The Cross-national Comparative Study of the Maintenance Time of Granted Patents in the Technical Field of Fixed Constructions in Different Countries

Jun Shen, Yongzhong Qiao2015 · DOI

Abstract

The maintenance information of granted patents in the technical field of fixed constructions in China, Germany, France, and Japan are empirically analyzed, which shows that there are many differences in the maintenance time of the patents granted by them. The mean value maintenance time in the technical field of fixed constructions is shorter than that of other technical fields. In the technical field of fixed constructions, the maintenance time of patents granted by France is longer than that of patents granted by China, Germany and Japan; the maintenance time of patents granted by China is the shortest; the maintenance tendencies of granted patents are greatly various in different periods. As the maintenance time extends, the number of patents falls dramatically in China, but in Germany, the number of the patents falls gradually. Large proportion of patents granted by France and Japan are distributed in long maintenance periods.

Introduction

In the global construction market, technical strength is the primary driver of competitive advantage. While the number of patents granted is a common metric for innovation, it is often a "vanity metric" that ignores quality. Patent maintenance time—how long an owner continues to pay fees to keep a patent active—serves as a more accurate proxy for a patent's economic and technical value. If a patent isn't generating profit or protecting a vital innovation, the owner will let it lapse. This study addresses the lack of cross-national comparative data specifically within the "fixed constructions" field (IPC Category E), seeking to reveal the true competitive status of four industrial giants: China, Germany, France, and Japan.

Methods

The researchers conducted an empirical, longitudinal analysis of patent lifecycles using a cohort of patents granted in 1994. This timeframe ensures that by 2014, every patent had either reached its maximum legal term or had been terminated early. The study utilized a custom database derived from national patent office records, totaling 15,352 patents (3,838 from each country). Patents were selected "equidistantly" from the larger pools of German, French, and Japanese grants to match the Chinese volume for that specific year. Statistical analysis focused on mean maintenance times, standard deviations, and distribution proportions across seven distinct time intervals.

Results and Analysis

The analysis reveals that the "fixed constructions" sector generally experiences shorter patent maintenance lives compared to fields like chemistry or electricity. However, significant differences emerge when comparing the four nations.

Maintenance Curve Archetypes

The study identified unique "shapes" for how patents lapse in each country, as illustrated in the distribution curves.

Distribution of patent maintenance periods across four countries.
  • China (The "Slope"): A dramatic drop-off where nearly 80% of patents are abandoned before year 9.
  • Germany (The "Step Plate"): A gradual, irregular decline.
  • France (The "Hump Yard"): Fluctuating maintenance with a high concentration of long-lived patents.
  • Japan (The "Trapezium"): A stable middle period where most patents stay active, with few dropped early or kept until the absolute end.

Comparative Statistics

Quantitative results confirm these trends. France holds the longest average maintenance time in this field, while China trails significantly.

Comparative statistics of patent maintenance time and technical field distribution.

As shown in the data summary, the mean lifespan for French patents is 10.29 years, compared to 9.25 for Japan, 7.95 for Germany, and 6.16 for China. Furthermore, 48.7% of French patents are maintained for more than 10 years, whereas 36.14% of Chinese patents last 3 years or less. Japan demonstrated the most consistent maintenance behavior, evidenced by the lowest standard deviation (3.28), suggesting a highly standardized approach to patent portfolio management.

Discussion and Conclusion

The shorter maintenance time in China is attributed to a "technical accumulation gap." While Chinese firms have grown rapidly, they often lack the deep-rooted patent management experience and "patent awareness" found in older European and Japanese firms. Interestingly, China's relatively lower maintenance fees do not prevent early abandonment, reinforcing the idea that the quality of the underlying innovation—not just the cost—drives maintenance decisions.

A primary limitation is the reliance on a 1994 cohort. While necessary for a full lifecycle view, it may not reflect the modern landscape of Chinese innovation. Future research should involve survival analysis on more recent cohorts to determine if the gap in maintenance time is closing as Chinese firms mature in international commercial operations.

Summary updated

Abstract

The maintenance information of granted patents in the technical field of fixed constructions in China, Germany, France, and Japan are empirically analyzed, which shows that there are many differences in the maintenance time of the patents granted by them. The mean value maintenance time in the technical field of fixed constructions is shorter than that of other technical fields. In the technical field of fixed constructions, the maintenance time of patents granted by France is longer than that of patents granted by China, Germany and Japan; the maintenance time of patents granted by China is the shortest; the maintenance tendencies of granted patents are greatly various in different periods. As the maintenance time extends, the number of patents falls dramatically in China, but in Germany, the number of the patents falls gradually. Large proportion of patents granted by France and Japan are distributed in long maintenance periods.
BibTeX
@misc{shen2015cross,
  author = {Jun Shen and Yongzhong Qiao},
  title = {{The Cross-national Comparative Study of the Maintenance Time of Granted Patents in the Technical Field of Fixed Constructions in Different Countries}},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.2991/emeeit-15.2015.38},
}
Figure