The efficacy and safety of desflurane versus sevoflurane in elderly patients during general anaesthesia: A meta-analysis randomized controlled trials

Yiping Li, Ruiming Deng, Juan Zhou, Shifu Hu, Aiping OuyangMedical 2018 · DOI

Abstract

The objective of this study was to systematically identify and meta-analyze randomized controlled trials (RCTs) comparing desflurane and sevoflurane in elderly patients undergoing general anesthesia. Databases including PubMed, EMBASE, Web of Science, and the Cochrane Library were searched through July 2018. Five RCTs involving 324 patients met the inclusion criteria. The analysis revealed that desflurane significantly reduced the time to open eyes (SMD -0.63), follow commands (SMD -0.97), extubation (SMD -0.77), and orientation (SMD -1.49) compared to sevoflurane. However, no significant differences were found regarding total anesthesia time or the length of stay in the postanesthetic care unit (PACU).

Introduction: The Challenge of Geriatric Anesthesia

As global life expectancy increases, the geriatric population requiring surgical intervention is growing. Elderly patients present unique challenges for anesthesiologists due to reduced physiological reserves and a higher risk of delayed recovery or postoperative cognitive dysfunction (POCD). Selecting the optimal anesthetic maintenance agent is therefore crucial. Modern volatile agents like sevoflurane and desflurane are preferred for their low blood solubility, which facilitates rapid emergence. However, clinical evidence comparing the two in elderly populations has been inconsistent. This meta-analysis aims to clarify which agent provides superior efficacy and safety for geriatric patients.

Methodology and Study Selection

The researchers followed standard Cochrane protocols to conduct a systematic review. They identified 658 records initially, which were eventually narrowed down to five high-quality RCTs. Data were analyzed using RevMan 5.2, calculating Standardized Mean Differences (SMD) for continuous outcomes. Heterogeneity was assessed using the $I^2$ statistic, with random-effects models applied where $I^2 > 50\%$.

PRISMA flow diagram of the study selection process.

The final dataset included 324 patients (165 receiving desflurane and 159 receiving sevoflurane) across five international studies: Chen (2001), Iannuzzi (2005), Rortgen (2010), Deepak (2013), and Pakpirom (2016).

Key Results: Faster Emergence with Desflurane

The meta-analysis demonstrated a clear advantage for desflurane in early recovery metrics. Desflurane's lower blood-gas partition coefficient likely explains its faster "wash-out" from the bloodstream, allowing patients to transition from an anesthetized state to wakefulness more rapidly.

Key findings include:

  • Time to open eyes: Significantly shorter with desflurane (SMD -0.63; $P=0.04$).
  • Following commands: Significantly faster (SMD -0.97; $P=0.01$).
  • Extubation time: Significantly faster (SMD -0.77; $P=0.009$).
  • Orientation: Significantly faster (SMD -1.49; $P < 0.00001$).
Risk of bias assessment and forest plots for anesthesia time (a), time to open eyes (b), and extubation time (c).

Despite these advantages in immediate emergence, the study found no significant difference in total anesthesia time (SMD -0.10; $P=0.43$) or the length of PACU stay (SMD -4.65; $P=0.11$). This suggests that while desflurane accelerates the initial waking process, it does not necessarily translate to a faster discharge from the recovery unit, which may limit its immediate economic impact on hospital throughput.

Discussion and Limitations

While the results favor desflurane for rapid emergence, several limitations must be considered. The total sample size of 324 patients across five studies is relatively small, limiting the power of subgroup analyses. Furthermore, high heterogeneity was observed in some metrics, likely due to varying clinical protocols and discharge criteria across different countries.

The study also lacked sufficient data to evaluate long-term outcomes such as the incidence of POCD or postoperative nausea and vomiting. Future large-scale, multi-center trials are needed to determine if the early recovery benefits of desflurane lead to improved long-term clinical outcomes or significant cost savings in geriatric care.

Summary updated

Abstract

The objective of the study was to systematically screen the literature and to identify of the results of randomized controlled trials (RCTs) comparing the efficacy and safety of desflurane versus sevoflurane in elderly patients during general anaesthesia. Databases including PUBMED, EMBASE, Web of Science and Cochrane Library were searched until July 2018 to identify relevant studies. Two authors independently reviewed each study. After literature screening and data extraction, a meta-analysis was conducted using the RevMan 5.2 software. Five RCTs, including 324 patients, met the inclusion criteria and were included in the final analysis. Our pooled analysis showed that elderly patients during desflurane general anaesthesia could reduce time taken to open eyes (SMD, -0.63; 95% CI, -1.23 to -0.03; P=0.04), follow commands (SMD, -0.97; 95% CI, -1.76 to -0.19; P=0.01), extubation (SMD, -0.77; 95% CI, -1.35 to -0.19; P=0.009) and orientation (SMD, -1.49; 95% CI, -2.43 to -0.54). However, there was no difference between desflurane and sevoflurane groups with regard to anesthesia time (SMD, -0.10; 95% CI, -0.35 to 0.15; P=0.43) and the length of postanesthetic care unit (PACU) PACU stay (SMD, -4.65; 95% CI, -10.31 to 1; P=0.11). Our results show that elderly patients during desflurane general anaesthesia offers several potential advantages over anaesthesia in terms of the time to open the eyes, follow commands, extubation and orientation. However both anesthetics appear to be equivalent with regard to the anesthesia time and length of PACU stay.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2018efficacy,
  author = {Yiping Li and Ruiming Deng and Juan Zhou and Shifu Hu and Aiping Ouyang},
  title = {{The efficacy and safety of desflurane versus sevoflurane in elderly patients during general anaesthesia: A meta-analysis randomized controlled trials}},
  booktitle = {Medical},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.15761/mri.1000148},
}
Figure