Research on the Relationship between Maintenance Time and Examination Time of Patents

Yongzhong Qiao, Hao Peng2016 · DOI

Abstract

Based on the maintenance and examination information of 3,838 patents granted in 1994 by SIPO, this paper analyzes the factors influencing patent longevity. Findings indicate that maintenance time is negatively correlated with examination time. Most patents are maintained for 1–3 years, while examination typically lasts 2–5 years. Notably, an examination period of approximately 4 years correlates with longer maintenance times compared to other durations. The study explores these trends through the lenses of protection periods, financing policies, market conditions, and the patent censorship system, concluding with suggestions to extend patent maintenance.

Introduction

While China has experienced a surge in patent applications, the quality of these patents—often measured by their maintenance time—remains a concern. Maintenance time refers to the duration an owner pays annual fees to keep a patent active. In China, many patents are abandoned shortly after being granted, contrasting with the decade-plus lifespans common in the US or Japan. This research investigates whether the examination time (the duration from application to grant) directly impacts this lifespan, potentially "eating" into the patent's commercial viability.

Methodology

The study utilizes a retrospective statistical analysis of 3,838 invention patents granted by the State Intellectual Property Office (SIPO) of China in 1994. This cohort allows for a full 20-year lifecycle tracking through 2014. The analysis includes comparative studies with international patent offices (USPTO, JPO, etc.) and linear regression to identify macro and micro trends in patent data.

The Inverse Relationship of Time

A critical factor in the Chinese patent system is that the 20-year protection term begins at the date of application. Consequently, every year spent in examination is a year of protection lost. This creates a zero-sum game where longer examinations inherently limit the maximum possible maintenance time.

Figure 1: Percentage of patents maintained for over 10 and 15 years relative to examination time.

As shown in Figure 1, there is a clear downward trend: as examination time increases, the percentage of patents maintained for long durations (10+ or 15+ years) decreases significantly. Notably, if an examination takes longer than 6 years, the probability of a patent being maintained for 15 years or more drops to zero.

The Four-Year "Sweet Spot"

Despite the general negative correlation, the data reveals a non-linear "sweet spot." Patents that undergo an examination period of roughly 4 years tend to have the longest maintenance periods.

Figure 3: Patent numbers by maintenance time (11-19 years) categorized by examination duration.

Figure 3 illustrates this clustering. Patents with a 4-year examination time (the purple line) show a significant peak in maintenance at the 16-year mark, with a higher volume of patents reaching this age compared to other examination durations. This suggests that a 4-year period may represent an optimal balance between rigorous examination (ensuring patent quality) and timely market entry. Conversely, very long examination times (6–9 years) often result in market obsolescence, where the technology is outdated by the time the patent is granted, removing any financial incentive for maintenance.

Policy and Market Factors

The study also identifies systemic issues, such as the "Crap Patent" loophole. Government subsidies and fee reductions often incentivize low-quality filings. These patents are typically maintained only as long as they are cheap; once tiered annual fees increase, they are abandoned. Furthermore, the lack of professional competence among some censors can lead to "indefinite delays," further shortening the effective life of valuable innovations.

Conclusion and Recommendations

To improve patent quality and longevity, the authors suggest:

  • Legal Reform: Establishing maximum examination durations in patent law.
  • Examiner Training: Enhancing the efficiency and rigor of substantive examinations.
  • Subsidy Adjustment: Shifting focus from filing volume to high-value innovation support.

While limited by its focus on the 1994 cohort, this study provides a foundational understanding of how bureaucratic efficiency directly dictates the commercial value of intellectual property.

Summary updated

Abstract

Based on the maintenance and examination information of granted 3838 patents in 1994 by SIPO, this paper draws some conclusions after concrete analysis. Firstly, the maintenance time is negatively related to the examination time. Secondly, the maintenance times of most patents are 1-3 years and the examination times of most patents are 2-5 years. Thirdly, when the examination time of a patent is between 2 years and 5 years, the maintenance time of this patent will be longer, especially in 4 years, compared to other examination time. Then, this paper researches the reasons of above conclusions from the point of patent protection period, the financing policy, the market conditions and the patent censor system. In the end, this paper makes suggestions how to extend maintenance time of patent.
BibTeX
@misc{qiao2016research,
  author = {Yongzhong Qiao and Hao Peng},
  title = {{Research on the Relationship between Maintenance Time and Examination Time of Patents}},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.2991/icemct-16.2016.242},
}
Figure