The effect of wrist posture on extrinsic finger muscle activity during single joint movements

Carl R. Beringer, Misagh Mansouri, Lee E. Fisher, Jennifer L. Collinger, Michael C. Munin, Michael L. Boninger, Robert A. Gaunt

Abstract

Wrist posture impacts the muscle lengths and moment arms of the extrinsic finger muscles that cross the wrist. As a result, the electromyographic (EMG) activity associated with digit movement at different wrist postures must also change. We sought to quantify the posture-dependence of extrinsic finger muscle activity using bipolar fine-wire electrodes inserted into the extrinsic finger muscles of able-bodied subjects during unrestricted wrist and finger movements across the entire range of motion. EMG activity of all the recorded finger muscles were significantly different (p < 0.05, ANOVA) when performing the same digit movement in five different wrist postures. Depending on the wrist posture, EMG activity changed by up to 70% in individual finger muscles for the same movement, with the highest levels of activity observed in finger extensors when the wrist was extended. Similarly, finger flexors were most active when the wrist was flexed. For the finger flexors, EMG variations with wrist posture were most prominent for index finger muscles, while the EMG activity of all finger extensor muscles were modulated in a similar way across all digits. In addition to comprehensively quantifying the effect of wrist posture on extrinsic finger EMG activity in able-bodied subjects, these results may contribute to designing control algorithms for myoelectric prosthetic hands in the future.

Introduction

The human hand is a biomechanical marvel, but its control is incredibly complex. The muscles that move our fingers—the extrinsic muscles—actually reside in the forearm and cross the wrist joint. This means that whenever you move your wrist, you change the length, tension, and mechanical advantage of your finger muscles.

For researchers building "mind-controlled" prosthetics, this is a significant challenge. These devices typically use electromyography (EMG) to "read" a user's intent from their muscle signals. However, if the EMG signature for a specific movement, such as "flex index finger," changes drastically based on wrist orientation, the prosthetic might fail or perform the wrong action. This study quantifies how much wrist posture modulates these signals across the entire range of motion.

Methods

The researchers recruited 11 healthy subjects (7 male, 4 female, ages 25–32) and employed high-fidelity recording techniques:

  • Intramuscular EMG: 16 bipolar fine-wire electrodes were inserted directly into specific muscle compartments (e.g., FDS, FDP, ED). This allowed for "clean" signals from deep muscles without the crosstalk common in surface recordings.
  • Kinematic Tracking: Subjects wore a specialized glove fitted with electromagnetic sensors to track precise finger joint movements.
  • Structured Tasks: Subjects performed single-digit flexion and extension while holding their wrist in five postures: neutral, flexed, extended, pronated, and supinated.
Experimental setup showing the tracking glove (a) and the virtual hand interface (b) subjects followed.

The dataset included 57 muscle recordings across 42 trial types, providing a comprehensive look at extrinsic finger muscle behavior.

Key Results and Insights

The study found that wrist posture has a statistically significant effect (p < 0.05) on the EMG activity of every finger muscle recorded. EMG activity varied by as much as 70% for the same finger movement across different wrist postures.

The Tenodesis Effect and Muscle Activity

One might assume muscles work hardest when they are shortest. However, the researchers found that finger extensors were most active when the wrist was extended. This is likely due to the "tenodesis effect": extending the wrist stretches the finger flexors, creating passive tension. The extensors must work harder to overcome this "rubber band" effect of their opposing muscles. Conversely, finger flexors were most active during wrist flexion.

Compartmental Sensitivity

The effect of posture was not uniform across all digits. For finger flexors, the index finger muscles (D2) showed the most dramatic variations. In contrast, the extensor muscles across all digits were modulated in a more synchronized fashion. Additionally, extrinsic finger muscles remained highly active during pure wrist movements, suggesting a dual role in both digit movement and wrist stabilization.

Representative intramuscular EMG signal before and after noise removal, demonstrating the high-fidelity recording of individual muscle activity.

Discussion and Future Work

While the study clearly quantifies the posture-dependence of EMG signals, several questions remain. It is unclear whether these changes are a hard-wired reflex or a learned neural strategy. Furthermore, since this study involved able-bodied subjects, the mechanical connections (tendons crossing the wrist) were intact. In transradial amputees, these connections are severed.

If the observed EMG changes are purely mechanical reactions, they might not be present in amputees. However, if they are part of a learned neural program, prosthetic controllers must account for them to achieve intuitive, dexterous control. Future research will focus on testing these findings in amputee populations to determine if the "neural ghost" of these signals persists after limb loss.

Summary updated

Abstract

Wrist posture impacts the muscle lengths and moment arms of the extrinsic finger muscles that cross the wrist. As a result, the electromyographic (EMG) activity associated with digit movement at different wrist postures must also change. We sought to quantify the posture-dependence of extrinsic finger muscle activity using bipolar fine-wire electrodes inserted into the extrinsic finger muscles of able-bodied subjects during unrestricted wrist and finger movements across the entire range of motion. EMG activity of all the recorded finger muscles were significantly different (p < 0.05, ANOVA) when performing the same digit movement in five different wrist postures. Depending on the wrist posture, EMG activity changed by up to 70% in individual finger muscles for the same movement, with the highest levels of activity observed in finger extensors when the wrist was extended. Similarly, finger flexors were most active when the wrist was flexed. For the finger flexors, EMG variations with wrist posture were most prominent for index finger muscles, while the EMG activity of all finger extensor muscles were modulated in a similar way across all digits. In addition to comprehensively quantifying the effect of wrist posture on extrinsic finger EMG activity in able-bodied subjects, these results may contribute to designing control algorithms for myoelectric prosthetic hands in the future.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{beringer2020effect,
  author = {Carl R. Beringer and Misagh Mansouri and Lee E. Fisher and Jennifer L. Collinger and Michael C. Munin and Michael L. Boninger and Robert A. Gaunt},
  title = {{The effect of wrist posture on extrinsic finger muscle activity during single joint movements}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-020-65167-x},
}
Figure