The hippocampus and spatial constraints on mental imagery

Chris M. Bird, James A. Bisby, Neil BurgessFrontiers in Human Neuroscience 2012 · DOI

Abstract

We review a model of imagery and memory retrieval based on allocentric spatial representation by place cells and boundary vector cells (BVCs) in the medial temporal lobe, and their translation into egocentric images in retrosplenial and parietal areas. In this model, the activity of place cells constrain the contents of imagery and retrieval to be coherent and consistent with the subject occupying a single location, while the activity of head-direction cells along Papez's circuit determine the viewpoint direction for which the egocentric image is generated. An extension of this model is discussed in which a role for grid cells in dynamic updating of representations (mental navigation) is included. We also discuss the extension of this model to implement a version of the dual representation theory of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) in which PTSD arises from an imbalance between weak allocentric hippocampal-mediated contextual representations and strong affective/sensory representations. The implications of these models for behavioral, neuropsychological, and neuroimaging data in humans are explored.

Introduction

The hippocampus has long been recognized as a cornerstone of episodic memory. However, its role extends beyond mere storage of past events; it appears fundamental to the construction of mental imagery—the ability to visualize scenes, whether remembered or entirely fictitious. Patients with hippocampal damage often struggle to imagine coherent scenes, even when the task does not require recalling specific autobiographical details. This review explores the computational mechanisms by which the hippocampus provides the spatial "scaffolding" necessary for coherent mental imagery.

The Boundary Vector Cell (BVC) Model

At the heart of the proposed framework is the Boundary Vector Cell (BVC) model. BVCs are hypothesized neurons that fire based on the distance and direction of environmental boundaries, such as walls or drops. These cells provide the primary input to place cells, which represent specific coordinates within an environment.

The BVC model fits experimental data by predicting firing patterns based on environmental geometry.

The model posits that the hippocampus acts as a spatial constraint. When we imagine a scene, the hippocampus ensures that all elements—objects, boundaries, and perspectives—are consistent with the viewer occupying a single, stable location. This "allocentric" (world-centered) map must then be translated into an "egocentric" (viewer-centered) image. This translation is thought to occur through a circuit involving the retrosplenial and parietal cortices, guided by head-direction cells that determine the mental viewpoint.

Empirical Evidence and Neuroimaging

The BVC model is supported by a synthesis of rodent electrophysiology and human neuroimaging. Functional MRI (fMRI) studies have shown that hippocampal activity increases parametrically with the number of boundaries in an imagined scene. For instance, imagining a room with four walls recruits the hippocampus more strongly than imagining an open space, regardless of the visual complexity of the objects within those spaces.

Furthermore, neuropsychological cases like Patient Jon demonstrate that while some aspects of memory may be preserved, the ability to generate spatially coherent scenes is severely compromised following hippocampal damage. These patients can often list items found in a scene but cannot describe their spatial relationships, leading to fragmented and non-coherent mental imagery.

PTSD and the Dual Representation Theory

The authors extend this spatial model to explain the pathology of Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD). They propose a "dual representation" theory of memory:

  1. Contextual Representations (C-reps): These are allocentric, hippocampal-dependent, and flexible. They provide the "where" and "when" that anchors a memory in its proper context.
  2. Sensory Representations (S-reps): These are egocentric, amygdala-dependent, and rigid. They capture the raw, affective sensory details of an event.

In PTSD, extreme stress leads to a downregulation of hippocampal function (weakening C-reps) and an upregulation of the amygdala (strengthening S-reps). This results in "homeless" sensory memories—vivid, terrifying images that lack a spatial anchor. Without the hippocampal constraint to keep the memory in the past, these S-reps intrude into consciousness as involuntary flashbacks, experienced as if they are happening in the present.

Supporting this, pharmacological studies using low-dose alcohol to disrupt hippocampal function have shown a selective impairment in "shifted-view" memory (which requires allocentric processing) while sparing "same-view" memory. Crucially, this impairment correlates with an increase in intrusive memories of traumatic stimuli.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The hippocampus serves as the "mind's eye" by enforcing spatial coherence on our internal representations. While the BVC model provides a robust account of spatial constraints, future work must integrate the role of grid cells in "mental navigation"—the dynamic updating of these images as we move through imagined space. Additionally, explaining how the hippocampus constrains the temporal sequence of events remains a significant challenge. Clinically, confirming the predicted hippocampal-amygdala imbalance during active intrusive episodes remains a priority for validating the dual representation theory of PTSD.

Summary updated

Abstract

We review a model of imagery and memory retrieval based on allocentric spatial representation by place cells and boundary vector cells (BVCs) in the medial temporal lobe, and their translation into egocentric images in retrosplenial and parietal areas. In this model, the activity of place cells constrain the contents of imagery and retrieval to be coherent and consistent with the subject occupying a single location, while the activity of head-direction cells along Papez's circuit determine the viewpoint direction for which the egocentric image is generated. An extension of this model is discussed in which a role for grid cells in dynamic updating of representations (mental navigation) is included. We also discuss the extension of this model to implement a version of the dual representation theory of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) in which PTSD arises from an imbalance between weak allocentric hippocampal-mediated contextual representations and strong affective/sensory representations. The implications of these models for behavioral, neuropsychological, and neuroimaging data in humans are explored.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bird2012hippocampus,
  author = {Chris M. Bird and James A. Bisby and Neil Burgess},
  title = {{The hippocampus and spatial constraints on mental imagery}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Human Neuroscience},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.3389/fnhum.2012.00142},
}
Figure