The HOD Hypothesis and a supercompact cardinal

Yong ChengMath. Log. Q 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the relationship between large cardinal properties in the universe of sets (V) and its inner model of definable sets (HOD). The authors prove that if a supercompact cardinal exists and the HOD Hypothesis holds, then there must be a proper class of measurable cardinals within HOD, effectively showing a reflection of large cardinal strength from V to HOD. This result has implications for understanding the structure of HOD and its proximity to V.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper delves into the fascinating world of set theory, specifically focusing on the relationship between the universe of all sets (V) and a special inner model called HOD (the set of all hereditarily definable sets). A central question in this area is how "close" HOD is to V. While V can be quite "underdetermined" when it comes to large cardinal axioms (like the existence of supercompact cardinals), HOD is often much more structured.

The "HOD Hypothesis" is a conjecture that suggests HOD is "close" to V in a specific sense, meaning it doesn't drastically differ from V in certain structural aspects. The paper addresses the question of whether large cardinal properties, such as the existence of a supercompact cardinal in V, can "trickle down" or be reflected into HOD. Specifically, it asks if the existence of a supercompact cardinal in V, under the assumption of the HOD Hypothesis, guarantees the existence of other large cardinals within HOD. The paper aims to show that this reflection does indeed happen, at least for measurable cardinals.

Methods

The paper's core contribution lies in proving a specific theorem: if $\kappa$ is a supercompact cardinal and the HOD Hypothesis holds, then there exists a proper class of regular cardinals below $\kappa$ that are measurable in HOD. The proof relies on several key tools and concepts from advanced set theory:

  • HOD Hypothesis: This hypothesis, proposed by W. Hugh Woodin, states that there is a proper class of regular cardinals that are not $\omega$-strongly measurable in HOD. The paper uses this as a crucial assumption.
  • Supercompact Cardinals: These are very large cardinals with strong embedding properties, which are central to the paper's setup.
  • Inner Model Theory: The paper extensively uses concepts from inner model theory, particularly focusing on "weak extender models" and their relationship to large cardinals.
  • Elementary Embeddings: These are fundamental tools in large cardinal theory, allowing mathematicians to construct models that "mimic" the behavior of larger cardinals. The proof constructs specific elementary embeddings to transfer properties from V to HOD.
  • Woodin's Theorems and Lemmas: The paper builds upon a significant body of work by W. Hugh Woodin, referencing several of his theorems and lemmas concerning HOD, supercompactness, and related concepts. Notably, Theorem 4.1, which provides a new formulation of supercompactness, and Lemma 4.2 are crucial for the main proof.

The proof strategy involves constructing specific elementary embeddings that connect different levels of the set-theoretic universe and carefully analyzing how properties of these embeddings, particularly concerning HOD, are preserved.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Reflection of Large Cardinal Strength: The most significant insight is that the existence of a supercompact cardinal in V, combined with the HOD Hypothesis, forces the existence of measurable cardinals within HOD. This demonstrates a powerful "reflection" principle, where large cardinal strength in the universe is not entirely lost when moving to the more structured HOD.
  • HOD Hypothesis as a Bridge: The HOD Hypothesis acts as a crucial bridge, ensuring that HOD is "close enough" to V for these large cardinal properties to be reflected. Without it, such a strong reflection might not occur.
  • Local vs. Global Universality: The paper contrasts "local" and "global" universality theorems. While supercompact cardinals in V might not exhibit their full strength in HOD (local), the HOD Hypothesis and HOD-supercompactness ensure a more global reflection of large cardinal properties.
  • New Formulation of Supercompactness: Theorem 4.1 introduces a novel formulation of supercompactness that is instrumental in proving the main result. This formulation highlights the coherence of intermediate embeddings, which is key to transferring properties to HOD.

Key Results

The main result of the paper is Theorem 4.3: If $\kappa$ is a supercompact cardinal and the HOD Hypothesis holds, then for any $\alpha < \kappa$, there exists a $\gamma$ such that $\alpha < \gamma < \kappa$ and $\gamma$ is measurable in HOD.

As a corollary, the paper presents Corollary 4.5 (Woodin's Local Universality Theorem), which states that if $\kappa$ is supercompact and the HOD Hypothesis holds, then for any $\alpha < \kappa$, there exists an elementary embedding $j: V_{\lambda+1} \to V_{j(\lambda)+1}$ with specific properties relating to HOD. This theorem further solidifies the idea of large cardinals in V being reflected in HOD.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Conjecture on Backward Direction: The paper poses a question about whether the converse of the main result holds. Specifically, if there exists a supercompact cardinal $\kappa$ and for every $\alpha < \kappa$, there exists a $\gamma$ such that $\alpha < \gamma < \kappa$ and $\gamma$ is measurable in HOD, does this imply the HOD Hypothesis? The authors conjecture that this backward direction might not hold, suggesting that proving the HOD Hypothesis solely from supercompactness is a difficult open problem.
  • Equivalence of HOD Hypothesis: The paper discusses the equivalence of the HOD Hypothesis with other statements under the assumption of HOD-supercompact or extendible cardinals. A natural question is whether this equivalence can be established assuming only supercompactness.
  • Woodin's Conjecture: The paper mentions Woodin's conjecture that if $\kappa$ is supercompact, then the HOD Hypothesis is equivalent to the existence of a weak extender model N for $\kappa$-supercompact such that $N \subseteq HOD$. This remains an open problem.

The paper highlights the intricate relationship between the universe of sets and its inner models, particularly HOD, and opens avenues for further research into the nature of large cardinals and their behavior within these structured models.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{cheng2017hod,
  author = {Yong Cheng},
  title = {{The HOD Hypothesis and a supercompact cardinal}},
  journal = {Math. Log. Q.},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1002/malq.201600007},
}
Figure