The effect of rapid relative humidity changes on fast filter-based aerosol-particle light-absorption measurements: uncertainties and correction schemes

Sebastian Düsing, Birgit Wehner, Thomas Müller, Almond Stöcker, Alfred WiedensohlerAtmospheric 2019 · DOI

Abstract

Measuring vertical profiles of the particle light-absorption coefficient using absorption photometers is often complicated by rapid changes in relative humidity (RH). These instruments determine absorption by measuring light attenuation through a particle-loaded filter. However, filter materials absorb or release water as RH fluctuates, altering their optical properties and creating measurement artifacts. This study investigates these effects using the Single Channel Tricolor Absorption Photometer (STAP) and the microAeth® MA200. Laboratory experiments revealed that the STAP (quartz-fiber filter) and MA200 (PTFE filter) exhibit opposing responses to RH changes. While linear and exponential correction schemes are proposed, the study highlights significant uncertainties due to RH sensor response times and ultimately recommends the use of aerosol dryers for vertical profiling.

Introduction

To accurately model climate change and assess air quality, scientists must quantify how much light is absorbed by atmospheric aerosols, such as black carbon (soot). Filter-based absorption photometers are frequently deployed on mobile platforms like drones, balloons, and aircraft to measure these properties across vertical atmospheric profiles. However, these measurements are prone to "ghost" signals—apparent absorption spikes that occur when the instrument moves through layers of varying humidity, such as when entering or exiting a cloud or crossing a boundary layer.

The Challenge of Humidity

The core of the problem lies in the hygroscopic nature of filter materials. When RH changes rapidly ($dRH/dt$), the filter material (quartz-fiber in the STAP or PTFE in the MA200) interacts with water vapor. This interaction changes the light attenuation through the filter, which the instrument's software incorrectly interprets as a change in particle loading. In clean environments or during rapid vertical ascents, these artifacts can be several times larger than the actual aerosol signal, leading to significant data bias.

Experimental Methodology

To quantify these artifacts, researchers designed a controlled laboratory setup to simulate rapid RH transitions. The experiments tested clean filters, filters loaded with hydrophobic black carbon (BC), and filters loaded with hydrophilic ammonium sulfate.

Schematic of the laboratory setup used to investigate the influence of relative humidity on aerosol absorption measurements.

The setup utilized a 0.5 m³ mixing chamber to prepare aerosol samples, which were then monitored by a suite of instruments including a Multi-Angle Absorption Photometer (MAAP) and a Mobility Particle Size Spectrometer (MPSS) to ensure consistent particle concentrations. The RH was controlled using a humidifier and mass flow controllers (MFC), allowing for precise, stepped changes in humidity delivered to the STAP and MA200 units.

Key Findings: Opposing Responses and Memory Effects

The study revealed a striking difference in how the two instruments react to humidity. The STAP showed a positive linear correlation with RH changes: as humidity increased, the apparent absorption increased. Conversely, the MA200 showed a negative response, where an increase in RH led to a decrease in apparent absorption.

Time series showing the response of STAP and MA200 absorption coefficients to stepped changes in relative humidity.

At a wavelength of 624 nm (60 s average), the STAP's sensitivity ranged from 0.14 to 0.29 Mm⁻¹ per % change in RH, depending on the filter loading material. The MA200 was more stable across different materials but showed a consistent negative response of approximately -0.4 Mm⁻¹ per % change in RH.

Furthermore, the MA200 exhibited a "memory effect" characterized by an exponential recovery period after an RH change. Researchers speculate this is due to water forming a thin film on the hydrophobic PTFE fibers, which acts as a refractive index matching layer, temporarily increasing light transmission through the filter.

Proposed Corrections and Limitations

The researchers developed mathematical correction schemes to mitigate these artifacts:

  1. Linear Correction (STAP): Correlating 1 Hz resolved absorption coefficients with RH change rates. The linear response was estimated at 10.08 Mm⁻¹ s⁻¹ %⁻¹.
  2. Exponential Recovery Model (MA200): A more complex approach to account for the time-lagged response of the PTFE filter.

However, the authors caution against relying solely on these fixes. The primary bottleneck is the response time of standard RH sensors ($t_{63} < 10s$), which is often slower than the optical response of the filter. If the sensor cannot capture the fastest RH fluctuations, the mathematical correction will remain incomplete.

Recommendations for Future Research

Because of the inherent uncertainties in post-processing corrections, the study concludes with two practical recommendations for the atmospheric science community:

  • Hardware Solutions: The most effective way to eliminate RH artifacts is to use an aerosol dryer upstream of the absorption photometer. This ensures the sample air reaches the filter at a constant, low humidity.
  • Operational Adjustments: When dryers cannot be used, vertical measurement platforms should ascend or descend slowly through layers with high RH gradients to minimize the $dRH/dt$ term.

