The durability of flexible eddy current array (FECA) sensors in harsh service environments

Yujian Song, Tao Chen, Ronghong Cui, Yuting He, Xianghong Fan, Binlin MaScientific 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Sensors for structural health monitoring (SHM) must be permanently integrated into structures and withstand harsh service environments, a significant challenge for aircraft applications. This paper investigates the durability of flexible eddy current array (FECA) sensors under extreme conditions, including intense vibration, salt fog corrosion, fluid immersion, and combined hygrothermal/ultraviolet radiation. We propose a robust integration method using aviation sealant and validate sensor performance through both finite element analysis and experimental testing. Results demonstrate that integrated FECA sensors maintain signal stability and structural integrity across all tested environments, successfully monitoring fatigue cracks even after prolonged exposure. This research provides critical evidence supporting the engineering application of FECA sensors for long-term aircraft structural health monitoring.

Introduction

Structural Health Monitoring (SHM) represents a paradigm shift in aviation maintenance, moving from scheduled inspections to real-time, sensor-based condition monitoring. Flexible eddy current array (FECA) sensors are particularly promising for detecting fatigue cracks around critical structural features like bolt holes. However, the transition from laboratory success to operational reliability is hindered by the brutal environments aircraft endure: constant vibration, corrosive coastal air, exposure to jet fuels and hydraulic fluids, and intense UV radiation at high altitudes. If a sensor delaminates or its signal drifts due to environmental degradation, the SHM system becomes a liability rather than an asset. This study addresses the fundamental challenge of ensuring sensor durability and functional integrity in these harsh service environments.

Sensor Design and Integration Strategy

The core of this study is an annular FECA sensor designed to monitor crack initiation and growth around fastener holes. The sensor is constructed as a flexible circuit using polyimide (PI) as the substrate and copper for the drive and sense windings.

Schematic and physical representation of the annular FECA sensor showing the multi-channel layout for crack detection.

A critical innovation presented is the integration method. Traditional brittle adhesives often fail under the thermal and mechanical cycling typical of aerospace structures. Instead, this research utilizes HM109 aviation sealant, an elastomer that remains flexible after curing. This sealant serves a dual purpose: it acts as a high-strength adhesive and forms a protective "skin" over the sensor, shielding the polyimide and copper layers from chemical ingress and mechanical wear.

The integration process of the FECA sensor onto the structure under testing using a protective sealant layer.

Experimental Methodology

To rigorously test the sensor's limits, the researchers employed a two-pronged approach: vibration analysis and accelerated environmental aging.

Vibration Durability

Using Finite Element Method (FEM) modal analysis, the team identified the resonance frequencies of the test specimens. They specifically targeted the 4th order vibration mode (1005 Hz), which creates the highest stress concentrations at the sensor mounting location. By subjecting the integrated sensors to $10^7$ cycles at this resonance, they simulated the most severe vibration loads an aircraft component might experience.

Environmental Exposure

Sensors were subjected to standardized accelerated aging protocols:

  • Salt Fog: 600 hours of concentrated corrosive spray (GB/T 10125-2012).
  • Fluid Immersion: A sequential 1,300-hour soak (800 hours in RP-5 jet fuel followed by 500 hours in hydraulic oil).
  • Hygrothermal/UV: 600 hours at 80 °C and 95% humidity under 340 nm UV radiation.

Following exposure, the sensors underwent functional validation on an MTS810 fatigue testing machine to ensure they could still accurately track real-time crack growth in 2024-T351 aluminum alloy specimens.

Key Results and Discussion

The experimental results confirm the high durability of the FECA sensor and its integration method:

  • Signal Stability: During vibration testing, output signal variation remained within 1%, with no evidence of debonding or fatigue failure in the sensor itself.
  • Environmental Resilience: Despite the aluminum specimens themselves suffering significant corrosion in salt fog tests, the sensors remained perfectly bonded and functional. The aviation sealant effectively prevented delamination and chemical degradation of the polyimide substrate.
  • Functional Integrity: Post-exposure fatigue tests demonstrated that the sensors could still identify crack initiation and growth with high precision. For example, in salt-fog-exposed samples, the sensors accurately flagged crack lengths (e.g., 1mm, 2mm, 3.2mm) by reaching predicted signal inflection points.
  • Material Durability: Neither the sealant nor the PI substrate showed signs of embrittlement or loss of adhesion after 600 hours of intense UV and thermal stress.

Conclusion

This study demonstrates that FECA sensors, when integrated with specialized aviation sealants, can survive and function reliably in the harshest environments typical of aircraft service. The transition from rigid adhesives to flexible, protective sealants is a key factor in this success. While future work should explore the synergistic effects of combined stressors and the impact of sealant thickness on sensor sensitivity, these results provide a robust foundation for the deployment of FECA sensors in real-world aerospace SHM applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

Sensors for structural health monitoring (SHM) need to be permanently integrated on structures and withstand the harsh service environments, which has been a big challenge for the application of SHM in aircrafts. This paper focuses on the durability of flexible eddy current array (FECA) sensors in harsh service environments of aircrafts, including vibration environment and several typical exposed environments. First, a kind of FECA sensor is illustrated and its integration method is proposed. Moreover, in order to study the durability of the sensor in vibration environment, the modal analysis is performed by the finite element method. According to the simulation results, the durability experiment in vibration environment is carried out under the fourth order vibration mode, which makes the sensor suffer the harshest vibration loads. During the vibration experiment, output signals of the sensor keep stable and the sensor is well bonded to the structure, which shows the integrated sensor has high durability in vibration environment. Finally, the durability of integrated sensors is separately tested in three exposed environments, including salt fog corrosion environment, fluid immersion environment, as well as hygrothermal and ultraviolet-radiation environment. After these environmental exposure experiments, all sensors are well bonded to structures and can effectively monitor fatigue cracks, which shows great durability. Therefore, FECA sensors can survive in harsh service environments of aircrafts, which provides important support for the engineering applications of FECA sensors.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{song2021durability,
  author = {Yujian Song and Tao Chen and Ronghong Cui and Yuting He and Xianghong Fan and Binlin Ma},
  title = {{The durability of flexible eddy current array (FECA) sensors in harsh service environments}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-021-89750-y},
}
Figure