The Effect of Venture Capital on Enterprise Benefit According to the Heterogeneity of Human Capital of Entrepreneur

Xin Jin, Puyang Zheng, Ziqi Zhong, Yali CaoFrontiers in Psychology 2020 · DOI

Abstract

This research explores the role of venture capital (VC) human capital—specifically the heterogeneity in education and professional backgrounds—in transforming innovation capabilities into tangible enterprise benefits. By analyzing 399 Chinese listed companies, the study demonstrates that VC investors with higher educational levels and engineering backgrounds significantly boost patent output. This increased innovation capacity acts as a mediator, ultimately driving improvements in financial metrics such as Return on Equity (ROE) and Tobin’s Q ratio.

Introduction

While venture capital is recognized as a vital funding source for startups, the specific mechanisms through which VCs add value beyond financing remain a "black box." This study shifts the focus toward the human capital of the VC investors themselves. It investigates how the professional and educational backgrounds of fund managers influence the innovation and financial performance of their portfolio companies, helping to bridge information asymmetries and resource gaps.

Methodology

The researchers employed a quantitative approach using multiple regression models to test a three-step relationship:

  1. VC Human Capital $\rightarrow$ Innovation Ability: Measuring how VC education and technical experience affect patent output.
  2. Innovation Ability $\rightarrow$ Enterprise Benefit: Measuring how patent output affects profitability (ROE) and growth potential (Tobin’s Q).
  3. The Interaction Effect: Analyzing whether high-quality VC human capital amplifies the financial impact of a company's innovation.

Data Overview

The study analyzed a sample of 399 listed companies in China that received venture capital before 2018. Data was sourced from the China VC Database and the Wind China Financial Database.

As shown in Figure 1, the sample firms are primarily listed on the Shenzhen, Shanghai, and Beijing stock exchanges, reflecting the core hubs of Chinese corporate activity.

Distribution of the selected exchanges for the 399 listed companies.

The industrial distribution of these enterprises is heavily concentrated in high-growth sectors. Manufacturing represents the largest segment at 37.3%, followed by the Internet sector at 28.72% (see Figure 2).

Proportion of industry distribution for the studied enterprises.

Key Insights

The "Engineering Edge"

VCs with engineering backgrounds are not merely financial managers; they are significantly more effective at fostering innovation. Their technical literacy likely allows them to provide better professional advice and technical resources to their portfolio companies.

Innovation as a Mediator

VC human capital does not always improve financial performance directly. Instead, it improves innovation ability first (increasing patent counts), which then serves as the engine for financial growth and market value enhancement.

The Experience Paradox

Interestingly, the study found that a VC's prior entrepreneurial experience did not have a statistically significant impact on innovation or benefits in this specific Chinese context. This suggests that technical expertise and social networks may be more critical value-drivers than past startup experience in this environment.

Key Results

  • Innovation Boost: There is an extremely significant positive correlation ($P < 0.001$) between the VC human capital index and the number of patents an enterprise produces.
  • Financial Impact: Both ROE and Tobin’s Q showed extremely significant positive correlations ($P < 0.001$) with patent counts.
  • The Value-Add Synergy: The interaction between patent counts and VC education/engineering background was significantly positive ($P < 0.05$), proving that high-quality VC human capital helps companies "monetize" their innovation more effectively.
  • Scale Diseconomy: Larger enterprise scale and higher R&D investment ratios were associated with lower immediate ROE ($P < 0.05$), highlighting the high costs and financing constraints associated with rapid expansion.

Conclusion and Future Work

The study concludes that the education level and engineering expertise of VC investors are vital for enhancing the innovation capacity and subsequent financial benefits of invested enterprises. However, firms must also manage the "scale diseconomy" that often accompanies rapid growth. Future research should utilize longitudinal data to track these relationships over time and explore strategies for optimizing the transition from high-innovation to high-profitability.

Summary updated

Abstract

This research was conducted for the purpose of exploring the role of venture capital (VC) based on the heterogeneity of human capital in the process of transforming innovation capabilities of enterprise into enterprise benefits and providing a reference for further research on enterprise performance development. In this study, 399 listed companies that obtained VC before 2018 from the China VC database and Wind China financial database were selected as research objects, and relevant data of patent number, return on equity, Tobin's Q ratio, and research and development (R&D) investment ratio of each enterprise were obtained. Enterprise innovation ability was introduced to construct the relationship model of human-capital VC, enterprise innovation ability, and enterprise benefit, and the relationship between human-capital VC, enterprise innovation ability, and enterprise benefit was analyzed by the multiple-regression model. The results show that the number of patents of invested enterprises has an extremely significant positive correlation with the human capital index (<i>P</i> < 0.001), and a significant positive correlation with the education level of personnel, the proportion of engineering professionals (<i>P</i> < 0.05). The return on equity and Tobin's Q ratio of enterprises have extremely significant positive correlations with the number of patents of invested enterprises (<i>P</i> < 0.001) and have a significant positive correlation with the number of patents of the invested enterprises × education level of the personnel, and the number of patents of the invested enterprises × proportion of engineering professionals (<i>P</i> < 0.05). All in all, the education level of the entrepreneur' s VC human capital and the proportion of engineering professionals can effectively improve the innovation ability of the enterprise, thus indirectly playing a value-added role in the improvement of enterprise benefits. The invested enterprises will also face the problems of scale diseconomy and financing constraint when their profitability is enhanced, so they need to optimize their own business strategies.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jin2020effect,
  author = {Xin Jin and Puyang Zheng and Ziqi Zhong and Yali Cao},
  title = {{The Effect of Venture Capital on Enterprise Benefit According to the Heterogeneity of Human Capital of Entrepreneur}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2020.01558},
}
Figure