PconsC4: fast, free, easy, and accurate contact predictions

Mirco Michel, David Menéndez Hurtado, Arne ElofssonbioRxiv 2018 · DOI

Abstract

Residue contact prediction was revolutionized recently by the introduction of direct coupling analysis (DCA). Further improvements, in particular for small families, have been obtained by the combination of DCA and deep learning methods. However, existing deep learning contact prediction methods often rely on a number of external programs and are therefore computationally expensive. Here, we introduce a novel contact predictor, PconsC4, which performs on par with state-of-the-art methods. PconsC4 is heavily optimized, does not use any external programs, and therefore is significantly faster and easier to use than other methods. PconsC4 is freely available under the GPL license.

Introduction

Predicting the 3D structure of a protein from its amino acid sequence remains a fundamental challenge in structural bioinformatics. A critical intermediate step is residue contact prediction—identifying pairs of amino acids that are physically close in the folded protein. While Direct Coupling Analysis (DCA) significantly advanced this field, it typically requires large sequence alignments to be effective.

Deep learning has improved predictions for smaller protein families, but these tools often introduce a "dependency hell," requiring a complex web of external programs like PSIPRED or HHblits. These dependencies make tools slow, difficult to install, and computationally expensive to run at scale. PconsC4 addresses these issues by providing a fast, self-contained, and accurate alternative that is easy to install via pip.

Methods

PconsC4 departs from the traditional "meta-predictor" approach, which stacks multiple external tools, in favor of a streamlined, integrated deep learning pipeline.

Architecture and Features

The core of the model is a U-net, a convolutional neural network (CNN) architecture originally designed for biomedical image segmentation. This architecture uses a series of down-sampling and up-sampling layers with shortcut connections to capture both local and global patterns in contact maps. The model processes 72 features: 68 one-dimensional sequential features and four pairwise features (including GaussDCA and mutual information).

Internalized Dependencies

To eliminate external bottlenecks, the authors re-implemented GaussDCA as a high-performance Python package using Pythran and integrated a pre-trained secondary structure predictor (ProQ4). This allows PconsC4 to run without external software dependencies, making it remarkably easy to deploy on any system with Python 3.5+ and a modern GCC compiler.

Key Results

PconsC4 was evaluated against standard benchmarks and the CASP12 dataset, demonstrating that efficiency does not have to come at the cost of precision.

Accuracy and Performance

PconsC4 performs on par with or better than the most advanced meta-predictors. On standard benchmarks, it achieves an Area Under the Curve (AUC) of 0.92, outperforming MetaPSICOV (0.88) and its predecessor PconsC3 (0.87).

ROC curves on the benchmark set showing PconsC4's superior AUC compared to other methods.

Speed and Usability

The most significant advantage of PconsC4 is its runtime. As shown in the comparison below, PconsC4 achieves a massive speedup—completing predictions in 12 to 56 seconds, whereas PconsC3 requires nearly 50 minutes (2931s). This represents a >25x speedup while eliminating all external dependencies ("Deps.").

Comparison of performance, runtime, and dependencies across different contact prediction methods.

Calibration and Data Efficiency

PconsC4 is exceptionally well-calibrated; a predicted probability of 0.2 closely corresponds to a 20% actual contact frequency. Additionally, while traditional DCA methods require approximately 100,000 effective sequences for peak accuracy, PconsC4 reaches near-maximum performance with only 100 sequences, making it a powerful tool for studying rare or poorly-sequenced protein families.

Conclusion

PconsC4 represents a major step forward in making high-quality contact prediction accessible. By combining a U-net architecture with internalized features, it matches the accuracy of complex meta-predictors while offering a significant speedup and trivial installation. Its efficiency makes it an ideal candidate for large-scale structural studies and metagenomics analysis.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Motivation Residue contact prediction was revolutionized recently by the introduction of direct coupling analysis (DCA). Further improvements, in particular for small families, have been obtained by the combination of DCA and deep learning methods. However, existing deep learning contact prediction methods often rely on a number of external programs and are therefore computationally expensive. Results Here, we introduce a novel contact predictor, PconsC4, which performs on par with state of the art methods. PconsC4 is heavily optimized, does not use any external programs and therefore is significantly faster and easier to use than other methods. Availability PconsC4 is freely available under the GPL license from https://github.com/ElofssonLab/PconsC4 . Installation is easy using the pip command and works on any system with Python 3.5 or later and a modern GCC compiler. Contact [email protected]
BibTeX
@misc{michel2018pconsc,
  author = {Mirco Michel and David Menéndez Hurtado and Arne Elofsson},
  title = {{PconsC4: fast, free, easy, and accurate contact predictions}},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1101/383133},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure