Abstract
We examine the 'diboson' excess at $\sim 2$ TeV seen by the LHC experiments in various channels. We provide a comparison of the excess significances as a function of the mass of the tentative resonance and give the signal cross sections needed to explain the excesses. We also present a survey of available theoretical explanations of the resonance, classified in three main approaches. Beyond that, we discuss methods to verify the anomaly, determining the major properties of the various surpluses and exploring how different models can be discriminated. Finally, we give a tabular summary of the numerous explanations, presenting their main phenomenological features.
Introduction
In 2015, the particle physics community was abuzz with reports of "bumps" in the data from the Large Hadron Collider (LHC). Both the ATLAS and CMS experiments observed a surplus of events when searching for heavy resonances decaying into pairs of vector bosons ($WW$, $WZ$, $ZZ$) at an invariant mass of about 2 TeV. While no single result was statistically significant enough to claim a discovery, the fact that multiple independent searches saw similar excesses in the same energy range was highly suggestive of "New Physics." This paper serves as a "pre-proceeding" for the Les Houches workshop, aiming to synthesize the experimental situation and provide a taxonomy for the theoretical models attempting to explain the signal.
Experimental Evidence at 2 TeV
The study relies on publicly available results from LHC Run 1 (8 TeV collisions), including all-hadronic, semi-leptonic, and fully leptonic final states, as well as Higgs-associated searches ($WH$, $ZH$). By digitizing limit plots, the authors extracted observed significances (in units of standard deviation, $\sigma$) as a function of resonance mass.
As shown in the figure above, overlapping excesses were found across multiple channels in the 1.8–2.0 TeV region. Peak local significances reached approximately $3\sigma$ in some ATLAS hadronic searches. The signal cross-sections required to explain these anomalies range from roughly 1 to 100 fb, depending on the specific channel and experiment.
Theoretical Taxonomy and Production Mechanisms
The paper classifies theoretical explanations into three main categories:
- Strongly Coupled Dynamics: Composite Higgs models where the resonance is a "rho-like" bound state of a new strong force.
- Enlarged Gauge Groups: Models like Left-Right Symmetry that predict new heavy gauge bosons ($W'$ and $Z'$).
- Extended Higgs Sectors: Scenarios like the Two-Higgs Doublet Model (2HDM) where a heavy neutral scalar mimics the diboson signal.
A major insight comes from the simplified model analysis of production modes. The authors demonstrate that if the 2 TeV resonance were produced primarily via Vector Boson Fusion (VBF), the required branching ratio would often have to be greater than 1 to match the observed cross-section—a physical impossibility.
This strongly suggests that the resonance is likely produced via quark-antiquark ($q\bar{q}$) annihilation rather than VBF.
Conclusion and the Run 2 Arbiter
The authors acknowledge that the "excess" might simply be a coincidence of statistical fluctuations or influenced by experimental resolution issues, such as the difficulty in perfectly distinguishing between $W$ and $Z$ bosons in boosted topologies.
However, the transition to Run 2 (13 TeV) provides a definitive test. At higher energies, the production cross-section for a 2 TeV particle increases by a factor of 5 to 7. This makes Run 2 the ultimate arbiter: the signal should either become a clear discovery or vanish as a statistical fluke. The paper concludes with a roadmap of 12 specific studies for Run 2 to discriminate between models, including measuring resonance widths and analyzing angular distributions to determine spin.
Summary updated