The Effect of Big Data Analytics Capability on Competitive Performance: The Mediating Role of Resource Optimization and Resource Bricolage

Bo Huang, Jianmin Song, Yi Xie, Yuyu Li, He FengFrontiers in Psychology 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how Big Data Analytics Capability (BDAC) translates into competitive performance, focusing on two key mediating mechanisms: resource optimization and resource bricolage. It reveals that resource bricolage, the art of making do with existing, often undervalued resources, is a more potent pathway to competitive advantage than resource optimization, especially when driven by BDAC.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While it's widely accepted that Big Data Analytics Capability (BDAC) can boost a company's competitive performance, the exact "how" remains somewhat of a black box. Researchers have identified BDAC as crucial for better decision-making, redefining business logic, and driving innovation. However, the specific mechanisms through which BDAC influences performance are not fully understood. This paper aims to bridge this gap by examining two distinct ways companies integrate and utilize their resources: resource optimization (efficiently allocating high-quality, often scarce resources) and resource bricolage (creatively leveraging undervalued, slack, or discarded resources). The study also differentiates between two facets of BDAC: BDA management capability (strategic planning, coordination) and BDA technology capability (infrastructural support for data handling). The core problem is to disentangle how these different types of BDAC interact with these resource integration strategies to ultimately impact competitive performance.

Methods

The researchers employed Partial Least Squares Structural Equation Modeling (PLS-SEM), a statistical technique well-suited for complex models with multiple variables and paths, especially when dealing with smaller sample sizes or non-normally distributed data. This approach allows for the simultaneous testing of direct and indirect relationships between the constructs. To ensure the robustness of their findings, they also conducted endogeneity testing using a two-step Heckman procedure to rule out potential biases from omitted variables, measurement errors, or reverse causality.

Datasets

The study utilized a cross-sectional survey dataset collected from 219 Chinese enterprises. The data was gathered through self-administered questionnaires distributed to MBA and EMBA students who held managerial positions, providing them with insights into their companies' strategies and operations. The sample covered various industries, including manufacturing, retailing, food service, and IT.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Resource Bricolage as the Star Player: The most striking insight is that resource bricolage, rather than resource optimization, acts as the primary mediator for BDAC's impact on competitive performance. This suggests that the ability to creatively repurpose existing, often overlooked resources is more critical than simply optimizing the use of prime assets.
  • BDA Management vs. BDA Technology: While both forms of BDAC contribute, BDA management capability shows a stronger influence on resource optimization, whereas BDA technology capability is more directly linked to resource bricolage. This highlights a strategic nuance: management prowess steers efficient resource allocation, while technological infrastructure enables the creative exploitation of what's available.
  • Bricolage's Superior Impact: The study found that resource bricolage has a stronger direct effect on competitive performance than resource optimization. This reinforces the idea that making do with less, but doing so creatively, can yield more significant competitive advantages.
  • The "How" of BDAC: The research provides a clearer picture of the mechanism: BDAC doesn't directly translate to performance in a vacuum. It works by enabling companies to better engage in resource integration strategies, with resource bricolage emerging as the more effective pathway.

Key Results

  • Resource Bricolage Mediates: Resource bricolage significantly mediated the relationship between both BDA management capability and BDA technology capability, and competitive performance.
  • BDA Management's Dual Role: BDA management capability positively influenced both resource optimization and resource bricolage. Notably, its effect on resource optimization was stronger.
  • BDA Technology's Focus: BDA technology capability was positively associated with resource bricolage but not significantly with resource optimization.
  • Bricolage Outperforms Optimization: Resource bricolage had a stronger positive effect on competitive performance (f² = 0.130) compared to resource optimization (f² = 0.037).
  • Mediating Effect Strength: The mediating effect of resource bricolage was stronger when linked to BDA management capability (β = 0.151) than when linked to BDA technology capability (β = 0.067).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Survey Data Subjectivity: Reliance on self-reported survey data can introduce common method variance and subjective biases. Future research could benefit from multi-method approaches, such as situational experiments or quantum computing, to mitigate these issues.
  • Cross-Sectional Design: The study's cross-sectional nature limits its ability to establish causality definitively. Longitudinal studies or case studies would provide more robust evidence.
  • Limited Mechanisms: The research focused solely on resource integration as a mediator. Future work could explore other potential mechanisms, such as strategic orientation or alliance modes.
  • Moderating Variables: Important moderating variables, like top management team (TMT) support and environmental dynamism, were not fully explored.
  • Sample Size: While 219 enterprises is a reasonable sample, a larger dataset could enhance the robustness of the conclusions.

Future research is encouraged to address these limitations by incorporating diverse methodologies, longitudinal data, and a broader range of influencing factors to further unravel the complex interplay between BDAC and competitive performance.

Summary updated

Abstract

Although big data analytics capability (BDAC) leads to competitive performance, the mechanism of the relationship is still unclear. To narrow the research gap, this paper investigates the mediating roles of two forms of resource integration (resource optimization and resource bricolage) in the relationship between two forms of BDAC [big data analytics (BDA) management capability and BDA technology capability] and competitive performance. Supported by Partial Least Squares-Structural Equation Modeling (PLS-SEM) and the cross-sectional survey data from 219 Chinese enterprises, the results show that the resource bricolage plays a significantly mediating role in the relationships between BDA management capability and competitive performance as well as in the relationship between BDA technology capability and competitive performance. Furthermore, the mediating effect in the former relationship is stronger than that in the latter relationship. Additionally, BDA technology capability only has a direct effect on resource bricolage, while BDA management capability has a stronger effect on resource optimization than that on resource bricolage. Finally, resource bricolage has a stronger impact on competitive performance than resource optimization. These findings contribute to understanding how enterprises could apply different forms of BDAC to other kinds of resource integration to achieve outstanding competitive performance.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{huang2022effect,
  author = {Bo Huang and Jianmin Song and Yi Xie and Yuyu Li and He Feng},
  title = {{The Effect of Big Data Analytics Capability on Competitive Performance: The Mediating Role of Resource Optimization and Resource Bricolage}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2022.882810},
}
Figure