Accurate contact-based modelling of repeat proteins predicts the structure of Curlin and SPW repeats

Claudio Bassot, Arne ElofssonbioRxiv 2019 · DOI

Repeat proteins are the modular "Lego sets" of the biological world, consisting of small, repeating units that assemble into larger, functional structures. Abundant in eukaryotic proteomes, these proteins are essential for cell signaling and acting as molecular scaffolds. However, their repetitive nature has long presented a challenge for structural biology, as traditional prediction methods often fail to resolve their complex internal symmetries.

In a study published in bioRxiv, researchers at Stockholm University demonstrate how deep learning can overcome these hurdles, successfully modeling five previously unsolved protein families, including the Curlin and SPW repeats.

The Challenge of Symmetry

Traditional protein structure prediction often relies on "contact prediction" via Direct Coupling Analysis (DCA). This method identifies pairs of amino acids that evolve in tandem; if two positions change together over millions of years, they are likely physically touching in 3D space.

For repeat proteins, this logic breaks down. Because the sequence repeats, traditional statistical methods get confused by the internal symmetry. This creates "ghost" contacts—statistical artifacts that appear as structural interactions but are actually just reflections of the sequence's repetitive nature. These artifacts introduce significant noise, making it nearly impossible to generate accurate 3D models using standard DCA.

A Deep Learning Solution

To address this, the researchers shifted from pure statistical methods to a deep learning approach using PconsC4. This tool utilizes a U-net architecture—a type of neural network common in image processing—to analyze contact maps. By treating the contact map as an image, PconsC4 can learn to recognize and ignore the periodic noise patterns that trip up older methods, effectively "de-noising" the structural signal.

The Modeling Pipeline

  1. Contact Prediction: PconsC4 generates a cleaned contact map.
  2. Secondary Structure: PSIpred provides predictions for alpha-helices and beta-strands.
  3. 3D Folding: These inputs are fed into CONFOLD to generate candidate 3D models.
  4. Quality Assessment: The resulting models are ranked using Pcons, which estimates the accuracy of the model relative to the true (but unknown) structure.

Benchmarking and Performance

The team benchmarked PconsC4 against GaussDCA, a standard statistical method, using a dataset of 819 known repeat proteins from RepeatsDB. The results were definitive: PconsC4 outperformed GaussDCA across every class of repeat protein.

The study found that protein architecture significantly impacts prediction accuracy:

  • Beta-strands vs. Alpha-helices: Proteins composed of beta-sheets (like beta-solenoids) are generally easier to model than those made of alpha-helices, as they produce more distinct co-evolutionary signals.
  • Solenoids vs. Beads-on-a-String: Solenoid structures (spirals) are easier to predict because they form consistent contact patterns. For "Class V" repeats, which resemble independent domains linked together, the authors found that modeling individual units separately actually improved accuracy.

Novel Structural Discoveries

After validating the method on known structures, the researchers applied it to 51 PFAM families that lacked experimental structures. They produced high-confidence models for five families:

  • SPW Family: The models revealed that this family forms transmembrane alpha-helices. A specific "SP" motif creates a structural kink, which is likely vital for its function within the cell membrane.
  • Curlin Repeats: The study confirmed that these repeats adopt a robust beta-solenoid structure.
  • MORN 2, RTTN N, and RHS repeats: These were also modeled with high estimated accuracy, providing a foundation for future functional studies.

Conclusion

By leveraging deep learning to filter out the noise inherent in repetitive sequences, this research provides a path forward for characterizing the vast number of repeat proteins currently missing from structural databases. While challenges remain in modeling extremely long chains and determining the precise orientation between distant domains, the success of PconsC4 marks a significant step toward completing our structural map of the eukaryotic proteome.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Repeat proteins are an abundant class in eukaryotic proteomes. They are involved in many eukaryotic specific functions, including signalling. For many of these families, the structure is not known. Recently, it has been shown that the structure of many protein families can be predicted by using contact predictions from direct coupling analysis and deep learning. However, their unique sequence features present in repeat proteins is a challenge for contact predictions DCA-methods. Here, we show that using the deep learning-based PconsC4 is more effective for predicting both intra and interunit contacts among a comprehensive set of repeat proteins. In a benchmark dataset of 819 repeat proteins about one third can be correctly modelled and among 51 PFAM families lacking a protein structure, we produce models of five families with estimated high accuracy. Author Summary Repeat proteins are widespread among organisms and particularly abundant in eukaryotic proteomes. Their primary sequence present repetition in the amino acid sequences that origin structures with repeated folds/domains. Although the repeated units are easy to be recognized in primary sequence, often structure information are missing. Here we used contact prediction for predicting the structure of repeats protein directly from their primary sequences. We benchmark our method on a dataset comprehensive of all the known repeated structures. We evaluate the contact predictions and the obtained models set for different classes of proteins and different lengths of the target, and we benchmark the quality assessment of the models on repeats proteins. Finally, we applied the methods on the repeat PFAM families missing of resolved structures, five of them modelled with high accuracy.
BibTeX
@misc{bassot2019accurate,
  author = {Claudio Bassot and Arne Elofsson},
  title = {{Accurate contact-based modelling of repeat proteins predicts the structure of Curlin and SPW repeats}},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1101/809483},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure