Squark-mediated Higgs+jets production at the LHC

J. Duarte, C. Peña, A. Wang, M. Pierini, M. SpiropuluarXiv 2017 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We investigate possible scenarios of light-squark production at the LHC as a new mechanism to produce Higgs bosons in association with jets. The study is motivated by the SUSY search for H+jets events, performed by the CMS collaboration on 8 and 13 TeV data using the razor variables. Two simplified models are proposed to interpret the observations in this search. The constraint from Run I and the implications for Run II and beyond are discussed.

Introduction

In the hunt for physics beyond the Standard Model, "Natural Supersymmetry" (SUSY) suggests that certain particles, like the top and bottom squarks (stops and sbottoms), should be relatively light to stabilize the Higgs boson's mass against quantum corrections. While the LHC has not yet found a definitive "smoking gun" for SUSY, the CMS collaboration reported a $2.9\sigma$ local excess in their 8 TeV data when looking for Higgs bosons produced with high-momentum jets using "razor variables."

This study addresses the gap between these experimental observations and theoretical models by proposing specific sbottom production processes that could explain this "bump" in the data without violating other known constraints.

Simplified Models for Sbottom Production

The authors propose two simplified models involving bottom squarks to explain the observed excess. These models provide a natural mechanism for producing Higgs bosons in association with jets and missing transverse energy (from neutralinos).

Decay topologies and Feynman diagrams for the proposed simplified sbottom models: Model A (left) and Model B (right).
  • Model A (Asymmetric): A heavy sbottom ($\tilde{b}_2$) and a light sbottom ($\tilde{b}_1$) are produced. The heavy one decays into a Higgs and a neutralino (the dark matter candidate), while the light one decays directly to a bottom quark and a neutralino.
  • Model B (Symmetric): Two sbottoms are produced, both eventually decaying into Higgs bosons and neutralinos. This model proved to be a robust way to interpret the data and was later adopted by the CMS collaboration for their 13 TeV results.

Methodology

The study utilizes a "re-interpretation" approach, building a high-fidelity simulation of the CMS experiment to test these new theories.

  1. Simulation Pipeline: Proton-proton collisions were simulated using PYTHIA 8, while DELPHES 3 was used to emulate the CMS detector response. Particles were grouped into jets using FastJet.
  2. Razor Variables: The analysis utilizes "razor variables" ($M_R$ and $R^2$), which are designed to characterize the heavy mass scale of new particles and the presence of invisible particles like dark matter.
  3. Statistical Inference: A Bayesian framework was employed to calculate the significance of the models, comparing the likelihood of the data given the SUSY model versus the Standard Model alone.

Key Results

The analysis demonstrates that sbottom production is a viable candidate for the observed events. Model B with a sbottom mass of approximately 500 GeV provided the best fit to the 8 TeV excess, yielding a combined significance of 1.8$\sigma$.

95% CL upper limit on the cross section for Model B as a function of sbottom mass, compared to NLO+NLL theory predictions.

The "best-fit" signal cross-section was found to be roughly 0.4 pb, aligning well with theoretical predictions. The study determined that sbottom masses below 330 GeV are excluded by the 8 TeV data for neutralino masses of $m_{\tilde{\chi}_1^0} = 100$ GeV. Validation showed that the emulated limits closely matched official CMS limits, proving the accuracy of the simulation pipeline.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors note that their fast simulation (DELPHES) has a slightly worse photon energy resolution than the real CMS detector, requiring a doubling of background uncertainties. Additionally, the study assumes 100% branching ratios for certain decay chains, which might be more complex in a full SUSY model.

While the bulk of the detailed fitting is on 8 TeV data, the authors suggest that higher-energy data from Run II and Run III will be the ultimate arbiter of whether these sbottom models are correct or if the 8 TeV excess was simply a statistical fluke.

Summary updated

Abstract

We investigate possible scenarios of light-squark production at the LHC as a new mechanism to produce Higgs bosons in association with jets. The study is motivated by the SUSY search for H+jets events, performed by the CMS collaboration on 8 and 13 TeV data using the razor variables. Two simplified models are proposed to interpret the observations in this search. The constraint from Run I and the implications for Run II and beyond are discussed.
BibTeX
@misc{duarte2017squark,
  author = {J. Duarte and C. Peña and A. Wang and M. Pierini and M. Spiropulu},
  title = {{Squark-mediated Higgs+jets production at the LHC}},
  year = {2017},
  eprint = {1703.06544},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1703.06544},
}
Figure