While the proposed mathematical corrections point in the right direction and help estimate measurement uncertainties, they should be considered a secondary tool compared to physical humidity control.

Summary updated

Abstract

Measuring vertical profiles of the particle light-absorption coefficient by using absorption photometers may face the challenge of fast changes in relative humidity (RH). These absorption photometers determine the particle light-absorption coefficient due to a change in light attenuation through a particle-loaded filter. The filter material, however, takes up or releases water with changing relative humidity (RH in %), thus influencing the light attenuation. A sophisticated set of laboratory experiments was therefore conducted to investigate the effect of fast RH changes (dRH ∕ dt) on the particle light-absorption coefficient (σabs in Mm−1) derived with two absorption photometers. The RH dependence was examined based on different filter types and filter loadings with respect to loading material and areal loading density. The Single Channel Tricolor Absorption Photometer (STAP) relies on quartz-fiber filter, and the microAeth® MA200 is based on a polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) filter band. Furthermore, three cases were investigated: clean filters, filters loaded with black carbon (BC), and filters loaded with ammonium sulfate. The filter areal loading densities (ρ*) ranged from 3.1 to 99.6 mg m−2 in the case of the STAP and ammonium sulfate and 1.2 to 37.6 mg m−2 in the case the MA200. Investigating BC-loaded cases, ρBC* was in the range of 2.9 to 43.0 and 1.1 to 16.3 mg m−2 for the STAP and MA200, respectively. Both instruments revealed opposing responses to relative humidity changes (ΔRH) with different magnitudes. The STAP shows a linear dependence on relative humidity changes. The MA200 is characterized by a distinct exponential recovery after its filter was exposed to relative humidity changes. At a wavelength of 624 nm and for the default 60 s running average output, the STAP reveals an absolute change in σabs per absolute change of RH (Δσabs∕ΔRH) of 0.14 Mm−1 %−1 in the clean case, 0.29 Mm−1 %−1 in the case of BC-loaded filters, and 0.21 Mm−1 %−1 in the case filters loaded with ammonium sulfate. The 60 s running average of the particle light-absorption coefficient at 625 nm measured with the MA200 revealed a response of around −0.4 Mm−1 %−1 for all three cases. Whereas the response of the STAP varies over the different loading materials, in contrast, the MA200 was quite stable. The response was, for the STAP, in the range of 0.17 to 0.24 Mm−1 %−1 and, in the case of ammonium sulfate loading and in the BC-loaded case, 0.17 to 0.62 Mm−1 %−1. In the ammonium sulfate case, the minimum response shown by the MA200 was −0.42 with a maximum of −0.36 Mm−1 %−1 and a minimum of −0.42 and maximum −0.37 Mm−1 %−1 in the case of BC. A linear correction function for the STAP was developed here. It is provided by correlating 1 Hz resolved recalculated particle light-absorption coefficients and RH change rates. The linear response is estimated at 10.08 Mm−1 s−1 %−1. A correction approach for the MA200 is also provided; however, the behavior of the MA200 is more complex. Further research and multi-instrument measurements have to be conducted to fully understand the underlying processes, since the correction approach resulted in different correction parameters across various experiments. However, the exponential recovery after the filter of the MA200 experienced a RH change could be reproduced. However, the given correction approach has to be estimated with other RH sensors as well, since each sensor has a different response time. And, for the given correction approaches, the uncertainties could not be estimated, which was mainly due to the response time of the RH sensor. Therefore, we do not recommend using the given approaches. But they point in the right direction, and despite the imperfections, they are useful for at least estimating the measurement uncertainties due to relative humidity changes. Due to our findings, we recommend using an aerosol dryer upstream of absorption photometers to reduce the RH effect significantly. Furthermore, when absorption photometers are used in vertical measurements, the ascending or descending speed through layers of large relative humidity gradients has to be low to minimize the observed RH effect. But this is simply not possible in some scenarios, especially in unmixed layers or clouds. Additionally, recording the RH of the sample stream allows correcting for the bias during post-processing of the data. This data correction leads to reasonable results, according to the given example in this study.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{dusing2019effect,
  author = {Sebastian Düsing and Birgit Wehner and Thomas Müller and Almond Stöcker and Alfred Wiedensohler},
  title = {{The effect of rapid relative humidity changes on fast filter-based aerosol-particle light-absorption measurements: uncertainties and correction schemes}},
  booktitle = {Atmospheric},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.5194/amt-12-5879-2019},
}
Figure