Abstract
Clinical application of the Er: YAG Laser for dental caries and periodontal treatment has been developed. In clinical use, the effect of mis-irradiation of the Er: YAG Laser on the surrounding tissues should be considered. The purpose of this study was to examine the effect of the Er: YAG Laser on soft tissues supposing the side effect of mis-irradiation. The Er: YAG Laser was irradiated against the tongue of rat under following various conditions; the energy level: 50, 150, 300mJ/pulse, pulsing time: 1 and 10 pulses, irradiation distance: 0, 5, 10 and 20mm, and irradiated field: wet or dry. Wounds on tongue were observed macroscopically at 0, 1, 3, 7 and 14 days after laser irradiation. Some specimens were also examined by SEM. The following results were obtained: contact irradiations caused limited damages to tongue regardless of water irrigation; however, the depth of wounds depended upon the pulsing time and power level of the laser, while, non-contact irradiation showed a little or no effect against tongue. Moreover, the use of water irrigation decreased their damages effectively. With respect to wound healing, all cases were shown as normal process. Clinically, most of mis-irradiations are supposed to happen with non-contact irradiation under water spray. These results indicate that the Er: YAG Laser application for intraoral usage would be safe for the surrounding soft tissues within the usual power setting in dental treatment.
Introduction
The Erbium-doped Yttrium Aluminum Garnet (Er:YAG) laser is a staple in modern dentistry because its wavelength (2.94 μm) is highly absorbed by water. This allows it to efficiently ablate dental caries and bone with minimal heat transfer to surrounding areas. However, the mouth is a cramped workspace, and a primary concern for clinicians is the potential for accidental "mis-irradiation" of soft tissues like the tongue or cheeks. This paper investigates the macroscopic and microscopic effects of accidental soft-tissue exposure under various clinical conditions including power, distance, and moisture.
Methods
The researchers used 10 male Wistar rats as a biological model. After anesthetizing the rats and securing their tongues, they applied an Er:YAG laser (ML22) under a matrix of variables:
- Energy Levels: 50, 150, and 300 mJ/pulse.
- Pulse Count: 1 pulse vs. 10 pulses.
- Distance: 0 mm (contact), 5 mm, 10 mm, and 20 mm (non-contact).
- Environment: Dry vs. Wet (water irrigation).
The team performed a longitudinal study, observing the wounds macroscopically and via Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) at intervals of 0, 1, 3, 7, and 14 days to track physical damage and the subsequent healing process.
Key Insights and Results
The Protective Power of Water
One of the most significant findings was that water irrigation acts as a literal shield. In non-contact scenarios, the water spray absorbs a portion of the laser energy, significantly reducing the depth and severity of the wound.
The "Micro-explosion" Mechanism
SEM observations confirmed that Er:YAG lasers work via "micro-explosions." Because the laser is absorbed so rapidly by the water within the tissue, the water vaporizes instantly, causing localized mechanical ablation rather than widespread thermal burning (charring).
Rapid Energy Dissipation
As the distance from the laser tip increases, the energy density drops. At distances greater than 10mm, the laser had almost no visible effect on the tissue, which is a reassuring "fail-safe" for clinicians.
- Contact Irradiation: Caused distinct, point-like defects. The depth was directly proportional to the power level and the number of pulses.
- Non-Contact (5mm): Produced only a faint white or brownish circular mark under dry conditions and even less under wet conditions.
- Non-Contact (>10mm): Resulted in no macroscopic changes to the tissue, regardless of the power setting.
- Resilient Healing: Even in cases of high-energy contact irradiation, the tissue followed a normal healing process, with significant recovery visible by day 7 and near-total resolution by day 14.
Conclusion
Clinically, most mis-irradiations are expected to occur during non-contact irradiation under water spray. These results indicate that Er:YAG laser application for intraoral usage is safe for surrounding soft tissues within the usual power settings used in dental treatment. Future work may include investigating the effects of mis-irradiation on bone tissue, which may be more sensitive than the highly regenerative soft tissue of the tongue.
Summary updated