The Effect of Ambient Illumination and Text Color on Visual Fatigue under Negative Polarity

Qiangqiang Fan, Jinhan Xie, Zhaoyang Dong, Yang Wang

TL;DR

This study investigates how ambient light and text color affect visual fatigue when using displays in low-light conditions, particularly with negative polarity (light text on dark backgrounds). They found that yellow text is the least fatiguing, while red text is the most, and that increasing ambient light generally reduces fatigue, though the effect varies by text color.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As we increasingly use visual display terminals (VDTs) in various environments, understanding factors that contribute to visual fatigue is crucial for user comfort and safety. This is especially true in low-illumination settings, such as nighttime driving with Head-Up Displays (HUDs) or using devices in dark rooms. Negative polarity (dark mode) is often employed in these scenarios, but its impact on visual fatigue, especially in conjunction with different text colors and varying ambient light, is complex and not fully understood. Previous research has yielded mixed results, highlighting the need for a more comprehensive study that considers the interplay of these factors.

Methods

The researchers conducted an experiment with 50 participants, using a Lenovo M14D monitor and a Tobii Pro X3-120 eye tracker. They manipulated two independent variables: ambient illumination (0, 5, and 10 lux) and text color (white, yellow, blue, green, and red) on a black background (negative polarity). Participants performed a reading task and a cognitive test. Visual fatigue was measured using objective indicators (pupil accommodation and blink rate) and subjective indicators (visual fatigue index via questionnaire and cognitive performance). A two-way MANOVA was used to analyze the interaction effects, followed by Duncan and Bonferroni post-hoc tests.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study used a custom experimental setup and did not rely on pre-existing datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Yellow is the hero of dark mode: Yellow text consistently emerged as the least fatiguing option under negative polarity, both objectively and subjectively. This suggests it's a prime candidate for interfaces where users might experience eye strain.
  • Red is the villain: Conversely, red text was associated with the highest levels of visual fatigue, making it a color to be used sparingly, if at all, in low-light, dark-mode interfaces.
  • Ambient light matters, but it's not a one-size-fits-all solution: While increasing ambient light generally reduced visual fatigue, its effectiveness was significantly influenced by the text color. This highlights the importance of considering both factors in tandem.
  • Objective and subjective measures can sometimes diverge: While objective measures like pupil accommodation and blink rate showed clear trends with text color and ambient light, the subjective visual fatigue index and cognitive performance showed more nuanced or sometimes inconsistent results, suggesting the complexity of human perception.

Key Results

  • Visual Fatigue Index: Red text led to the highest visual fatigue index, followed by green, blue, and white, with yellow text showing the lowest. Ambient illumination did not significantly affect the visual fatigue index.
  • Pupil Accommodation: Yellow text showed the highest pupil accommodation, while red text showed the lowest. Higher ambient illumination (5 and 10 lux) generally increased pupil accommodation compared to 0 lux.
  • Blink Rate: Yellow text elicited the highest blink rate, followed by white, blue, green, and red. Increasing ambient illumination from 0 to 5 lux and then to 10 lux significantly increased blink rate.
  • Cognitive Performance: Yellow, blue, and white text resulted in significantly better cognitive performance compared to green and red text. Yellow text showed the best cognitive performance at 5 lux ambient illumination.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Limited Color Palette: Only five text colors were tested, and the study did not explore the full spectrum of colors or variations in background color beyond pure black.
  • Restricted Ambient Illumination Range: The tested levels of ambient illumination (0, 5, 10 lux) were limited, potentially preventing a full understanding of the interactive effects across a wider range.
  • Objective Measures: The study relied solely on eye movement data for objective measures. Incorporating EEG data could provide a more comprehensive understanding of visual fatigue.

Future work could involve:

  • Expanding color research to include dynamic content like animations and videos.
  • Investigating a broader range of ambient illumination levels.
  • Utilizing advanced analytical tools and multi-channel EEG to more accurately measure visual fatigue and cognitive effects.
  • Developing adaptive interfaces that adjust color schemes based on ambient illumination to optimize user experience.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study investigates the effects of ambient illumination and negatively polarized text color on visual fatigue, exploring the issue of visual fatigue when using visual display terminals in low-illumination environments. The research methodology utilized an experimental design to collect data on changes in pupil accommodation and blink rate through an eye tracker. Partici-pants completed a reading task while exposed to various text colors and ambient light conditions to evaluate visual fatigue and cognitive performance. The study's findings suggest that text color significantly affects visual fatigue, with red text causing the highest level of visual fatigue and yellow text causing the lowest level of visual fatigue. Improvements in ambient lighting reduce visual fatigue, but the degree of improvement varies depending on the text color. Additionally, cognitive performance is better when using yellow and white text but worse when using red text. Yellow text is the most effective choice for reducing visual fatigue under negative polarity. In-creasing ambient lighting can also improve visual fatigue in low-illumination conditions. These findings will offer valuable guidance for designing visual terminal device interfaces, especially for low-illumination or night environments, to minimize visual fatigue and improve the user ex-perience.
BibTeX
@misc{fan2024effect,
  author = {Qiangqiang Fan and Jinhan Xie and Zhaoyang Dong and Yang Wang},
  title = {{The Effect of Ambient Illumination and Text Color on Visual Fatigue under Negative Polarity}},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/s24113516},
}

Loading related content...

Figure