Observation of Cervical Enamel and Root Dentin of Treated Cavity after Root Caries Removal Using Er: YAG, Laser

Akira Aoki, Toshimoto Yamada, Masayuki Otsuki, Hisashi Watanabe, Junji Tagami, Isao IshikawaJournal of Japanese Society for Laser Dentistry 1997 · DOI

Abstract

This study investigates the morphological and histopathological changes in cervical enamel and root dentin following root caries removal using an Er:YAG laser. Ten extracted human teeth with root caries were used in a split-tooth design, comparing laser ablation to conventional mechanical removal with a steel bur. Results indicated that the Er:YAG laser effectively removes carious lesions with minimal thermal damage to surrounding tissues. However, the laser-treated surfaces exhibited irregular cavity margins and significant microcracking in the enamel, suggesting that further refinement of irradiation techniques is necessary for optimal clinical outcomes in adhesive restorations.

Introduction

Traditional dental cavity preparation relies on mechanical steel burs, which often cause patient discomfort through noise and vibration and may lead to the unnecessary removal of healthy tissue. Early laser applications in dentistry, such as Nd:YAG or $CO_2$ lasers, were limited by significant thermal side effects, including charring and cracking, due to high absorption by mineral components. The Er:YAG laser ($2.94 \mu m$) offers a promising alternative; its wavelength is highly absorbed by water, enabling "explosive ablation"—a thermo-mechanical process that removes tissue with minimal heat transfer. This study aims to evaluate the structural integrity of tooth components after such treatment.

Methodology

The study utilized ten extracted human teeth affected by naturally occurring root caries. A split-tooth experimental design was employed to ensure direct comparability:

  • Control Group: Half of each carious lesion was removed using a standard steel bur mounted on a low-speed micromotor.
  • Experimental Group: The remaining half was treated with an Er:YAG laser (145 mJ/pulse at the tip, 10 pulses per second) under continuous water spray.

The researchers used a combination of "contact mode" for bulk removal and "non-contact (defocused) mode" for finishing the cavity floor. Evaluation was conducted via Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) for surface morphology and histopathological analysis using hematoxylin and eosin (HE) staining to assess tissue integrity and thermal impact.

Results and Discussion

Ablation Efficiency and Thermal Impact

The Er:YAG laser successfully removed decayed tissue to a level comparable to mechanical burs, as verified by caries detector dyes. Histological observations confirmed that thermal damage was remarkably localized. The water spray used during irradiation serves a dual purpose: it acts as a coolant to prevent heat buildup and provides the medium for the explosive removal of debris. Consequently, the "damage zone" or altered tissue layer was limited to a very thin superficial region (5–15 $\mu m$). Unlike older laser technologies, no major carbonization, melting, or deep thermal necrosis was observed, supporting the "cold" ablation characteristics of the Er:YAG wavelength.

Surface Morphology and Enamel Integrity

SEM analysis revealed distinct differences between the laser-treated and mechanically prepared surfaces. Lased dentin lacked the typical "smear layer" produced by mechanical burs. Instead, it displayed micro-irregularities similar to an acid-etched surface. This texture is theoretically beneficial for resin bonding as it provides a clean surface for mechanical interlocking.

Cross-sectional view of the cavity showing the relationship between enamel (E) and dentin (D).

However, the cavity margins produced by the laser were often irregular and less defined than those created by mechanical burs. A significant finding was the vulnerability of the cervical enamel. While the dentin fared well, the brittle structure of the enamel showed significant microcracks and "blocky" irregularities under SEM evaluation.

SEM image (50 µm scale) illustrating blocky irregularities and microcracks in the lased enamel.

These structural changes in the enamel are likely due to the mechanical impact of the explosive ablation process. The presence of such cracks raises concerns about the long-term marginal seal of restorations, as they could serve as pathways for microleakage and secondary caries.

Conclusion

The Er:YAG laser is an effective tool for the precise removal of root caries with minimal thermal risk to the pulp and surrounding dentin. However, the resulting surface morphology presents specific challenges for restorative dentistry. The irregularity of the cavity margins and the presence of microcracks in the enamel suggest that current laser techniques may require supplemental finishing steps. Future research should focus on optimizing irradiation parameters—specifically pulse energy and frequency—to refine marginal finishing and ensure the long-term success of adhesive restorations on lased surfaces.

Summary updated

Abstract

The purpose of this study was to examine morphological and histopathological changes of the cervical enamel and root dentin of the treated cavity after root caries ablation using an Er: YAG laser. The prepared surfce using the Er: YAG laser was compared with that of conventional mechanical treatment. Ten extracted human teeth with root caries were used. Half of the carious lesion in each tooth was ablated with the Er: YAG laser, and the other was removed with a steel bur mounted on a low-speed micromotor. Er: YAG laser treatment was carefully performed under water spray using a combination of contact and non-contact irradiation modes. SEM and histopathological observations were performed for each treatment. The Er: YAG laser was able to ablate root carious lesion effectively without major thermal damage to the surrounding dental hard tisssues. However, the treated cavity margin tended to be irregular and unclear. Due to the careful irradiation technique, the irregularity of the cavity floor was relatively small and the residual structural change of the lased dentin was generally minimal except for the scarce highly-damaged area. The super ficial layer of the lased dentin showed deep staining with hematoxylin in the histological observation and typical microirregularities in the SEM examination. On the lased enamel, however, large microcraks and microirregularities were noted in the SEM evaluation.In order to perform effective caries removal and cavity preparation using the Er: YAG laser, further studies are required on the irradiation conditions and techniques, and on the conditioning of the lased surface for adhesive restorations. Especially, structural changes and finishing of the marginal enamel of the lased cavity should be investigated more minutely.(J. Jpn. Soc. Laser Dent. 8: 31-37, 1997, Reprint requests to Dr. AOKI)
BibTeX
@article{aoki1997observation,
  author = {Akira Aoki and Toshimoto Yamada and Masayuki Otsuki and Hisashi Watanabe and Junji Tagami and Isao Ishikawa},
  title = {{Observation of Cervical Enamel and Root Dentin of Treated Cavity after Root Caries Removal Using Er: YAG, Laser}},
  journal = {Journal of Japanese Society for Laser Dentistry},
  year = {1997},
  doi = {10.5984/jjpnsoclaserdent.8.31},
}
Figure