by stimuli (e.g., additively or multiplicatively)?
  • Does this ongoing bilateral activity affect an animal's actual behavior and perception?

Methods

The researchers employed widefield optical imaging in awake mice to monitor neural activity across both cortical hemispheres simultaneously. This technique allowed them to observe large-scale brain activity patterns. They used two types of genetically encoded indicators:

  • Voltage sensors (VSFP Butterfly 1.2): These report on subthreshold membrane potential fluctuations, offering a glimpse into the underlying neural dynamics.
  • Calcium indicators (GCaMP6): These report on neuronal spiking activity, providing a measure of more direct neural output.

Mice were trained on a visual detection task, where they had to report the location of a visual stimulus. This allowed the researchers to study neural activity both during a baseline "pre-stimulus" period and during active task engagement. They developed sophisticated data processing techniques to isolate and analyze the bilateral and unilateral components of the neural signals, including methods to account for potential artifacts and hemodynamic signals.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from transgenic mice engineered to express voltage and calcium indicators in specific neuronal populations. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, the research generated novel data from experiments designed to address specific hypotheses.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bilateral Brain Activity is Pervasive: Spontaneous neural activity is not confined to one hemisphere but is strongly synchronized across both, especially in areas closer to the midline of the brain.
  • Ongoing Activity Drives Variability: This bilateral ongoing activity is a primary driver of the variability observed in sensory responses, explaining a substantial portion of the differences in neural activity from trial to trial.
  • Activity Persists Through Stimulation: Crucially, bilateral ongoing activity doesn't disappear when a stimulus is presented. Instead, it continues and often "swamps" the weaker, unilateral visual responses.
  • Additive Interaction is Key: The way ongoing bilateral activity combines with stimulus-evoked responses is predominantly additive. This means the ongoing activity simply shifts the baseline level of response, rather than multiplying it or interacting in more complex ways.
  • Perception is Robust to Bilateral Fluctuations: Despite significantly influencing neural activity, bilateral ongoing fluctuations did not appear to affect the mice's ability to make correct perceptual decisions in the visual task. This suggests the brain has mechanisms to filter out or ignore this bilateral noise when making choices.

Key Results

  • Bilateral ongoing fluctuations accounted for up to 60% of the trial-by-trial variance in observed neural signals.
  • The degree of bilateral symmetry in ongoing activity varied across cortical areas, being strongest in somatosensory and medial visual areas and decreasing with distance from the midline.
  • In the secondary motor cortex (M2), bilateral correlation was significantly reduced during task engagement compared to a passive state.
  • An additive model accurately predicted observed neural activity, with the bilateral component being far more influential than the visually evoked component alone. For example, in area PM, the additive model explained 58% of variance, while the visually evoked response alone explained only 12%.
  • Behavioral analysis showed no significant difference in performance (correct choices or no-go responses) when comparing trials with high versus low bilateral ongoing activity. This held true even when analyzing different visual areas or when ongoing activity patterns resembled visual responses.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their study focused on mice and that findings might differ in other species. While they propose that downstream readout mechanisms might ignore bilateral fluctuations for perceptual decisions, this remains a hypothesis. Future work could explore this by using optogenetic stimulation to directly manipulate bilateral activity and observe its impact on behavior. Additionally, investigating the specific neural circuits and pathways (like the corpus callosum) responsible for mediating this bilateral coordination could provide deeper insights. The study also opens avenues for exploring how this bilateral activity might be modulated by different brain states or arousal levels, although their initial findings suggest it's largely independent of slow arousal changes.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the absence of external stimuli or overt behavior, the activity of the left and right cortical hemispheres shows fluctuations that are largely bilateral. Here, we show that these fluctuations are largely responsible for the variability observed in cortical responses to sensory stimuli. Using widefield imaging of voltage and calcium signals, we measured activity in the cortex of mice performing a visual detection task. Bilateral fluctuations invested all areas, particularly those closest to the midline. Activity was less bilateral in the monocular region of primary visual cortex and, especially during task engagement, in secondary motor cortex. Ongoing bilateral fluctuations dominated unilateral visual responses, and interacted additively with them, explaining much of the variance in trial-by-trial activity. Even though these fluctuations occurred in regions necessary for the task, they did not affect detection behavior. We conclude that bilateral ongoing activity continues during visual stimulation and has a powerful additive impact on visual responses.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{shimaoka2019impact,
  author = {Daisuke Shimaoka and Nicholas A. Steinmetz and Kenneth D. Harris and Matteo Carandini},
  title = {{The impact of bilateral ongoing activity on evoked responses in mouse cortex}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.43533},
}
Figure