Abstract
The defect relaxation volumes obtained from density-functional theory (DFT) calculations of charged vacancies and interstitials are much larger than their neutral counterparts, seemingly unphysically large. In this work, we investigate the possible reasons for this and revisit the methods that address the calculation of charged defect structures in periodic DFT. We probe the dependence of the proposed energy corrections to charged defect formation energies on relaxation volumes and find that corrections such as the image charge correction and the alignment correction, which can lead to sizable changes in defect formation energies, have an almost negligible effect on the charged defect relaxation volume. We also investigate the volume for the net neutral defect reactions comprised of individual charged defects, and find that the aggregate formation volumes have reasonable magnitudes. This work highlights an important issue that, as for defect formation energies, the defect formation volumes depend on the choice of reservoir. We show that considering the change in volume of the electron reservoir in the formation reaction of the charged defects, analogous to how volumes of atoms are accounted for in defect formation volumes, can renormalize the formation volumes of charged defects such that they are comparable to neutral defects. This approach enables the description of the elastic properties of isolated charged defects within the overall neutral material, beyond the context of the overall defect reactions that produce the charged defect.
Introduction: The Relaxation Volume Conundrum
In materials science, defects like vacancies and interstitials are fundamental to understanding properties such as diffusion and mechanical strength. When a defect forms, the surrounding crystal lattice distorts, a change quantified as the relaxation volume ($\Delta \Omega^r$). This parameter is critical for predicting how defects interact with external stress and internal strain fields.
However, researchers using Density Functional Theory (DFT) have long faced a "conundrum": the relaxation volumes calculated for charged defects in semiconductors and insulators are often an order of magnitude larger than those of their neutral counterparts. For instance, in Uranium Dioxide ($UO_2$), a neutral uranium vacancy has a relaxation volume of approximately $-9 \text{ \AA}^3$, while the same vacancy with a $4-$ charge exhibits a massive $+40.5 \text{ \AA}^3$ expansion. These values seem unphysically large and lead to unrealistic predictions of defect-strain interactions.
Investigating Potential Culprits
To resolve this, the authors investigated whether these large volumes were artifacts of finite-size effects or deficiencies in standard correction schemes. They focused on three prototypical systems: Uranium Dioxide ($UO_2$), Silicon (Si), and Gallium Arsenide (GaAs), representing different types of charge localization.
A common approach to correcting charged defect calculations is the Freysoldt-Neugebauer-Van de Walle (FNV) scheme, which addresses image-charge interactions and potential alignment. While these corrections are vital for accurate formation energies, the study found they have a negligible impact on the relaxation volumes.
As shown in the figure above, applying the alignment correction shifts the formation enthalpy curve vertically but does not significantly move the minimum along the volume axis. This confirms that the "unphysical" volumes are a real feature of the DFT potential energy surface, not a numerical error in the correction schemes.
The Solution: The Electron Reservoir Volume
The breakthrough came from revisiting the thermodynamics of defect formation. In a charged defect calculation, electrons are exchanged with a reservoir (typically the Fermi level). Just as we account for the volume of atoms moved to a chemical reservoir when calculating formation volumes, we must also account for the volume change of the electron reservoir ($\Delta \Omega^{ref}$).
When an electron is added to a bulk crystal, it causes the entire lattice to expand or contract due to changes in bonding or electronic pressure. This "carrier-induced" volume change is often ignored in standard defect volume definitions. By defining a renormalized formation volume that includes this reservoir term, the authors found that the properties of individual charged defects become physically sensible and comparable to neutral ones.
Key Results and Implications
- Renormalization: For the $V_U^{4-}$ vacancy in $UO_2$, accounting for the reservoir volume (calculated as $-11.6 \text{ \AA}^3$ per unit charge) reduces the effective relaxation volume from $+40.5 \text{ \AA}^3$ to a much more reasonable $-6.02 \text{ \AA}^3$.
- Aggregate Consistency: In charge-neutral reactions, such as the formation of a Frenkel pair, these large individual volume terms naturally cancel out. This explains why experimental measurements of aggregate defect populations never encountered these extreme values.
- Broad Applicability: The study demonstrates that this renormalization is necessary regardless of whether the charge is localized (as in $UO_2$ polarons) or delocalized (as in Si or GaAs bands).
Conclusion
This work resolves a long-standing puzzle in the first-principles modeling of defects. By identifying the missing thermodynamic term—the electron reservoir volume—the authors provide a consistent framework for calculating the elastic properties of isolated charged defects. This enables more accurate multiscale modeling of materials under stress, where the interactions of individual charged defects play a crucial role.
Summary updated