The evolutionary history of topological variations in the CPA/AT superfamily

Sudha Govindarajan, Claudio Bassot, John Lamb, Nanjiang Shu, Yan Huang, Arne ElofssonbioRxiv 2020 · DOI

Abstract

CPA/AT transporters consist of two structurally and evolutionarily related inverted repeat units, each comprising a core and a scaffold subdomain. During evolution, these families have undergone substantial changes in structure, topology, and function. Central to their transport process are two non-canonical helices, which appear in different families as either "reentrant" or "broken." Using an integrated topology annotation method—combining topology prediction, structural homology, and the "positive-inside rule"—we identified novel topologies across these families. We classified all families into three distinct evolutionary groups based on a structurally similar C-terminal repeat unit, termed "Fold-types." Our analysis reveals complex topological transitions, including orientation flips, changes in scaffold helix numbers, and the loss of core helices driven by gene duplication and repeat shuffling. These findings are hosted in the CPAfold database (cpafold.bioinfo.se), providing a comprehensive resource for understanding the evolution of membrane transport.

Introduction

Membrane proteins are the essential gatekeepers of the cell, yet their structural complexity often eludes standard classification. The CPA/AT (Monovalent cation/proton antiporter / Anion transporter) superfamily is a prime example of this challenge. Found across all kingdoms of life, these proteins are critical drug targets for conditions ranging from heart failure to cancer.

Structurally, these transporters are built from two inverted repeat units. However, throughout their evolutionary history, these units have undergone massive "topological gymnastics." They gain or lose helices, flip their orientation within the membrane, and alternate between "broken" helices (which cross the membrane with a kink) and "reentrant" helices (which enter and exit on the same side). This extreme diversity has led to significant discrepancies in major protein databases like Pfam, TCDB, and OPM. This research provides a unified evolutionary roadmap to explain how these diverse structures emerged.

Methodology: Integrated Topology Annotation

To map the evolutionary history of the CPA/AT superfamily, researchers developed an integrated topology annotation pipeline. This molecular detective work combined three distinct layers of evidence:

  1. Topology Prediction: Utilizing TOPCONS2 to estimate the placement of transmembrane helices.
  2. Structural Homology: Aligning sequences with the few families that have known crystal structures to infer the architecture of unknown families.
  3. The "Positive-Inside Rule" (KR-bias): This biological heuristic relies on the fact that positively charged residues (Lysine and Arginine) are more prevalent on the cytoplasmic side of the membrane. This bias was used to validate the orientation of the predicted topological models.

By applying hierarchical clustering to individual repeat units rather than the whole protein, the team identified evolutionary relationships that were previously obscured by the divergence of the full sequences.

The "Fold-type" Framework

A central discovery of this study is that while the N-terminal repeat unit of these transporters varies significantly, the C-terminal repeat unit remains remarkably conserved. This conservation allowed the researchers to use the C-terminal unit as an evolutionary anchor, defining three distinct "Fold-types":

  • 5-helical-broken
  • 7-helical-broken
  • 6-helical-reentrant

This classification system reveals that transporters can transition between broken and reentrant helices. Such transitions are not minor tweaks; they require the protein to gain or lose scaffold helices to maintain the necessary inverted symmetry for function.

Evolutionary Dynamics and Repeat Shuffling

The study highlights several mechanisms driving topological variation:

  • Repeat Shuffling: In families such as Mem_trans, the protein's orientation flipped because the N- and C-terminal repeats were essentially swapped or shuffled during evolution.
  • Internal Duplication: While most CPA/AT transporters originated from ancient duplications, some families (like the Asp-Al_Exchanger) show evidence of more recent internal duplications, maintaining high similarity between their two halves.
  • Novel Topologies: The team identified proteins with previously unmapped topologies containing between 9 and 14 transmembrane helices, providing a clearer model for how a 7-helical broken repeat could evolve into a 6-helical reentrant repeat through mutation and fusion.

Conclusion and the CPAfold Database

The culmination of this research is the CPAfold database (cpafold.bioinfo.se). This searchable resource hosts updated classifications, structural models, and sequence motifs for the entire superfamily. While some evolutionary trees in the study faced challenges like low bootstrap values—a common issue in highly divergent sequences—the "Fold-type" classification provides a robust framework for future study.

By mapping the evolutionary gymnastics of the CPA/AT superfamily, this work offers vital insights into the mechanics of ion transport and provides a foundation for more precise drug design targeting these essential molecular machines.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract CPA/AT transporters consist of two structurally and evolutionarily related inverted repeat units, each of them with one core and one scaffold subdomain. During evolution, these families have undergone substantial changes in structure, topology and function. Central to the function of the transporters is the existence of two non-canonical helices that are involved in the transport process. In different families, two different types of these helices have been identified, reentrant and broken. Here, we use an integrated topology annotation method to identify novel topologies in the families. It combines topology prediction, similarity to families with known structure, and the difference in positively charged residues present in inside and outside loops in alternative topological models. We identified families with diverse topologies containing broken or reentrant helix. We classified all families based on 3 distinct evolutionary groups that each share a structurally similar C-terminal repeat unit newly termed as “Fold-types”. Using the evolutionary relationship between families we propose topological transitions including, a transition between broken and reentrant helices, complete change of orientation, changes in the number of scaffold helices and even in some rare cases, losses of core helices. The evolutionary history of the repeat units shows gene duplication and repeat shuffling events to result in these extensive topology variations. The novel structure-based classification, together with supporting structural models and other information, is presented in a searchable database, CPAfold (cpafold.bioinfo.se). Our comprehensive study of topology variations within the CPA superfamily provides better insight about their structure and evolution.
BibTeX
@misc{govindarajan2020evolutionary,
  author = {Sudha Govindarajan and Claudio Bassot and John Lamb and Nanjiang Shu and Yan Huang and Arne Elofsson},
  title = {{The evolutionary history of topological variations in the CPA/AT superfamily}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1101/2020.12.13.422607},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure